2 ms·
> This killed the basic advantage of RISC. The "all instructions the same length" concept really killed it - it meant 2x code bloat. That meant bigger caches or
by pcwalton 12y ago
> This killed the basic advantage of RISC. The "all instructions the same length" concept really killed it - it meant 2x code bloat. That meant bigger caches or worse cache performance. It meant more RAM and more RAM bandwidth or worse memory performance. The x86 instruction set, for all its faults, is compact.
I'm not really sure that is a big deal today, however. Maybe it was when caches were much smaller, but AArch64 went back from a variable width encoding scheme (Thumb) to uniform width instructions in 64-bit mode, without any problems that I'm aware of, and the performance is quite good. At the same time, the x86-64 ISA has gotten quite a bit less space-efficient: because of the extension to 16 registers, REX prefixes are everywhere and eat up lots of bytes of the instruction stream.