8 ms·
Delphi's self-driving car
- Turing_Machine 12y agoThey've reached El Paso, TX, having started in San Francisco: https://twitter.com/AmyMessano https://twitter.com/AmyMessano (Amy Messano is their PR person) Apparently they racked up a speeding ticket in Arizona. :-)
- agumonkey 12y agoReminds me of drivers grunting when their GPS warns of speed limits (I actually checked, my father's one reacted under 1 second from the moment our car passed the sign on a highway).
- bbulkow 12y agoThey share the parking lot of my company, and the cars look pretty cool. What I don't understand: cars are not encrusted with sensors like Google's self driving cars. Would love an explaination of their tech to hide sensors.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoDidn't Google just bolt a ton of sensors on top of an existing car and called it a day? Also, it seems that only they are using LIDARs - apparently Tesla is doing self-driving cars without them (look at the Model S - do you see any sensor?), and so are some major car manufacturers.
- CardenB 12y agoIt's true. LIDAR can make the car look bad. If you add LIDAR in places where you can hide them (like the side of the car) vision is seriously restricted. This is why Google places the LIDAR so high up in their cars. The LIDAR is able to give an almost-birds-eye view of the surroundings the higher up it is. Plus Elon doesn't like LIDAR because it bit him when they tried using it for autonomous landing tech at SpaceX. Still, cameras and radar only get you so far... I'm also wondering how Delphi is doing all this with the tools they have.
- Turing_Machine 12y agoPer their site, the Delphi vehicle has "... four short-range radars, three vision-based cameras, six lidars, a localization system, intelligent software algorithms and a full suite of Advanced Drive Assistance Systems." http://www.delphi.com/delphi-drive http://www.delphi.com/delphi-drive
- CardenB 12y agoRight, I meant to say, "I wonder how they're getting so much functionality out of LIDAR without mounting it so high?"
- RealityVoid 12y agoYeah, but they're using radars. Or fixed-pointing LIDARS. They are more discrete and blend more easily into the car. As for other companies not using LIDARS, I beg to disagree. They do, but they use the far far simpler (and cheaper) variety. But the Google tech has a broader view of the surrounding area. In the end, it won't matter as much how pretty the sensors look as long as they get the job done.
- mattlutze 12y agoOn the contrary, two cars the same, it will matter more how pretty the sensors are, as people aren't going to purchase an "ugly" car in droves.
- RealityVoid 12y agoI bet you that if the car has better performance and reliability, people won't give a rat's ass how pretty the car looks.
- rwmj 12y agoAlso, I don't care what my taxi looks like.
- masklinn 12y ago> Tesla is doing self-driving cars Tesla is absolutely not doing self-driving cars at the moment, they're doing limited autopilot (which IIRC already exists to an extant on other high-end sedans e.g. auto-steering using lane detection on highways)
- TeMPOraL 12y agohttp://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/self-driving/tesla-model-s-to-combine-safety-sensors-to-go-autonomous http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/self... Current Teslas apparently have enough hardware to drive themselves around, but this year they plan to enable only a limited set of features because of safety reasons.
- chiph 12y agoThe problem I have with lane detection is that my state's highways don't have the clearest painted lines. And on the road I'd most want to use an auto-drive system on, it's been under construction since the late 80's so the lines are frequently wrong or missing. Not to mention the effect that heavy rain and snow has on the visibility of the lines. I think it's a fine supplemental system, but should never be a primary guide.
- dagw 12y agoGoogle's self driving car program was essentially born out of the DARPA Self Driving Challenge where looks weren't in any way a factor. So they started with the best senors possible, and kind of assume that they'd probably get smaller with time. Delphi, Tesla and all other car manufacturers came at the problem from the starting point that obviously visual sensors where a non-starter. So they started with the smallest sensors possible and kind of assumed that they'd get accurate enough with time Eventually they'll meet in the middle.
- agumonkey 12y agoIt's funny how fast things have changed since Thrun won. Before that, IIRC, cars wouldn't manage to drive 10% hitting a rock. All of a sudden : Google Cars everywhere.
- dagw 12y agoI know it's amazing. 11 years ago the state of the art car barely made 12 km, before getting stuck on a rock. And that was without having to deal with any traffic. 8 years ago the state of the art car managed to crawl through a 60 mile fake urban course at a speed of just over 20 km/h Today 'everybody' has a working self driving car handling real life traffic and normal driving speeds.
- pmorici 12y agoWhen I was in college in the early 00's I worked at a Delphi test lab. Even back then they had sensors under development that were pretty advanced especially for the time. Things like automated cruise control that adjusted the cruise speed based on the surrounding traffic. The leap from driver assisting tech to full self driving doesn't seem that big in terms of the sensors themselves and Delphi has been making sensors that go into production automobiles for a long time.
