6 ms·
Canada's CSE cyberwarfare toolbox revealed
- nvk 12y agoThe job of a spy agency is to spy, that will never change. The problem I have is when it starts infringing the rights and freedoms of it's own citizens (ie C-51).
- elchief 12y agoThey don't even have to. The NSA will spy on Canadians and then ship CSE the data.
- hurin 12y agoThere needs to be a ban on this practice. I don't know about Canadian law, but most likely the spirit of: The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures Was certainly not: Ask the Canadians to seize it for you and then they can give it back to you without due process. (This is exactly the kind of Hostile Act the NSA should be protecting American's against, not cooperating with).
- koblas 12y agoGreat opportunity - for nation states that don't have the ability to create a cyber department, just outsource to somebody who can spy on everybody. There are some great economies of scale, since more than one client is going to be interested in mining in Brazil or some piece of oil information from the middle east... You've got multiple customers for the same data.
- Zirro 12y agoThere is a great difference between spying on individual targets and capturing data from millions of people who have done no harm. The latter practice is what these agencies have been have heavily criticized for.
- devsd0 12y agoNot mobile link http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/communication-security-establishment-s-cyberwarfare-toolbox-revealed-1.3002978 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/communication-security-establi...
- ChrisArchitect 12y agothx. dismayed that the urls don't match up (by removing the 'm' or whatever). Boo.
- kefs 12y agoThe Intercept write-up: https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/03/23/canada-cse-hacking-cyberwar-secret-arsenal https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/03/23/canada-cse-hac... One of the documents (PDF, 46 pages): https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1690224/doc-6-cyber-threat-capabilities.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1690...
- plg 12y agoI see two strategies: (1) fight to restrict how much spy agencies spy. (2) fight to bolster ordinary citizens' use of technologies like encryption so that they cannot be spied upon. I would bet that strategy (2) is the more likely one to gain traction and make a difference against the infringement of our rights as citizens.
- rainforest 12y agoThe problem with strategy (2) is that the government can take action to stop it. For example, in the UK it's a criminal offence to withhold encryption keys in the face of a warrant. David Cameron also relatively recently argued that encryption should be banned or controlled to prevent anyone hiding things from the intelligence services. Widespread deployment of encryption would probably just result in more offensive tactics from intelligence agencies.
- middleclick 12y agoKey disclosure laws fall into this same category. It doesn't matter if you use full-disk encryption - you have to turn over the keys when asked else you face imprisonment. TrueCrypt's plausible deniability feature was really helpful; I wish dm-crypt has something like this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law And this is what happened in Canada recently: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/quebec-resident-alain-philippon-to-fight-charge-for-not-giving-up-phone-password-at-airport-1.2982236 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/quebec-resident-al...
- gkoz 12y agoIn this context hindering the use of encryption by your own citizens seems like making every other intelligence agency's job easier.
- zby 12y agoNumber one problem is attribution. Restricting the agencies will never be effective if you cannot know which one did something.
- 12y ago
- an_d_rew 12y agoI'm Canadian, and my initial thought was "Yay! We don't suck at something! Hooray! We're not irrelevant!" followed quickly by "Oh, $hit..." :-( The worst part is that if this was part of evidence-based policy, strategy, or tactics, it would at least be arguably not stupid. Sigh.
- dguido 12y agohttps://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1690224/doc-6-cyber-threat-capabilities.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1690... This is not a "cyberware toolbox." This is an IDS. For real, I bet they are using Snort inside one of their codeworded intrusion detection/response systems. Companies try to defend themselves from hackers by analogous systems. Is this any different?
- godgod 12y agoYou are poorly informed. This goes well beyond an IDS. While yes, I'm sure they detect using signatures LIKE snort but snort isn't storing 300TB of full take content on citizens to be shared with the other nations that play ball. Full take data goes "on your permanent record" which can be used later to frame or blackmail you. Much different than snort.
- at-fates-hands 12y agoAre we seeing an arms race now in terms of cyberwarfare? It seems like this is the next "must have" for any nation state arsenal. Makes you wonder what will be more powerful in five years. These kinds of weapons that can attack and bring down parts of a countries infrastructure or a nuclear bomb?
- godgod 12y agoI stand by this statement. All good governments eventually turn bad.