17 ms·
The Need for Care with “Thoughtcrime”
- escherize 12y agoIt seems like our freedoms are being eroded more every day. I would like to see a discussion about the best actionable steps we can take to stop. Is donating to the eff the best I can hope for?
- cbd1984 12y agoIf you think this, your perspective must be limited to a pre-1970s worldview, or you must not know much about how much freedoms were stomped on before things like Roe v Wade and the current notion of a strong freedom of speech protection.
- verbin217 12y agoYou've just expanded the time horizon until something was apparently worse than the present. That doesn't refute a local decline.
- PhasmaFelis 12y agoA few decades ago, this guy could have been convicted for "obscenity" and no one would have said a word. The question of whether he intended anyone actual harm might never have come up. It's a sign of progress that we now frown on imprisoning people explicitly for being icky and weird, and thoughtcrime prosecutors are forced to gin up more serious charges.
- zo1 12y agoIt's democracy, right? So then I would suggest rallying people to your cause, and trying to force some sort of adhoc vote/referendum from your leaders. If you get some sort of majority with you to participate in a concerted effort, and still your leaders deny you your voice. Well, then, you're not in a democracy, my friend. Not even a representative one.
- byuu 12y agoThankfully the district court judge was the only person in the courtroom besides the defendant capable of distinguishing fantasy from reality. Now if only he could have levied criminal sanctions against the prosecutor in this case. It's terrifying how these juries think. It really is as simple as, "Have any of you played Grand Theft Auto? Does that make you all car thieves? Have you watched Saw? Does that make you serial killers? No? Then why are we here?" That people will vote to convict a man simply because they don't like what he thinks about, and that these cases can get this far in the first place, is absolutely terrifying. People really have become too stupid for a jury of one's peers to result in a fair trial. What do you think these people would do if this man had an impossible fetish, like petrification or gigantism? "Your honor, clearly the defendant had conspired to turn a woman in real life into a 50-foot tall statue. We must lock him up before he is able to do so."
- thaumasiotes 12y ago> "Your honor, clearly the defendant had conspired to turn a woman in real life into a 50-foot tall statue. We must lock him up before he is able to do so." Without disagreeing with you, I think most people "like this" would accept that argument. But there's no urgency there, because he'll never be able to do so. My mother advanced to me once the opinion that someone with a foot fetish should be legally barred from going into podiatry. I was shocked that people could think that way. :/
- croon 12y agoIndeed. Clearly you can't separate work and play and cure breast cancer if you're into boobs. /s
- pekk 12y ago> It's terrifying how these juries think. Two words: jury selection.
- noonespecial 12y agoIts ridiculously easy to get out of jury duty. Don't.
- paulsutter 12y agoMad props to Scott & Cyan Banister whose First Amendment Clinic at UCLA[1] funded part of this effort. Scott[2] was with IronPort, PowerSet, Slide, among many other companies, and is setting a great example for other entrepreneurs. [1] https://www.law.ucla.edu/academics/clinical-and-experiential-programs/the-clinical-experience/banister-first-amendment-clinic/ https://www.law.ucla.edu/academics/clinical-and-experiential... [2] https://www.linkedin.com/in/banister https://www.linkedin.com/in/banister
- masmullin 12y agoI find this terrifying. It makes me want to scream and cry at the same time.
- spiritplumber 12y agoThis is what happens when people actively try to get out of jury duty. The smart ones succeed. The derp ones less so.
- pekk 12y agoThe smart ones get out of jury duty anyway, because the lawyers select them out if they are honest enough to show signs of critical thinking. And smart Machiavellians have no reason to waste their time on it.
- Potando 12y agoTalking about committing a crime isn't thoughtcrime. It's perhaps better called a "speechcrime". It's already illegal for all sorts of things. Conspiracy of course is one way. There's also incitement and threats, as well as "intent". That last one is more of a true thoughtcrime. The real world effect of manslaughter is the same as murder, but the distinction lies with what the person was thinking.
- impossiblegame 12y agoThe NYMag article linked within describes exactly why rational people should be scared of those who state obsessive desires to torture and kill people, especially when they've chosen their targets. Two close friends of the profiled from their torture forum: "[Robert] Asch [former school librarian, previously accused of molesting four boys] brought with him a bag containing a Taser, meat hammer, skewers, and a dental retractor." There are few times I'm happy to see intervention by a federal agent but imminent torture and murder is one. His buddy and accomplice arrested for the same scheme, Richard Meltz, is a police chief who used his access to gather data about potential victims. Valle himself is a cop who stalked his intended female victims on paid time using police resources. He described graphically how he wanted to torture, dismember, and kill them. One was his wife and several were women he knew previously who didn't reciprocate his sexual interest. He gave out their identifying details, which he obtained using his position of authority, to a bunch of psychopaths who are clearly willing to act. These are all specific, credible threats of murder. If the power dynamics were different I wonder how this thread would go down? If, instead of a message board for men wishing to kill women, it were a message board for Muslims wanting to kill Christians, would you react the same way? What if specific people have been targeted - would you defend the aggressor's right to free speech over the targeted's right to live? What if the aggressor's friends were found carrying everyone they needed to torture and kill the targeted? Would you really defend that free speech?
- tomjen3 12y agoRead the story. It specifically says that nobody was targeted and no offline activity took place. Your muslims vs christians doesn't come in here.
- rayiner 12y agoIt's not a story, it's a press release. And EFF is more creative with the facts in their press releases than I'm comfortable with.[1] See: http://m.nydailynews.com/new-york/cannibal-faces-life-guilty-conspiracy-kidnap-illegal-databases-article-1.1286075 http://m.nydailynews.com/new-york/cannibal-faces-life-guilty.... He did use the NYPD police database to access information about a high school girl, and was convicted of it based on records of the access. He did send another member a file documenting the murder of one of his friends just before meeting her in person. He did talk about murdering and eating his wife. I still don't think there was the required "overt act" but it wasn't just abstract fantasizing like the EFF is making it out to be. [1] Public interest organizations can be just as bad as cops in this regard (ACLU is an exception). I stopped getting Public Citizen emails when they described an a teenager who had just been with a group of friends when someone else shot someone, and was sentenced to life. They failed to mention the kid was with a gang of other teenagers who brutally robbed and murdered a pizza delivery driver while his wife and child sat in the back seat. If you mention the facts, people might get outraged at the guy you're defending.
- angdis 12y agoI basically agree with the judge throwing out the verdict. However, I don't like the usage of the word "thoughtcrime" here. This was not "thoughtcrime." It was a very creepy freak who wrote online, at length, about performing some extremely disgusting violent crimes. Such behavior outside of the right context is going to raise alarm and cause people to start snooping around. And of course getting identified should rightfully trigger termination for a police officer.