5 ms·
You also have to ask whether a lack of the door lock would have prevented the crash. Can a rogue pilot crash the plane fast enough that the door locks are irre
by saalweachter 12y ago
You also have to ask whether a lack of the door lock would have prevented the crash. Can a rogue pilot crash the plane fast enough that the door locks are irrelevant? Can he crash it while the other pilot is in the cockpit? I remember other black box recordings from another crash where one pilot was merely confused, steering the plane into a crash while the others tried to save it, and no one realized what was going on until it was too late.
- StavrosK 12y agoThat was the Air France flight, and it strikes me as a major UX disaster. The flight sticks' input was averaged, as if that's ever a desirable scenario! "Oh yeah, we know we want to keep it level, so you pull back on the stick a bit, I'll push it an equal amount and we'll be okay." Yeeeah.
- richardkmichael 12y agoThis not how simultaneous side-stick input works. Conflicting inputs are rejected with a warning ; dual input is also indicated with a warning. Non-conflicting inputs are summed, to model the way traditional centre sticks/yokes would work, when both pilots are acting. Generally, due to procedure, only one pilot is controlling the aircraft at any time; and, there is a "hand-off" to pass the control between them. There is a priority override button on each side-stick to take control from the other pilot. However, a potential problem with side-sticks arises because the sticks are independent -- the non-controlling stick does not mirror (i.e., no force feedback) the controlling stick movement, as would happen with the mechanically connected centre sticks/yokes. Meaning, the non-controlling pilot cannot tell what the controlling pilot is doing. This was the problem on AF447. If you read the CVR log, one pilot was confused about how to handle the situation and, unfortunately, he took control several times during the recovery attempt. In the final seconds, he verbally states he is pulling back on the stick (attempting to climb), which revealed to the [then returned to the cockpit] captain what he was doing, but there was not enough time to correct (forward, nose down) to exit the stall before they struck the ocean surface. (The stall warning itself was another disastrous UX problem as well, in my opinion.)
- StavrosK 12y agoHmm, so there was no averaging? One of the pilots just took control? Completely agreed about the stall warning as well, I just didn't mention it. Don't warn about stalls unless there's actually danger of stalling!