4 ms·
The problem is that you can't get very far into the discussion before all the available options involve overhauling the entire system. And there's no way, reali
by vinceguidry 12y ago
The problem is that you can't get very far into the discussion before all the available options involve overhauling the entire system. And there's no way, realistically, to do that.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> And there's no way, realistically, to do that. Yes, yes there is. We start with the most victimless crimes (drug possession for personal consumption) and go from there. Police unions will fight it. Prison unions will fight it. The court system will fight it. Nevertheless, it must be done.
- pc86 12y agoNone of what you just said is an argument against "And there's no way, realistically, to do that." which many people (myself included) believe when you're talking about a systematic overhaul of the entire criminal justice system. Saying "oh well it must be done" doesn't negate the fact that practically speaking, it's impossible.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoWe start with the most victimless crimes (drug possession for personal consumption) and go from there. Did I not call that out enough? My apologies if so. Stop wasting time prosecuting what doesn't provide value in prosecuting.
- mellavora 12y agoIn support of your position, how did we ever let people convince us that victimless "crimes" were crimes? The definition of crime rests on the concept of harm, which requires a victim.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 12y agoSo-called "victimless crimes" are crimes where the harm perceived is a diffuse harm rather than a focused harm on a particular individual. There's really no reason why diffuse harms should not be criminal while focused ones should (arguably, diffuse harms are less able to be addressed by individual action through the civil justice system, so outside of focused harms where the victim is unable to pursue action after the crime, like murder, diffuse harms are the most important for government to address directly.) OTOH, there's often a lot more disagreement over whether what some people perceive as a diffuse harm actually is a harm.
- mikeash 12y agoI've never seen "victimless crime" defined as diffuse versus focused harm, and I would strongly disagree with describing it as such. For example, dumping mercury into a major river causes extremely diffuse harm, but I'd never describe it as a "victimless crime." In the other direction, smoking weed in private harms nobody except the smoker. The harm is so focused it doesn't even touch anyone besides the offender. Yet this is almost the canonical example of "victimless crime." It's not about diffuse harm, it's about whether anyone was harmed at all besides the accused.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> In the other direction, smoking weed in private harms nobody except the smoker. This is precisely the point that is contention. The entire argument for prohibiting marijuana is that this is, in fact, not the case, and that, through a number of indirect channels, people "smoking weed in private" harms others throughout society in a variety of ways. Obviously, as I said, there is considerable disagreement about whether this is, in fact, the case, (and, also, as to whether, even if it is, prohibition mitigates or exacerbates these harms, and as to whether, in any case, prohibition is an ethically-acceptable response even if the harms exist and prohibition mitigates them.) But it certainly is not the case that those who support prohibition generally agree that the crimes are "victimless" that those opposed to prohibition describe that way.
- 12y ago
- mikeash 12y agoSignificantly reducing the number of criminals is fairly easy without overhauling the system. Decriminalize drug use and possession. That'll cut the number of trials (or pleas) substantially all by itself, and even more so if you assume that knock-on effects will reduce crime overall, as many drug legalization proponents think it would. Other nonviolent offenses could be cut back as well. Stop putting people in prison because one of them paid the other one for sex, for example. Here in Virginia, you can potentially go to jail for a year (and, obviously, have a trial if you want it) for driving at 80MPH in a zone marked for 70MPH! Increasing resources for holding trials is also not terribly difficult and doesn't require any sort of overhaul. It's just a problem of money, and not a big one. Just for a random example, it looks like the courts account for about 0.3% of my local county budget and about 1% of my local state budget. We could literally increase court resources by a factor of 10 with only a modest increase in taxes to fund it.