5 ms·
Seriously though, what can Maya do that Blender can't?
by tomjen3 12y ago
Seriously though, what can Maya do that Blender can't?
- angersock 12y agoHave a decent user interface?
- geoka9 12y agoJust curious, have you tried using blender at a more or less advanced level? It's like comparing Windows and a Unix system and saying that Unix doesn't have a decent user interface. I mean, once you start using blender extensively, you realize that blender makes your workflow faster than the mainstream CG packages.
- angersock 12y agoOf the big CG packages, I've used both 3DS Max, Maya, and Blender--Max most of all. The gold standard for UI for me, though, is still Wings3D (based on Nendo). It has way better UV unwrapping support than anything else I've tried. It is as good as it is specifically because the functionality it aims at is quite limited. Sketchup gets an honorable mention for UI, but the scripting and geometry it makes is such garbage I can't recommend it.
- dtf 12y agoBlender's a bit like a tiling window manager. If you don't get on with your keyboard you're not going to have much to say. It is however extremely efficient for those that do. What it's missing really is some of the universal, underlying data flow architecture that the likes of Maya and Houdini had from the start. But it's getting there.
- geoka9 12y ago> some of the universal, underlying data flow architecture that the likes of Maya and Houdini had from the start Could you elaborate on that? I'm not sure I understand what you mean by "data flow" in the context of a CGI package.
- dtf 12y agoMaya has its dependency graph architecture, while Houdini has its many layers of networks. They both make explicit their pipelines of data transformation, using a common building block, and that allows the system and the artist to reason about what gets done and when. You might create some geometry (a grid), then apply some noise to it to create a landscape, then use it as part of a physics simulation as a static object, then also use it as part of the rendering of the final image. You expect to be able to change the parameters of each of those stages and reason about the result. You'll generally see these pipelines depicted as editable, directed graphs (DAGs) in the application. Blender uses DAGs for a number of things - eg an image compositor, and for shading networks. It also provides modifier layers (like 3DS MAX) for geometry transformation. But it doesn't go down to the core of the application which is why you can get some problems when it comes to certain tasks in animation for instance. But they are working on this. It's a bit like all these various architectures for the web - Flux, RxJS etc. They're making explicit the transformations and dependencies that happen, by means of a data flow graph (even if it is not visualised). This usually means less surprises and more opportunity for optimization.
- geoka9 12y agoOh yes, I see now. Actually, that was one of the few things I missed in Blender coming from Softimage. Not too much, though, but I do appreciate the power of a unified editable operation stack/pipeline for bigger projects.
- foobarbecue 12y agoThey're working on it, though: http://code.blender.org/index.php/2015/02/blender-dependency-graph-branch-for-users/ http://code.blender.org/index.php/2015/02/blender-dependency...
- wolfgke 12y agoBeing one of the industry standards for 3D modeling. OK, and having a file format that can at least in theory be read by other programs (.blend files are simply undocumented memory dumps).
- GroSacASacs 12y agoSure, .blend files are basically useless outside of Blender, and that's why there's an export command that lets you export what you made into other format like .X3D (xml based) for example or even Wavefront .obj file.
- geoka9 12y agoOr even .3ds for that matter (not to mention collada).
- wolfgke 12y agoBut can you guarantee that no information is lost by exporting? I personally have my doubts (and I had bad experience with the Blender exporters in the past on this point; perhaps the bugs are fixed now). In my opinion Blender should introduce two file formats: - .blend: The existing format; fast to load, save etc., but not for reading from external programs - .blend_external: A format that presents exactly the same information as a .blend file, but can be read easily by external software and is thus completely documented in all details. Perhaps more slow to load/save (which should not matter for the purposes of .blend_external).
- dtf 12y agoThis is pretty much the same dilemma as all content creation packages - whether 3D software, audio, CAD, video editing etc. Internal formats need to be fast and robust to frequent revisions, and will inevitably support procedural transformations on data that are unique to that software (eg a particular mesh modifier, particle system, audio compressor or video effect). So external formats become quite difficult to specify, and generally require that everything gets baked/bounced down to the lowest common denominator - eg per-frame animation channels, or EDL-level edits in a video. The .blend format isn't actually that bad, if you really need to access it. I've seen a number of external libraries written in C or Python that do this, and it's one of those formats where you can skip over the unknowns (as indeed Blender itself does when loading files from the future). If you want to do 3D interchange, this will depend much on your particular application. We have FBX for mesh, scene and animation data which is pretty good. OBJ is always there for the simplest of things. ABC (Alembic) support is coming to Blender for more complex geometry, and there's talk of OpenVDB for voxel data. Other roads out include numerous exporters for various game platforms - THREE.js, the new Khronos gITF format or OpenGEX.
