5 ms·
I think it's funny that the author used such flowery language, yet seems to be of the opinion that "criticism" and "critique" mean "opposition", a common but in
by vacri 12y ago
I think it's funny that the author used such flowery language, yet seems to be of the opinion that "criticism" and "critique" mean "opposition", a common but incorrect belief. Film critics don't oppose films, for example. They discuss the pros and cons of various films, and suggest films that may be appropriate depending on your preferences. I wouldn't have thought a logophile would make that error.
Then again, the author also thinks that 'Silicon Valley' is synonymous with 'technology'. I wonder how many venture-capital backed startups were involved with the automation of the pilot's cockpit that he so mourns...
- danans 12y agoI think he's actually attacking the mourning of cockpit automation, not defending it. He uses it as an example of Carr's romanticization of manually performed work.
- vacri 12y agoI don't read the 'pilot' paragraph that way. It leads in with "Carr's basic premise is sound" and the following sentence about the pilots is used to support that first sentence. I do admit that I only read half-way through the article as a whole, though; I found it pretty light on substance and more trouble than it was worth. On a tangent, regarding the self-driving vehicle, I would venture that the critic referred to already has a... cough "self-driving Carr" cough ...
- knucklesandwich 12y agoI think it's funny that the author used such flowery language, yet seems to be of the opinion that "criticism" and "critique" mean "opposition", a common but incorrect belief. The author isn't talking about people who oppose technology, he's talking about people who evaluate it's evolution, which is in line with criticism in the sense of "film criticism". The people being cited here are clearly not against technology on the whole. Then again, the author also thinks that 'Silicon Valley' is synonymous with 'technology'. It's called synecdoche. The US Government isn't relegated to Washington, DC either.