3 ms·
Thanks for the advice and links! I always appreciate when a stranger takes time to help me. I'm going to check out the Felleisen stuff, but my concern is that
by smt88 12y ago
Thanks for the advice and links! I always appreciate when a stranger takes time to help me.
I'm going to check out the Felleisen stuff, but my concern is that it's so much more academic than anything I'll have time to do. The difference between what I'm doing and a college class is that I don't have time to lay groundwork. I can't explain how much of the underlying systems work, even though I think it's really important.
That might seem like I'm taking issue with the concept of a boot camp, but it's actually the opposite. I want to prove, at least to myself, that a boot camp can be truly valuable and provide long-term education value. That means teaching modeling, good habits, and good practices more than teaching how the stack works.
> pretending that web programming is a snowflake looks a bit like an excuse
I don't think I made my point clearly. Beginning web programming (at least in Ruby, Python, PHP, and Node) doesn't require an understanding of many underlying concepts that you'd need to know to write in, say, C. By the time you need to know how the compiler optimizes things, how memory is allocated, or when to fork vs. spawn, you're probably beyond the scope of a boot camp (and hopefully dealing with lots of traffic!)
The core of the problem isn't that I'd be teaching web programming. It's that I have very limited time, and while not much of the concepts are complex, there's too much to cover in even a year of classes.
> dismissive attitude
> hopping on the boot camp gravy train
> matter of taste
Since I do appreciate your advice, I'll give you some.
You seem to enjoy helping people on HN, just like I do. That's what motivates me to teach: I love helping people, especially to do something I think they'll enjoy (and can make them more financially stable).
On HN especially, I often perceive two motivations for helping: to genuinely share knowledge and experience, or to feel superior. Sometimes these are intermixed a bit, of course.
If your goal is truly to share your knowledge and experience, then you shouldn't taint it with the implied judgments, presumptions, and condescension that I've highlighted above. If your goal is, instead, to feel superior, then I hope this is fulfilling you in whatever way you're not intrinsically fulfilled.
And, on a related note, I'm not going to study anything Zed Shaw says about anything because his online persona is repugnant. It may be my own bias, but I don't trust the suggestions of a teacher who acts like a spiteful child on the internet and takes pleasure in verbally attacking others. I've never heard of a great teacher who behaved that way -- in fact, my great teachers have all been incredibly patient, kind, and magnanimous.
- brudgers 12y agoI have far more interest in helping the students than for helping you find excuses not to approach teaching as a profession in itself, and I get the sense if I mentioned Maria Montessori or John Dewey the response would be, "But they weren't teaching web programming at a boot camp." Learning about pedagogy will help you prepare a better curriculum. That will serve your students better than the alternative. Don't get me wrong, there's nothing wrong with someone just being in it for the money. But my interest is not in helping people rationalize what is fully legal but ethically slides down slope towards a make-a-buck-scam. And that's what comes to mind when I see "bootcamp" these days to a first approximation. Sure, I think there are some reasonably good bootcamps. I don't think they correlate with hiring people with no training experience and little interest in developing knowledge in the pedagogical practice. Maybe you will make this one exceed my naive expectations. At least that's my hope. Zed Shaw has a strong background in the pedagogy of situations where people die from mistakes. He takes teaching seriously in accord with that experience. That leads to some admirable traits and some that are less so. Being rude doesn't make someone wrong, though sometimes it just makes someone a dick.
- smt88 12y agoI now understand the motivation behind your tone, and I think it's very noble. If this boot camp isn't valuable to the students, it would violate my own ethics to do it. My original question wasn't about how to teach, but about what to teach. As for the "how", your points are all well taken, and I will give Shaw's work a look after all. It can't hurt. I come from a family of professional teachers and have no intention of diluting the meaning of teaching. At the same time, the people who join boot camps are obviously looking for something less time-consuming than a full degree program, while still valuable. I know I can provide that (and have taught web languages before).
- brudgers 12y agoThe what of teaching is the curriculum. Zed Shaw's skill is in developing curricula. That comes from a careful attention to the how, not the what. Hence the multiple curricula. His interview on Hanselminutes is a great place to start: http://hanselminutes.com/407/learning-code-the-hard-way-with-zed-shaw http://hanselminutes.com/407/learning-code-the-hard-way-with... I'm not suggesting Zed Shaw as the end all and be all. Kathy Sierra's approach is an alternative (though requiring more effort to implement): http://www.objectsbydesign.com/books/KathySierra.html http://www.objectsbydesign.com/books/KathySierra.html In the end, the focus shouldn't be on teaching what you know, but the relevant part of what you will know after rigorous preparation. The big question isn't about whether the students will all work on a standardized project or one of their own choosing. The big question is what specific knowledge, skill and ability that project must reflect.