3 ms·
I work for a large private sector union. Unions are not perfect, nothing is, but they are also completely democratic institutions. But, the decline in union m
by rsuelzer 12y ago
I work for a large private sector union. Unions are not perfect, nothing is, but they are also completely democratic institutions. But, the decline in union membership does not tell the whole story about the decline of wages in America.
I believe the decline in wages and union membership reflects a shift in how people value themselves as human beings, and their relationship to their fellow man.
The biggest obstacle to increasing wages to more equitable levels comes from the mentality: "At least I have a job", "I will be rich someday", "I can make it on my own", "I'm only going to work here for a year". These thoughts are what has allowed wages to be pushed to their lowest levels in recent history without any push-back from the work force.
Unions at their core are nothing more than a group of workers who get together to negotiate a contract and are willing to take action to force the employer to sit down and negotiate. This used to be understood, but at some point unions became viewed as some sort of "servicing" entity that drew its powers from a mysterious legal paper. Members forgot that the union was THEM.
Thankfully, the labor movement is starting reverse course from decades of this mentality.
The truth is that, the only power which workers (unionized or not) have is to withhold labor in a coordinated manner. Contracts are meaningless without the power of a strike. Without workers being willing to all withhold labor together, union or not, wages will continue to decline until a moral crisis is reached.
Sorry, that was a bit of a ramble, but "unions" are just groups of workers who have a 501(c)(5) paper with IRS that allows them pool money together to organize.
- frostmatthew 12y ago> they are also completely democratic institutions I've seen this democracy in practice first-hand in my previous career where shop stewards diligently ensured that come time for a union vote those that will vote the "right way" are provided time-off and/or transportation while the others are "stuck working" or "there's no more room in the van."
- randomdata 12y agoI believe the decline in wages and union membership reflects a shift in how people value themselves as human beings, and their relationship to their fellow man. From the data I am looking at, wages started to stagnate (I see no clear decline trend) around the year 1965, which roughly coincides with when women started to enter the workforce in a meaningful way. Could it be simply that the near-doubling of the labour pool pushed the supply beyond the demand, thus depressing prices and forcing people to take what they can get? More recently, we might say robots have helped increase the supply even further. Like you recognized later on in your post, the power of the union comes from artificially restricting the supply of workers to make supply and demand work in their favour, so does it not stand to reason that attitude shift you have observed is a result of the same market economics, not the other way around?