3 ms·
A good tour of casual criticism of basic income. Its couched in 'if everything were the same as today' terms, ignoring other changes that would have to be made
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
A good tour of casual criticism of basic income. Its couched in 'if everything were the same as today' terms, ignoring other changes that would have to be made to implement BI nationwide.
Some issues are fake, like suggesting that different states could afford different levels of BI. Who says its a state program? That's a red herring.
Suggesting its supported by taxation is another red herring. Inflation would be slightly affected; but given that 99% of the money is hoarded by a few, what the other 1% get is actually a small piece of the pie. Inflation would be a small issue. So issuing new money to cover the BI would be a simple approach, which also serves to counter (in America at least) the huge inequalities present.
Lastly, there's irrelevant discussion of means testing to 'deserve' the BI. That shows the author must have some fundamental misunderstanding of what a Basic Income is, and it isn't a means-tested welfare benefit. Its a break from that model, by design.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI know there's resistance to the BI because the Puritan work ethic is so strong. But that's not the same as a legitimate critique of the BI.