- supercoder 12y agoBe usable
- jsheard 12y agoHave real paid support?
- berkut 12y agoThere are actually better apps than Maya for modelling / UVing, but for animation / rigging / skinning / techanim it's the benchmark. Blender's got most of the functionality in theory, but it's really not well architected / designed in terms of workflow - a bit like old Nokia Nxx phones - they had all the features, but they weren't user-friendly for many things.
- geoka9 12y agoBlender has made a lot of strides in the past few years. Have you tried it recently? My last encounter with blender was in 2008 and it was rather painful. I gave it another try several months ago and got my socks blown off. I've since rebuilt my workflow around blender and there's no going back.
- erikano 12y agoBlender is pretty good. I've only used it a few times but I agree that the UI seems to have improved quite a bit. I did find the interface modes a bit confusing at first (and I say that as someone whos primary text editor has been Vim for the last 5-6 years). With so much functionality, where to find the things you are looking for can be a bit difficult. I think doing as you did and rebuilding your workflow around the tool is probably the best way to get productive.
- geoka9 12y ago> With so much functionality, where to find the things you are looking for can be a bit difficult. I've yet to see a 3D program where it's easy (except, maybe Google Sketchup). They are complicated beasts, so new users should expect a learning curve. In my experience, though, Blender gets easier once you master the basics (while most other packages let you do a "hello world" type project easily, but mire you down with their "friendly" UI for more advanced stuff). Another important thing that sets Blender apart WRT learning curve, is the abundance of good tutorials and help (it's even got its own stack exchange site[1] - incredibly helpful!). [1] http://blender.stackexchange.com http://blender.stackexchange.com
- 12y ago
- joeld42 12y agoAnimation/rigging tools seem particularly lacking to me. For example, a "set driven key" in maya is simple, very common action. You can do the same thing in blender, but it takes more steps and seems kind of obscure. Blender often has trouble dealing with scenes at production scale. Not that it can't do it (as the blender movie projects prove) but generally you have to know the strengths and weakness of it well to set up a scene at production scale. And to be honest, the scale of the blender shorts is pretty small compared to a typical maya production scene. It's getting better with every release though. A lot of the tools, for example the texture painting and matchmoving tools, are already better than maya. Render layers have recently caught up. I think maya still has an edge in production use, but we're starting to see blender being used in real production situations. If you look at the trajectories of development of both programs, blender is moving fast and maya is more or less sitting still.
- photex 12y agoThe most honest answer is that studios can't extend the software without violating the GPL. Maya is outrageously extensible in a variety of ways and really set the standard for being "open" in this way. A lot of the big studios have toolsets that radically transform parts of Maya, shaping it into the tool needed for the work. Maya is also pretty crusty, plenty of other applications do a better job at it's core competency, but they simply aren't dug into studio pipelines like a tick in the way that Maya is. Blender has to limit itself to Python, or at least, I'm not aware of the ability to create native plugins. I'm all for Python, but a lot of interesting work is done in C++ building native operators for the application or embedding custom viewports for gamedev which I don't think is remotely possible in Blender yet. Additionally, licensing prevents many integrations from getting off the ground.
- virtualritz 12y agoThe GPL doesn't matter if you only use the software inside the studio.
- belorn 12y agoSo what you are saying is that there is no benefit of using Maya if you are not specifically a commercial software company who want to sell derivative tool-kits made from open source projects. Or... should I sum it up as Maya is used by studios who already has c++ experience, and Blender is used by studios that has python experience?
- Animats 12y agoHave a usable user interface? Here's a hotkey chart for Blender.[1] You must memorize this. "Note that charts and references relate to common or frequently used actions in Blender so should not be regarded as a comprehensive list of shortcuts. Note also that triggers are context sensitive, the same key may function differently depending upon the Editor open or operation performed". [1] http://www.katsbits.com/tutorials/blender/useful-keyboard-shortcuts.php http://www.katsbits.com/tutorials/blender/useful-keyboard-sh...
- wz1000 12y agoI haven't used 3D modelling software, but I presume that you would look up things as you need them as in any other software, and not memorize everything in the beginning. Things that are commonly used will be memorized automatically.
- foobarbecue 12y agoI was scared away from Blender for years by people like you. Last week, I learned Blender. I was astonished to find it way more intuitive than every other 3D program I've used heavily. That includes: 3DS Max, Polyworks, Cyclone, Meshlab, CloudCompare, RiScan, Moray, Photoscan, VisualSFM. You can do everything 100% with the mouse, or 100% with the keyboard. I'm at about 60% keyboard, 40% mouse, which is just how I like it. If you can't remember how to do something, and can't find it in the clicky menus (even though it IS there), just press space and type what you want to do.