3 ms·
I don't see it as post-capitalism, just a change in what constitutes the most efficient means of production. Cuts out middlemen. If rent-seeking accounts for a
by jjoonathan 12y ago
I don't see it as post-capitalism, just a change in what constitutes the most efficient means of production. Cuts out middlemen.
If rent-seeking accounts for an increasing fraction of economic activity (a big IF, but let's assume it's true for the sake of figuring out consequences) then it will eventually surpass the inefficiencies of small-scale generalist production and we'll break into "communes." Scare quotes because there's no reason they have to be anti-technology, anti-capitalism, anti-trade, anti-government, or any of the other scary associations that follow the word around.
Especially for "unskilled" (or otherwise marginalized) labor, this sort of a model would seem to make sense. Employers would be forced to beat the value proposition of "work x days a month, do whatever you want with the remainder, your ability to secure food and shelter is guaranteed unless you screw up big time."
There's a ton of work to be done before it's a viable alternative. Hell, I bet it's even going to get VC funding someday (better to sell the shovels, right?). Neat stuff, but right now I'll just watch from the sidelines. Robotic farming (GVCS), DIY circuit board / chip manufacture, DIY chemical industry (stock up on popcorn when they get to Haber or Frank-Caro), 3D printing of structures... am I missing anything? Is there a mailing list I should be on (FBI forgive me)?
EDIT: We should talk about the big sticking point, which will be "how would one replace or compensate specialists that haven't been marginalized by capitalism yet and don't contain bunches of 'hippies,' for lack of a better word"? In other words: doctors. This is why I'm on the sidelines for now ;)
- bryanlarsen 12y ago"If rent-seeking accounts for an increasing fraction of economic activity (a big IF)" Is this really a big IF? Software revenue is technically rent (since the cost of production is 0), and that's definitely growing as a fraction of economic activity.
- jjoonathan 12y agoI tend to agree, but I've been waffling between sides and it was tangential to the argument I was interested in, so I hedged. Actually, it should be rent seeking + costs of competition. Some things are marginally important not because they serve a consumer need but because they still provide an advantage in the eternal tug-of-war. Advertising is the typical example. A DIY economy would save on some of those costs too.
- fweespeech 12y ago> Is this really a big IF? Software revenue is technically rent (since the cost of production is 0), and that's definitely growing as a fraction of economic activity. The cost of production [software engineers] is not 0. The labor of maintaining software products [sysadmins] on the internet to perform the distribution is not 0 The cost of distribution [bandwidth] requires extensive infrastructure that the owners charge for. The power, hardware, etc. for the machine is non-0 as well. > rent-seeking is expending resources on political activity to increase one's share of existing wealth without creating wealth. That is the definition I'm used to. So I'm not sure if you can really classify that as a "rent".
- zzalpha 12y agoIn what world is the cost of software production zero? You are aware software developers are paid, you know, money for services, right? To be honest, your argument, here, is exactly the trouble economists have trying to understand economic rent. Rent is to economists what pornography is to a supreme court justice: they know it when they see it. There simply is no concrete theory to define rent, and so it's extremely difficult to provide any kind of proof of increased rent seeking in modern economies without relying on personal judgment, and therefore bringing to bear personal bias. Which is, of course, why you think software is rent while someone else might not: it's in the eye of the beholder.
- bcheung 12y agoSoftware engineers are one of the highest paid professions. How does software production cost 0? Do you mean distribution?
- jchrisa 12y agoMaybe these communes can be run like social networks, so you don't even have to worry about how people smell, as long as they contribute and don't screw up big time.
- jjoonathan 12y agoThey could even compete against one another to offer better "benefits" for less work. It's a much sunnier proposition than forcing the billions of people who need to eat to compete for an ever-shrinking pool of un-automatable work, wouldn't you say?
- bcheung 12y agoFood production and food science are advancing and it will only accelerate. Currently, technologies like aquaponics allow for high volumes of nutrient rich foods to be produced with much less water and fuel inputs. In the future we may be able to print food. At that point, you don't really need to be employed to survive. An unlimited supply of food for a person will be as cheap as a stocking stuffer.