3 ms·
The bulk of the requirements for the F-35 are perfectly reasonable; a stealthier replacement for the F-16 and F/A-18, which essentially perform the same role bu
by philwelch 12y ago
The bulk of the requirements for the F-35 are perfectly reasonable; a stealthier replacement for the F-16 and F/A-18, which essentially perform the same role but the Air Force chose one and the Navy chose the other. If you could get a next generation light fighter-bomber to replace both, and make it stealthy enough to replace the F-117 at the same time, that would be the perfectly reasonable aircraft. As it stands, the Navy already hedged their bets with the F/A-18E/F Super Hornet, which has been a complete success.
The only thing that did in the Joint Strike Fighter was the requirement to develop a STOVL close-air-support platform for the Marine Corps, to replace the Harrier. That should have been a separate project. STOVL and conventional aircraft have entirely different aerodynamic requirements, and there's no real requirement for a stealth close-air-support platform because it's not like the enemy isn't going to notice the slowly hovering jet plane that's strafing them and shooting missiles at them. But it's so hard to get Congress to fund any replacement aircraft at all that everyone decided to go ahead and put all their hopes and dreams and lobbying efforts behind a single plane.
- hackuser 12y ago> it's not like the enemy isn't going to notice the slowly hovering jet plane that's strafing them and shooting missiles at them I thought the STOVL was designed to enable take off and landing without airfields and aircraft carriers. Are you sure the intent is that it will hover over the battlefield while attacking? Current planes seem to hit targets fine while flying at a much safer hundreds of miles/hour.
- tankenmate 12y agoThe main platform for Marine STOVLs is pocket carriers; littoral assault carriers that lack cats and traps. Quite often they also carry amphibious landing craft as well.[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amphibious_assault_ship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amphibious_assault_ship
- acveilleux 12y agoIt's not going to hover, that would be insane (in fuel use if nothing else) but the USMC wants/needs a close air support platform. A jet that will fly sufficiently low and slow to attack ground targets effectively. Even when the friendly troops are only a few hundred meters away. That's intrinsically different from the Air Force and Navy whose planes will spend their time closer to 30k feet then 3k feet. Flight at low altitudes and speed requires fundamentally different characteristics then flight at high altitude and comparatively high speed.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- engi_nerd 12y ago> It's not going to hover, that would be insane (in fuel use if nothing else) Really nerdy aside: it would also be insane with regards to hot gas ingestion. There would be a very high likelihood that the engine would take in the missile exhaust if launches happened in the semi-jet-borne or jet-borne regions.