7 ms·
In the United States articles have been bemoaning the loss of our topsoil since the 1930s. They seem to follow a template. We need our soil; we'll die without
by CapitalistCartr 12y ago
In the United States articles have been bemoaning the loss of our topsoil since the 1930s. They seem to follow a template. We need our soil; we'll die without it. Then explaining the rate we're losing it at; how much we have left, finishing with dire warnings.
My parents were farmers. We haven't depended on topsoil to fill our collective larder since those 1930s. We add nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and various minor minerals.
Nitrogen made from and by the petroleum industry. We use it to grow corn, a heavy feeder, turn that corn into a gasoline additive and pretend it's green. Phosphates are dug from the ground a few miles from where I live by giant drag lines. We use petrochemicals to compensate for massive mono-cropping and now we have gene-splicing. The soil? It's just a grow medium for petro-food.
Anyone who still pretends our modern cornucopia is the fruit of the soil is being willfully ignorant.
- scottshepard 12y agoI believe that erosion is a bigger issue than loss of nutrients. For example, Iowa has lost an estimated 10 inches of topsoil in the last 150 years. There are only six inches left. Dust-covered bedrock does not make good farmland.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoI am definitely not a fan of our current system, but your post illustrates the problem. Under that topsoil is meters of subsoil before the bedrock. The current agri-corps can continue to play the chemistry set game with our food for another century or more if we let them. The rise of "Roundup Ready" crops is helping to eradicate the monarch butterfly. Multiple articles about the plight of the honeybee have been posted to HN. These are externalities to their profits unless and until we change that.
- daeken 12y ago> The rise of "Roundup Ready" crops is helping to eradicate the monarch butterfly. This is true, but it's significantly less direct than the news stories have indicated. The issue is that Roundup is being used to eliminate milkweed, which are essential for monarch butterflies. It's not Roundup or Roundup Ready crops that are harming monarch butterflies, but what they're being used to eliminate.
- sophacles 12y agoRight, it's like when you don't give a person food. You aren't harming him - his own body is doing that as a secondary effect of simple food denial. These distinctions are important.
- ambler0 12y agoI'm all for correcting oversimplified news stories, but I don't understand why you call this "significantly less direct". As far as I can see, it's exactly one step less direct, i.e. as close as you can get without killing them directly. As you say, milkweed is essential for them. It's literally the only plant this species lays its eggs upon.
- daeken 12y agoIt's significantly less direct because Roundup has no effect on the Monarch butterflies. The issue is the way it's being used by farmers. If it were not being used to eliminate milkweed, there would be no effect whatsoever on the butterfly populations. We would have the same problem with absolutely any other herbicide.
- joshuapants 12y agoOr if milkweed were replanted in other areas still within the Monarchs' path but not mixed in with the crops. Many towns have butterfly gardens, but something on a larger scale would work too.
- daeken 12y agoI wonder what kind of scale you would need to make this work? I'd be curious to see numbers on it, and whether or not it's feasible; definitely a great option if so!
- ambler0 12y agoIn any case, it doesn't hurt to try and grow some milkweed in one's own yard, which many of us in my area do.
- cplease 12y agoSo what? Is biodynamic farming going to feed 10B people? The free-marketers and the greens are by and large ignoring the elephant in the room: unsustainable human population growth. Technology is reaching the limit as far as pie-slicing goes. Virtually every single macro problem facing the planet is exacerbated by overpopulation.
- briantakita 12y ago> So what? Is biodynamic farming going to feed 10B people? Natural polyculture methods have higher yields than chemical monoculture methods. There will be less of a particular type of corn or soybean, but more food overall. Though some farmers, such as Masanobu Fukuoka was able to have significantly higher rice yields (& even more overall food of different types) using natural polyculture methods than chemical monoculture methods. Note that permaculture is of a different tradition than biodynamic farming. Both are good in their appropriate usages. Appropriate for the climate, land, water context, etc.
- cplease 12y agoReally? So, we go from, say, 450M agriculture waged workers today, to 2 billion. Or 3 billion. Or 5. Slaving away with hoes on their tiny biodynamic farmsteads . Problem solved, 10 billion fed (although living in abject circumstances, ignoring pollution etc. here). Let's take it to 15 billion people. What does the planet earth look like then? Also, I think your premise that "natural polyculture" can scale up to feeding the high 10 digits of people in anything resembling the kind of society we expect to live in is unrealistic, to say the least.
- briantakita 12y agoReally. Don't let the marketing of large chemical manufactures fool you. The UN has a report that small scale, distributed farming is more efficient & yields more food than large monoculture farms. It's been measured. http://www.technologywater.com/post/69995394390/un-report-says-small-scale-organic-farming-only http://www.technologywater.com/post/69995394390/un-report-sa... The only "disadvantage" is more people will be required to grow food. However, given the amount of people who are out of work & economically displaced, this would be a good thing. These people will be given autonomy & food sovereignty. There is historical evidence that monoculture, petrol farming does not work. Look at the "green revolution" in India. India is moving back toward natural farming techniques because they work.
