5 ms·
I sadly do this too. Mostly as a time saver. Though many of the articles are not long on here, I find that the comments provide a better and briefer summary, wi
by Balgair 12y ago
I sadly do this too. Mostly as a time saver. Though many of the articles are not long on here, I find that the comments provide a better and briefer summary, with rebuttals and secondments built in.
I said sadly, as others state, the comments here prime me to read an article differently and influence me. I do not like that, I am human and anchoring is a real thing for us all [1].
In general, I think HN has a good enough and small enough reader base to be able to trust the comments; much like reddit was back about 5 years ago and /. about 12 years ago. Alas, all good things will come to an end. If/when that happens, don't trust the comments again and move on to whatever is next.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring
- iamcurious 12y agoAnchors are inevitable. The only question is which anchor to use. Comments are more of a discussion and less of a monologue, so I consider them a better anchor for topics I'm not familiar with.
- beat 12y agoPoint about having a place for the good thoughts to congregate is spot-on. The question is, will HN grow to be unwieldy like reddit and slashdot did, or will something better come along without this one starting to suck first? As an aside, I wish my handle here was "Anonymous Coward"...
- Balgair 12y agoFrom one of my favorite tumblrs: http://rulesformyunbornson.tumblr.com/post/6290597184/498-hidden-gems-wont-stay-hidden-forever http://rulesformyunbornson.tumblr.com/post/6290597184/498-hi... "498. Hidden gems won’t stay hidden forever. Especially if you brag about them." So yes, eventually HN will become like all the others, especially if the quality stays high. I am almost certain there is a 'Murphy's Law' type thing about this, though I don't know the name. Also, there will be another thing out there that does not suck while HN will start sucking, but it will be hard to find. Likely, there are a lot of them already, but their userbases are so tiny that it's almost impossible to find them. Actually, hey. Why can't we engineer around this? Like say, have subreddits that your IP defaults into, keeping the userbases small no matter how big the site gets.
- jarrettch 12y agoAs long as it stays "Hacker" News, I think the audience will stay small enough and comments will remain to be mostly high quality. If it branches out into "Cat Video News" and God knows what else then we may be in trouble.
- Rainymood 12y agoThe comments on Hacker News are high quality because there are only certain people with downvoting privileges. And trust me: they downvote ruthlessly. Which is imo a good thing. Just take a peek at Reddit: subreddits with a high moderator count (which actively moderate) are high quality. /r/AskHistorians and /r/AskScience spring to mind. They do not allow any jokes in the comments.
- burger_moon 12y agoThis is why I don't visit Reddit much anymore. I appreciate the seriousness of this discussion board even with controversial topics not related to the programming sphere.
- engi_nerd 12y agoI've been lurking for a lot longer than my account has been active (probably a good 5 years now); have never seen what the criteria are for being able to downvote. Could you please enlighten me?
- Balgair 12y agoHonestly, I'm a bit curious too, bu kinda do not want to know, as I may be then tempted to 'go for it' and obtain that ability.
- Retric 12y ago~500 Karma
- needacig 12y agoIt has to be a lot higher than that now because the commenter with the comment above yours has ~900 karma and doesn't have downvote privilege.