4 ms·
Cynical me. I don't see people who've never had to work, doing more than watching the latest Reality TV program and complaining about the quality of the free fo
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
Cynical me. I don't see people who've never had to work, doing more than watching the latest Reality TV program and complaining about the quality of the free food. Doing those other things is all about cultural values, and nothing about free time.
- vijayr 12y agotry watching TV non stop for a week or two - it gets boring and annoying, real fast. there will be people who will watch TV all day when they don't have to work, but there will also be people who would spend their time doing useful things. Even if the latter group is just a fraction, it would benefit everyone immensely in the long run. After all, only a few thousand people edit wikipedia out of 7 billion of us, only a few thousand people write open source software but all of humanity benefits from it, right?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoPollyanna. Think about a generation of teenaged boys with nothing to do but watch television. The carnage!
- iamthepieman 12y agoSelection bias right there in "people who've never had to work" What if you took people who have always had to work/chosen to work and give them resources to free up their time. Of course, you'd probably get a lot of bad things as well as good since sudden changes will always generate some churn and chaos short-term. Think about this for yourself. If you didn't have to work, or only had to work 25-30 hours a week what would you do with the extra time? Now apply that to every middle class individual. Sure some would spend the time in less productive or even harmful ways. But others would spend it even more wisely than you imagine yourself spending it.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoSure. But steady state, nobody's working. Us old guard will die off and leave just young'uns that never had to work. That was the idea I was getting at.
- fown9 12y agoIf you old people would stop working and retire, the young people would have work to do. What's that? you didn't save anything after the best financial boom time in history? You have to work until you're 80? Well, then stop complaining.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThe topic was of a Basic Income that meant no one has to work any more unless they want to.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bmelton 12y agoTo be fair, a lot of market-based savings schemes were wiped out in 2008. My in-laws, who diligently spent their entire lives working boring jobs in banks (as accountants and such, not wall street), who prepared for their retirement by paying off their modest $250,000 home (in Nashville, it's nicer than the dollar amount makes it seem), found themselves screwed when they went to retire, as their 401Ks were now worth fractions of what they'd expected. So they're still working, extending their retirement in the hopes that their portfolios will recover, or that they can continue earning enough while they're healthy that they can offset it. It literally never occurred to me until your comment that someone might resent them for trying to earn a living for themselves without burdening the rest of society.
- aros 12y agoI find it sad that you have to emphasize a 250k home as "nice" since people around here are used to million dollar single bedroom apartments crammed in to a city. In many, many places in the US, you can easily own 3000+ sqft of land and home for 250k.
- panglott 12y agoI work, I watch TV, I play with my kid and help him with homework, I make some edits to Wikipedia, I study stuff online, &c. &c. When I was between jobs recently I did more of all of those things—except TV. I don't know many people in the rentier class that have never had to work, but my understanding is that the status quo already allows them to spend all the time they want watching reality TV ;)
- pjc50 12y agoI don't see people who've never had to work Other than the idle rich, I don't see many people who've never had to work either. I've seen people unable to work, and I've seen people denied the opportunity to work, but the idle poor are really not as prevalent as people seem to think.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThe topic was of Basic Income and the utopian future where nobody has to work if they don't want to. Some writer painted a bright picture where everybody would be volunteering at the senior center. I disagreed.