3 ms·
>> The QR code is used to initialize a direct (encrypted) bluetooth / wifi direct connection. Taking a picture of the QR code isn't enough to get the one-time p
by Nursie 12y ago
>> The QR code is used to initialize a direct (encrypted) bluetooth / wifi direct connection. Taking a picture of the QR code isn't enough to get the one-time pad.
If, as the article says, the QR code gives a symmetric AES key, then yes it could well be enough to get the OTP if you've eavesdropped on the traffic as well.
>> But there is no discussion of these points so far. Everybody is just piling hate on the product for its failings. We need to be better than that if we want a secure app ecosystem.
What we need to be better at is recognising that "Hey, look at my brand-new awesome crypto-system!" is a huge red flag, and what we should be looking for is "Hey, we're using tried and tested protocol X, which we're pretty confident about".
From an app-writer's perspective I can see why they want to announce that they've made this awesome new security system - they want to differentiate themselves, and security is in the public eye right now so seems to be a selling point. Human nature being what it is, new and shiny is eye-catching and good for sales. But we really want pretty much the opposite here.