- rmason 12y agoIf you want to save the soil then you can stop plowing and go no-till. Course if you go no-till you need to use more chemicals. If you want to use fewer chemicals then you need to use GMO seed. Course a loud minority doesn't want farmers to use GMO seed despite a mountain of scientific evidence that it's safe. I worked as an agronomist for twenty years. The overwhelming majority of farmers want to save the soil while balancing that with protecting the rural environment for their children. I trust them more than the hand wringing editorial writers to make the right choices.
- evjim 12y agoPermaculture is an option for notill, no chemical. Mix a variety of crops that benefit eachother. But it makes automation harder.
- graycat 12y ago> For example, Iowa has lost an estimated 10 inches of topsoil in the last 150 years. Interesting. Reference? When I was in the Midwest farming communities in Indiana and Ohio, the row crops were heavily corn, wheat, and soy beans. Then after harvest, there were lots of dead corn stalks, wheat stalks, and soy bean plants on the ground, and those plants got plowed under. Heavily those plants were carbon, and the first cut guess where the carbon came from was CO2 in the atmosphere and not from the existing soil. So, net, all the plant matter was heavily from the atmosphere and adding to the soil. So, typically annual plants, year by year, add to top soil. Indeed, it is fair to say that that was mostly the origin of the top soil. For another example, as a child, we lived in one house for about 16 years, and I got to mow the grass twice a month or so for much of that time. Well, over the 16 years, the top soil rose with respect to the concrete driveway and walkways, rose 1-2 inches. So, we added to the top soil. So, if we are losing a lot of top soil from, say, Iowa, then where it is going? Well, it could blow, but then it stands just to add to top soil in Illinois, Indiana, and Ohio, not a net loss. Or, we're carrying the top soil away via the corn kernels, wheat seeds, and soy beans themselves? Tough to believe that the seeds take more soil than the rest of the plant adds. Or the top soil could get washed into rivers which about has to be the Mississippi River. So, should be able to see all that Iowa top soil along the Mississippi River and, then, into the Gulf of Mexico. Can the USGS and Corps of Engineers find that top soil for us? I can believe that the tree cutting of the mountains in the East US by 1930 or so resulted in a lot of top soil from the mountains washing into the local valleys, but Iowa, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, etc. are nearly flat as a table, in part because at one time they were lake bottoms. I'd want to see a good and careful argument about loss of top soil in Iowa.
- selimthegrim 12y agoThat top soil is going either into the Atchafalaya or right off the continental shelf. None of it is hanging around the delta anymore.
- carapace 12y agoToby Hemenway gave a great lecture at Nicholas School of the Environment at Duke University, and he specifically talks about how we have "made people out of oil" for the last few generations. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nLKHYHmPbo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nLKHYHmPbo
- chongli 12y agoWe add nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and various minor minerals. Sure, until we run out of phosphorus[0]. [0]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peak_phosphorus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peak_phosphorus
- refurb 12y agoThis frightens me about as much as "peak oil".
- Jedd 12y agoThis comment is ambiguous in intent, but worrying in effect. Peak oil is worriesome for a variety of reasons, but peak element / mineral (or more important, exhaustion of readily available or recoverable sources of same) is much more so - there's no wind or solar equivalent for certain elements.
- dreamweapon 12y agoJust because some people maybe overhyping the risks of (accessible) resource depletion doesn't mean it isn't a valid issue.
- codingdave 12y agoSo basically, modern farmers don't have one iota of sustainability in their methods. Aren't you just strengthening the premise of the article, even if you disagree on the details?
- aaron695 12y ago> So basically, modern farmers don't have one iota of sustainability Exactly which of the above will run out in the next 1000 years? You've made a statement without any evidence. Even peak phosphorus mentioned in other comments seems as dodgy a concept as peak oil. Or do you mean they are not following the religion of mothernature knows best and using science and technology for sustainability instead.
- noodle 12y ago> Exactly which of the above will run out in the next 1000 years? Phosphorus. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095937800800099X http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959378008...
- guard-of-terra 12y ago"Nitrogen made from and by the petroleum industry" This is it. When growing food, soil and labor are not the limiting factors. Petroleum is. If you have lots of oil, you can perhaps do hypdroponics in a desert; if you don't, all your farming will need heavy subsidies to cover for its petroleum consumption. I don't expect world to care about soil until it becomes limiting factor. Call me when they resume growing grain in Siberia.
- briantakita 12y agoThank you for your anecdotal account. Many petroleum farmers suffer from soil runoff. There is also desertification. Also, there is inefficient usage of water draining the acquirers. Note that California monoculture petrol farmers are largely responsible for using nearly 80% of California's water usage. There's also habitat loss for insects & other organisms. There's also pollution of water from the excess nitrogen. There's also the poisoning of the people who eat chemical agriculture foods. Note the obesity epidemic & it's relation to the disruption of gut bacteria. Herbicides & Fungicides disrupt biological processes in humans. You mention "scare tactics". The problem is temporarily mitigated by mining & importing the nutrients. This is inefficient on fossil fuels because we are trucking in nutrients that are available with natural systems. Here's another account a farmer using natural systems to build soil. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9yPjoh9YJMk&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9yPjoh9YJMk&feature=youtu.be His yields increased & he is the most profitable farmer in his local area.