3 ms·
We've already (in America) got so many basic support programs, I don't see a problem with accepting Basic Income. There's food stamps, housing assistance (20%
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
We've already (in America) got so many basic support programs, I don't see a problem with accepting Basic Income. There's food stamps, housing assistance (20% of Americans!) and free education already.
{edit: add Basic Income}
- flatline 12y agoThe problem is at the intersection of welfare and work. You have to be really poor and stay really poor to qualify for most of these social programs, and the programs are designed to be pretty minimal and thereby encourage people to work. At the same time, they disincentivize much of the low-paying work that many people on welfare can obtain, because they will be worse off without the handout. This is what unconditional basic income is supposed to address. It is also the source of concern about jobs going away, that a much larger number of people are going to be swept into government-subsidized poverty, which will put strains on the already burdened welfare system in the US. Where will the money come from?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThe question was about acceptance, which is demonstrate by the existence of these programs. The further question of resource is a good one. And its not about money, which is after all, imaginary points on a scorecard. The real question is where are the goods coming from? It'll have to be automation, because the premise is that people won't be working.
- geebee 12y agoI think the big arguments for basic income are: 1) there is a huge and inefficient bureaucracy involved in administering these various assistance programs 2) the way these programs work (you lose access to them if your income rises above a fairly low threshold), we've essentially created a marginal tax rate of 100% on certain types of low income workers. 3) rapid technological change and increasing automation undermines the moral argument against redistribution of wealth. It is interesting that libertarians, not generally known for enthusiasm around wealth distribution, appear at least intrigued by basic income. This is just a quick summary, of course, I'd encourage you to read more about the case for basic income.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoRe: 1. Apparently it takes more money to administer Welfare, than they disburse. Hopefully a Basic Income would solve that one.
- eru 12y agoYes, there's an interesting coalition of libertarians and socialists (called liberals in America) in favour of basic income. Strange bedfellows.
- nissimk 12y agoDid you see the divisiveness created by the Affordable care Act? Every democrat voted for it and every republican voted against it. It was forced through and many people complained bitterly about it. The affordable care act is not even a national healthcare plan. It was almost impossible for them to get ACA passed when it was basically just adding regulation and bureaucracy to the existing private insurance system. The opposition kept saying socialism and redistribution of wealth. Why do you think "Basic Income" would be "no problem," when it actually is both socialism and redistribution of wealth. Even looking through the comments here on HN, there are a lot of folks who would have a big problem with it.