3 ms·
Lag and poor visibility. Drones work on slow ground attack convoys and buildings where they can fly around for a time but they are controlled via satelites so
by tomjen3 12y ago
Lag and poor visibility.
Drones work on slow ground attack convoys and buildings where they can fly around for a time but they are controlled via satelites so there is a couple of seconds of lag between when the image is recorded and the orders are received by the drone.
In a dog fight, which is really what you have to build a fighter plane for, that kind of lag means you lose every time. Add to that that drones are too slow, have no agility and little to no armour and they are going to be completely useless even against obsolete planes - SAA (Assad) show down one a few days ago.
The US has stealth drones, but that is only useful till you are discovered. If you are going faster than the speed of sound that is one thing, but these drones are not.
- Diederich 12y agoI wonder how possible it would be construct UAVs that were specialized for air to air combat. They could operate in something of a hybrid mode, perhaps with ground control most of the time, but acting in full automatic mode during the dogfighting. There'd be a lot of advantages. I presume such a dogfighting UAV would have visibility in all directions, all the time. They could potentially pull much tighter turns than any aircraft with a human on board, and with real-time point to point communication, could work together in ways that are impossible with human flown fighters. Part of me wonders if a lot of the amazing game AI that has been developed could apply directly to such a project.
- vacri 12y agoDogfights are a thing of the past. Fighters don't joust at close distances anymore. I did a small part of my degree at a defence research place in the mid-90s. I remember someone showing me an experiment on how best to present range information about other planes to a fighter pilot, in terms of physical appearance. What was curious was the names for the ranges: 'safe', 'lethal', and 'very lethal'. 'Very lethal' was still several kilometers, and I asked about the guns and dogfighting - and got 'that doesn't happen anymore'. More significant issues are speed, weather, and payload size. If you need fighter cover now, you don't want to hear "but it's raining". And speed is needed to increase operational range and response time.
- Symmetry 12y agoI imagine the problem with control is to just direct semi-autonomous UCAVs from an AWACS. Current drones are slow and have little agility but that's due to them being optimized for cost and loiter time. The MASTAC Frisbees used at the Navy Fighter Tactics school could pull 15 G turns, for instance.