2 ms·
I believe that the author is basically right. More precisely, I think that there are three types of programmers. Those who don't know the formal theory. Thos
by btilly 12y ago
I believe that the author is basically right.
More precisely, I think that there are three types of programmers. Those who don't know the formal theory. Those who know it but don't think in terms of complexity except when they have to. And those for whom big-O is second nature.
I believe that there is great value from having someone around who falls into the third group. (That's where I'd rate myself.) But they are rare. And there is little difference in practice between people in the first and second groups. Exactly how little difference is demonstrated by the fact that people who once took CS and then work as programmers find their memories of big-O fading over time because they aren't using it.
As for where the slippery slope ends, given the choice of having a new developer be a typical CS grad versus a beginning programmer who has mastered everything in Code Complete, I'd go for the second one every time. Obviously this isn't true if you're in an area that requires CS knowledge. But for most working developers, I think it is.