3 ms·
Arguably, we should be taxing based on the value of only the land itself, and not considering improvements (buildings, etc.) made to the land, in order to not (
by ForHackernews 12y ago
Arguably, we should be taxing based on the value of only the land itself, and not considering improvements (buildings, etc.) made to the land, in order to not (mildly) disincentivize making improvements to land one owns.
- nwah1 12y agoYes, and since raw land can have a hefty unearned price tag, we already know that most of the value is left to the titleholders. It is very much like the patent debates, except even worse. At least a patentholder, in theory, might have had something to do with thinking up the idea. And at least the patent doesn't last forever Land titles are permanent, yet the titleholder had nothing whatsoever to do with the manifestation of the space and matter contained at the location.
- Symmetry 12y agoThe problem is that a large fraction of our land value is in cities and most of them have zoning restrictions that don't match classic notions of owning land. It's easy for otherwise identical pieces of land in the same neighborhood to differ in price by a factor of ten depending on whether it comes with the right to build a house on it. Well, I suppose that means that the land tax just has to incorporate different gradients of "owning" land but that's probably still simpler than trying to determine the value of improvements.
- whomonk 12y agoYou are right that assessments are based on the highest and best allowable use, but actually land assessments are the easiest part. Pennsylvanian mayors are on record that assessment changes (both technical and legal) almost completely evaporate from shifting from buildings to land.
- whomonk 12y agoYou are right that assessments are based on the highest and best allowable use, but actually land assessments are the easiest part. Pennsylvanian mayors are on record that assessment challenges (both technical and legal) almost completely evaporate from shifting from buildings to land.
- whomonk 12y agoThe main problem is much greater than that builders are discouraged from improving because of a tax on buildings. The main reason we see slums, vacant buildings, fenced lots, parking lots, and single story buildings from 1900 next to new skyscrapers is that not taxing the annual rental value actually encourages hoarding land, since the value of land increases faster than anything else and the less an owner invests in improvements, the higher rate of return from "capital" (land) appreciation will be.