5 ms·
The issue isn't with closed source databases. The issue is with trusting smaller startups who don't have a customer base large enough to avoid dropping. Oracle
by threeseed 12y ago
The issue isn't with closed source databases. The issue is with trusting smaller startups who don't have a customer base large enough to avoid dropping.
Oracle and Teradata for example are proven databases with official support available worldwide and a talent pool you can draw from almost immediately. You don't get that with most open source databases (at least those that don't have a parent e.g. Datastax, Mongo, MySQL).
- YuriNiyazov 12y agoIf no one allowed small-startup technology into production, then the industry stagnation would be tremendous, so I disagree that is the issue. However, once you do rely on a small-startup database, it better be closed source, so I disagree: the issue is the closed-source part, not the small-startup part.
- mathattack 12y agoThis is why the world needs early adopters. There needs to be people interested enough in new technologies for their own sake to invest time in them. That's a very different motivation than P&G or Unilever.
- threeseed 12y agoExactly. There is room in this world for closed and open source products. Enterprise companies will trade technology for stability and supportability. Most of us will flip the other way.
- mathattack 12y agoI oversimplify it by saying "Companies will pay cash and accept closed source in return for good documentation and someone to answer the phone." Most non-IT buyers don't bring up open vs closed source in purchasing discussions.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- threeseed 12y agoThe fact is that the world depends on closed source databases. So yes I continue to disagree that you should never use one just because it is closed source. And I never said that people shouldn't use small startup technologies. Only that when you do you take the risk of the company not being around in a few years. And the people who will take that risk are really other startups or early adopters.
- kamaal 12y ago>> I disagree: the issue is the closed-source part, not the small-startup part. Correct. But you are betting the success of your nascent start up on another nascent start up. This is straight up wrong. For a large company its different. They have all the resources to go into months long migration projects. As a start up, you can't afford time for migrations when you are busy doing the real work.
- baldfat 12y agoplease don't down vote because you disagree. Write a reply. Down vote what is inappropriate and doesn't add to the conversation. I strongly disagree your stance on Oracle in particular. I had two arrays at a medium size academic library 8 years ago. Anything I had to call about the data base meant a line item for business review due to cost if it wasn't covered by Oracle's service agreement. PostgreSQL is amazing and I much rather work with that and hire whoever I want with what I want to do either per instance or annual contracts.
- reitanqild 12y agoTotally agree: All to often I see anonymous downvotes on answers that are factually correct and/or helpful.
- angrybits 12y agoI guess he hasn't learned the house rules.
- falcolas 12y agoThe problem is, downvotes due to disagreement are codified as acceptable. Which still sucks, since downvotes can lead to shadowbans. PS. Just double checked the Guidelines, and this codification is no longer there. However, there's also no guidance to suggest an appropriate reason to downvote.
- mkramlich 12y agoagree. same experience. so I rarely comment on HN anymore. dominated by very very narrow-minded assholes. my time better spent elsewhere.
- 72deluxe 12y agoWhere do you spend it, out of interest? What comparable places are there for chatting on nerdish things like this?
- 12y ago
- lmm 12y ago> Oracle and Teradata for example are proven databases with official support available worldwide and a talent pool you can draw from almost immediately. I've watched Oracle try to strangle more than one company once they were dependent on their database. One they succeeded, one managed to migrate to PostgreSQL just in time. If you build your business to be dependent on Oracle they have you by the balls; don't think they're not going to squeeze. And IME the worldwide talent pool is much more available and... well, talented, for PostgreSQL or MySQL or any of the major open-source options.