3 ms·
This is not unique to Pearson. I do grant writing for nonprofit and public agencies, and I've worked on all sorts of education projects, including numerous proj
by jseliger 12y ago
This is not unique to Pearson. I do grant writing for nonprofit and public agencies, and I've worked on all sorts of education projects, including numerous projects for school districts, Head Start, Early Head Start, and Universal Pre-Kindergarten (UPK—it's an NYC program). For most of these projects, funders require applicants to identify the curriculum(s) that'll be used. The curriculums themselves are hundreds, sometimes thousands, of pages of stuff like this:
3. The Buildings Study; (a) Investigating the Topic; Day 5; Investigation 3: What are buildings made of? What makes them strong? Vocabulary: English: Characteristics. Spanish: Caracteristicas. Large Group: Opening Routine: "Sing a song and talk about who's here." Poem: "A Building My Size." Use Might Minutes 49, "A Tree My Size."
(From The Creative Curriculum: For Preschool: Featuring the Buildings Study.)
I'll stop now. These things are always faintly ridiculous, but they're mandated, so people produce them, and others use them. I have a shelf sitting next to me.
A lot of funders will list validated curriuclums, so you have to chose from this, and only a relatively small number of companies are in the game. Those that are, from what I've heard on the grapevine, also spend a lot of money and time and energy taking people out to dinner and doing the sort of stuff you might've seen on Mad Men. It's a hard business but can also be a very profitable one.
The teachers on the front lines know all this stuff is bogus. The basics of reading, writing, and math haven't changed substantially in decades. Everyone knows that great teachers aren't great teachers because they've mastered "Common Core" or "The Buildings Society."
But most of these decisions get made deeply underground, and no one sees them. Common Core has for whatever reason become a politically popular thing to hate, but if you drill down to find each state's standards, they won't be any better.
In some ways not much has changed since Richard Feynman wrote "Judging Books by Their Covers" (http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm) decades ago. The big publishers all know this stuff. Even the Al Jazeera article is only seeing a shadow from the main event.
EDIT: For more on UPK in particular see http://blog.seliger.com/2015/01/11/trying-to-give-away-universal-pre-kindergarten-upk-or-early-head-start-ehs http://blog.seliger.com/2015/01/11/trying-to-give-away-unive.... Some outsiders are aware of how this stuff works, but it's not overtly corrupt and it's not sexy enough to be newsworthy most of the time.
- snowwrestler 12y agoEach state's standards are the Common Core. They are literally the same thing; the name "common core" simply refers to the effort to align the standards from state to state. Why? Because the basics of reading, writing, and math are the same in every state. State alignment of standards is common. You may have heard of the Uniform Commerical Code or the Uniform Building Code, which are other examples. Even the states whose governors are rejecting Common Core for political reasons are putting in place new state standards that are not substantially different from Common Core. But since national conservative organizations have latched onto the name Common Core for their fundraising, the name has become messy for conservative governors. But the concept of standards in education is still very popular. And standards are not the same thing as curricula. The standards define what students should learn; curricula define how students will learn that. The two are constantly conflated, which is not helpful to either.
- kedean 12y agoUnfortunately if you have too stringent of standards, the curriculum to teach it becomes implicitly standardized as well. If you mandate too many things, then there is no room for the teachers to make any decisions based on their knowledge of the class itself, and you may as well use a robot instead. This problem is looming right now as common core has been mandating more and more things from teachers.