4 ms·
I am actually surprised that ecosystems on Earth somehow are in an equilibrium, with plants converting as much carbon back into oxygen as animals convert back,
by EGreg 12y ago
I am actually surprised that ecosystems on Earth somehow are in an equilibrium, with plants converting as much carbon back into oxygen as animals convert back, on a global scale.
I mean, how does evolution explain that? We once had a near exinction for anaerobic bacteria, because of all the oxygen they produced, at least that's the theory. But the feedback mechanism is through such a global thing (amount of CO2 in the atmosphere) that it is a wonder to me how the populations don't just enter a tragedy of the commons.
- nitrogen 12y agoI don't think it's right to say that Earth is in "equilibrium"; it's always changing, with or without us (though it's changing faster with us). But the feedback mechanism is through such a global thing (amount of CO2 in the atmosphere) that it is a wonder to me how the populations don't just enter a tragedy of the commons. If oxygen-using species generate more carbon dioxide, plants grow better, producing more oxygen. No tragedy of the commons here once the feedback is in place. We're also talking about geological time scales.
- crpatino 12y agoThat's survivor bias. Earth looks in equilibrium to us because it changes very, very slowly... and we happen to evolve to make the most out of the current set of conditions. But I'd bet that to the living organisms of the Cambrian period, the current state of our planet would look like a complete (though slowly improving) wreck.