- minthd 12y agoPoor car companies. Between the possibility of this technology available as retrofits for old cars, the common use case for this as a taxi without the need to own it(and the efficiencies that come with it) ,the possibility of car sharing using this tech(like uber-pool) , and the long life of many current cars - the future of car companies seems hard(maybe after some brief period of big demand).
- jnty 12y agoYou say this like the car companies aren't developing self-driving technology too. They are - they just don't need or want to shout about it as they don't want to cannibalise the existing market until it's necessary.
- minthd 12y agoEven if they're the developing the tech, they'll do everything in their power as to not cannibalize themselves , and that will also contribute to their downfall. classic disruption. And you can see that in the way they talk: they believe that they should aim at partial self-driving(only on highways) while Google targets full self driving(including cities) which is a totally different challenge. On thing not clear from this article about delphi - is their ride includes city driving ? because self-driving cars could also cannibalize Deplhi, as far as i understand.
- Tloewald 12y agoThis is "the car companies". Car companies are largely systems integrators, buying pieces from companies like delphi and putting them in a nice box.
- maxerickson 12y agoDelphi was even at one time a part of GM, it was spun out as an independent company in the 1990s (I guess the company and GM division would not entirely overlap, but whatever).
- ssharp 12y ago
- falcolas 12y agoLooks like, similarly to the Google car, this is also heavily dependent on detailed maps of roads. The advanced radar-based sensors are pretty slick, but I'm curious about their limitations in terms of the size of the objects they can detect, and how far away. My car uses some similar technology for automatic cruise control and crash avoidance, but either the hardware or software is primitive, since it occasionally tries to protect me from rear-ending a car in the other lane.
- 72deluxe 12y agoI was hoping with this title that it was about a self-driving car written in Delphi / Pascal. Turns out I was disappointed.
- druidsbane 12y agoI'm interested in finding out what kind of inter-car communication these companies are considering; direct reports from cars on the scene as well as official beacons that cars can subscribe to along highways and in cities.
- mariusz79 12y agoWhen there is a talk about Apple going into self-driving car, there are hundreds of comments. When Musk mentions that Tesla will have self-driving car almost everyone here has an orgasm, but when a company that's well established in automotive industry drives their car from SF to NYC, we can't get even 30 comments in 12 hours?
- GeorgeHahn 12y agoThey didn't do the drive yet, this is just a piece of fluff to fill the time between their initial announcement and the drive (which will start next week).
- mariusz79 12y agoActually they are already on the road.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoThats the problem with voting-based sites. The sexy stories get play and everything else, outside of rare oddities, is marginalized. This is fine I suppose if we want to get a certain superficial benefit from this site, but if you want something deeper, often from what I imagine people think of as "boring" companies or "boring" spaces, it just won't work on a site that has this kind of voting mechanism in place. Geeks like to think of ourselves immune from things like celebrity, hype, PR, etc, but we actually are very vulnerable to it. We play up this "man of logic" persona, but its just a self-compliment. Not too long ago we were telling each other that $FOSS_project would destroy Windows/exchange/office, or Xioami will kill Android as we know it, or $billionare will fix $unsolvable_problem, or Diaspora will destroy Facebook, or that Ouya would destroy mainstream consoles, but it turns out that "boring" often wins as MS, Google, and Sony keep making profits and maintaining marketshare. We believe these things because they are pleasing to believe. If you got your news and tech opinions from slashdot 10 years ago you'd be shocked to even see Microsoft in business. How are we different today than the usually wrong slashdot narrative of yesterday? The larger issue is that dissenting voices are too easily marginalized. I'm pretty skeptical of the success of Tesla and Oculus for reasons I feel I present in a mostly productive way, but when I mention them its just a ticket to being downvoted, which on here and reddit just limits the visibility of the comment. Fanboy comments get upvoted to mass visibility and become the defining narrative. Those narratives become the norm and, well, here we are.
- ashwinl 12y agoCompletely agree about the prejudice against the well established. I am not affiliated with the Delphi project, but work in this space. Not having knowledge of the effectiveness of the Delphi autonomous system, can't speak to that. But, with regards to their mechanical design, this team has demonstrated autonomous capability with a familiar and covert form factor: obscured GPS antennas, LIDAR and cameras. And computing. Not visible in either the rear seat or trunk [1, 2]. Also important to mention that this product is a partnership between Delphi and Ottomatika [3]. Ottomatika is the company that won the 2007 DARPA Urban Challenge from CMU and provides the SLAM and software expertise. Admittedly, the Google's of the world help with the lobbying and regulatory efforts which eventually expedite the technology transfer to the market for the Delphi's and smaller startups in this space [4]. [1] https://twitter.com/harrymccracken/status/578624426079494145/ https://twitter.com/harrymccracken/status/578624426079494145... [2] https://twitter.com/DelphiAuto/status/580388500291342338 https://twitter.com/DelphiAuto/status/580388500291342338 [3] http://ottomatika.com/blog.html http://ottomatika.com/blog.html [4] http://www.getcruise.com http://www.getcruise.com