5 ms·
Right now, the top post is about how FoundationDB got acquired and promptly taken out of circulation. This is currently 2nd, and is written with the idea of he
by davidw 12y ago
Right now, the top post is about how FoundationDB got acquired and promptly taken out of circulation.
This is currently 2nd, and is written with the idea of helping people form communities on top of a proprietary system.
Slack seems like it might be a good thing for companies, but for public stuff, I'll continue to stick with IRC.
I'll add: this site seems like a cool idea and good work by whoever created it, but I'm just averse to building on that particular foundation.
- asb 12y agoBuilding on this - what happened to Mibbit? Axod used to post on HN regularly with really impressive load and growth stats https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=axod https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=axod. It seems that after Freenode blocked it, progress rather stalled. To me, with some UI polish mibbit could very well have solved many of the IRC UI issues
- davidw 12y agoYeah, that was kind of lame on Freenode's part. There are plenty of fairly accessible IRC clients though.
- GreaterFool 12y agoI've been using a free version of irccloud.com and as far as web-based IRC clients go, it is fantastic. The paid plan is rather expensive though. $5/month for access to an IRC client is a bit much. I have a DigitalOcean VM from which I connect through irssi; I access that using Chrome Secure Shell. That's my basic setup. And $5/month per user for the team plan would quickly add up! So irccloud for work would simply be too expensive; and that's just the client. Private IRC server (as a service) won't be cheap either. Or could run it myself but then I'd also have to maintain it myself. Slack hits the sweet spot. There's nothing to maintain, the barrier to entry for non-technical people is low. The apps are great and so is the web version. It evokes the feeling of IRC and adds convenience of instant messaging (e.g. @-mentions, notifications; irccloud does mentions and notifications too which makes it really good). So yeah, Slack is a cage, but a golden one. With a comfortable plush sofa and freshly brewed coffee. I can hang out there with friends and do some work...
- prawnsalad 12y agoMibbit is still proprietary which is the same issue with Slack. The KiwiIRC webbased IRC client is open source with a free to use (no ads!) hosted version that is gaining in popularity. More and more existing IRC networks are enabling Kiwi with complete Freenode support also. UI improvements are coming up to make the most IRC actions usable via the UI which will make a huge improvement over many IRC options out there. Disclaimer: I'm a Kiwi IRC dev.
- Uberphallus 12y agoNot even for companies, IRC IMO would be much better, the only issue is, as always, you need someone responsible for the infrastructure: not only servers, but scripting for Jira/Dropbox/NameYourCurrentTrendyPlatform integration. -No single point of failure. -No dependency on a different company for a vital points of your business. -No private info stored on a 3rd party system, in a different state and potentially a different country (legal nightmare to ask for damages). -Distributed system. Local servers give lower lag for multisite companies, internet access outage means netsplit, not inability to communicate. -Already existing indexing and searching features if desired. -Many bots to automate/notify/interact with insane amounts of stuff. -Thousands of IRC clients, with enormous customizing features, for every conceivable platform, that do as much and even more than all these "this is how communication should be" solutions. -Bridging IRC to XMPP/Sametime/etc plugins/apps to interoperate with other companies. I can sort of understand Slack for a small company, but if you have your own server infrastructure, no, I can't.
- swombat 12y agoSetting up the system you describe above to work as well as say, Hipchat, with notifications by email and push notifications to iOS and Android clients, @mentions, reliability, etc, is certainly doable. If you have someone who's basically a competent geek, they can probably do that in a few days to get it all working perfectly. Once set up this sort of stuff tends to be fairly robust, so it probably won't take more than 1 days a month to maintain, deal with inevitable issues, etc. If you have absolutely nothing better to do with your time, it's a great idea to do this yourself. For the rest of us who are actually trying to grow businesses rather than set up IRC servers, there's HipChat and Slack.
- davidw 12y ago> For the rest of us who are actually trying to grow businesses rather than set up IRC servers, there's HipChat and Slack For something purely internal for a company, that makes sense to me. It's the public, 'general interest' kinds of things where I'd avoid building on something proprietary if possible. Seems like a good place to mention, on Freenode: * #startups - pretty informal and sometimes a lot of noise with little signal, but occasionally something good, too. * #bootstrappers - a channel I'm trying to get going. Not much there yet!
- orthecreedence 12y agoExactly what I thought as I was reading through the topics on the site..."Most of these sound like an IRC channel" (or hell, a subreddit). Definitely love Slack for team communication but I don't think it would work as well for public chat.
- wingerlang 12y agoUsage wise it is nothing near a subreddit, although it is nearly identical to IRC.
- joshdance 12y agoMy company used HipChat, Slack, IRC, and a few others. I hated using IRC. The amount of functionality that you get from Slack is so much better than IRC, I ok using their proprietary system. And if Slack gets acquired/killed/defunct, someone else will step up and fill the void.