7 ms·
Well, we finally have flexbox now!
by TazeTSchnitzel 12y ago
Well, we finally have flexbox now!
- lisper 12y agoIt's far from clear to me that flexbox actually solves the problem. For example, consider the following: <table style='height: 100%; width: 100%'> <tr><td align=center valign=center> <h1>Hello world</h1> The following button should be centered:<br> <button>Button</button> </td></tr> </table> Can you reproduce that with flexbox? In a way that works across all browsers? Without writing huge amounts of code? [NOTE: This example has a bug in it. See the subsequent comments]
- icebraining 12y agoDoesn't simply replacing the table/tr/td with a div with "margin: auto; text-align: center" work? Seems to yield the same result, at least in Firefox.
- lisper 12y agoMargin: auto doesn't center vertically. Also, it only centers the element that it applies to, not the contents of that element. My example was supposed to illustrate this, but it actually has a bug. I thought buttons didn't get centered by text-align, but they do. Here's an updated example: <table style='height: 100%; width: 100%'> <tr><td align=center valign=center> <h1>Hello world</h1> The following green square should be centered:<br> <div style='width: 30px; height: 30px; background: green'></div> </td></tr> </table> margin:auto also requires you to manually set the width of the div you're trying to center in order to work.
- nkuttler 12y agoThat's easy to do without tables. See display: table; and display: inside-block for the div. text-align: center, yadda.
- lisper 12y agoDisplay: table is cheating, and essentially conceding that you should have been using tables all along. And there is no such thing as display: inside-block. (You probably meant inline-block.) The devil is in the details. I believe if you try it you will find it is nowhere near as easy as you imagine.
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> Display: table is cheating, and essentially conceding that you should have been using tables all along. Not at all. "display: table" (and the related "display: table-cell" and similar) mean that you've written something which is not semantically a table, but which should use the browser rendering conventions of a table. That's a perfectly reasonable distinction. Otherwise, would you suggest that every use of "font-family: sans-serif" is cheating and essentially conceding that you should have been using a <font> tag all along?
- lisper 12y ago> Otherwise, would you suggest that every use of "font-family: sans-serif" is cheating Yes, if your intent is to use font-family as an example in an argument for using CSS. > and essentially conceding that you should have been using a <font> tag all along? No, I'm saying that a font tag and a font-family style are equivalent. One is as good as the other. You should read this: http://blog.rongarret.info/2009/02/on-semantics-of-html.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2009/02/on-semantics-of-html.html
- JoshTriplett 12y agoEven if you argue that HTML tags don't have semantic meanings (which I'd strongly disagree with, pointing to numerous tools that derive useful semantic information from such tags), there's quite a lot of value in defining your markup in terms of semantics and then separately defining what you want those semantics to look like. With good semantic markup, you can easily retheme your site to look completely different, make it scale to a mobile UI, or make it accessible to users of screen readers. So, there's a major difference between using font-family and a <font> tag, and a major difference between using display: table* and <table>/<tr>/<td> tags. And for the same reason, you shouldn't use class="sidebar" if what you mean is class="navigation" (or for that matter <nav>). Let alone class="big-red-button" when what you mean is class="delete". To use an example from that article: sure, <p> is not as semantically significant as <section> or <h1>, but it's a lot more semantic than, say, <br/><br/>, which I've seen used between paragraphs. "This is a paragraph" is more semantically useful than "this has an indent on the left and 1.4x line spacing"; "this is a heading" is more semantically useful than "this is 24pt and bold".
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoYes.