3 ms·
IMO the minimal security requirements for online voting must include fully open source code. I don't mean open source licensing, but the entire implementation m
by ams6110 12y ago
IMO the minimal security requirements for online voting must include fully open source code. I don't mean open source licensing, but the entire implementation must be open to public review and audit.
Even with that, I have my doubts. On the other hand, traditional paper ballots are certainly prone to all kinds of fraud, and on balance I'd say an electronic system should be able to do better, if not be perfectly secure.
- boyter 12y agoAgreed. I have argued for this with other technical people and they still argue the opposite however. I am in New South Wales and have raised the source issue to all the candidates in my electorate. I usually get blank stares over this point. This worries my deeply as how can someone who does not understand the implications of what they are doing legislate laws about it. I would like to see it done better. No idea how but perhaps the taking of a test to prove some level of knowledge before being allowed to vote on any issue.
- jacques_chester 12y agoAsk the candidates if they would be happy if paper ballots were counted without scrutineers. Or with scrutineers from only one party, who have quietly replaced electoral officials.
- boyter 12y agoThats a good point. I shall be doing that the next time one is at my local train station.
- rodgerd 12y ago> and on balance I'd say an electronic system should be able to do better Based on what evidence? Paper fraud requires a physical presence, and the scope is limited to what a person or group of people can achieve. Breaching electronic systems can happen on the server or client (conversations around the latter are noticeably absent from arguments by e-voting proponents). Breaches can be orchestrated from anywhere, including locations which with no extradition agreement, and can use botnets to scale infinitely.