4 ms·
> This data comes from a unified Google Analytics profile I wish my tax dollars were not being spent to help a for-profit entity track me across the Web.
by smacktoward 12y ago
> This data comes from a unified Google Analytics profile
I wish my tax dollars were not being spent to help a for-profit entity track me across the Web.
- thomasjames 12y agoI think using a pre-existing software service as a base instead of a massive handmade distributed system may not be a bad idea for the USG. Remember the healthcare.gov rollout? Although it is certainly a government contract to a private corporation, the cause is warranted since it helps the federal government better allocate resources and make funding decisions. Your comment does raise the question, though, of whether the Digital Analytics Program managing the account requested any safeguards for user privacy or are just using the standard free or premium service. There was an article earlier around the launch of healthcare.gov that raised the same privacy issues you are now relating to Google Analytics, but I can't remember who published it.
- wpietri 12y agoIf you'd like to opt out, try this: https://tools.google.com/dlpage/gaoptout https://tools.google.com/dlpage/gaoptout It says, "Available for Microsoft Internet Explorer 8-11, Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, Apple Safari and Opera". Personally, I prefer this to having my tax dollars spent on reinventing web analytics. Especially given that it wouldn't be cheap; Google bought what is now Google Analytics in 2005 for circa $30 million [1] and has put a lot into improving it since. And now that I think about it, I'm not sure that tax dollars are, net, being spent here. GA is very easy to install, and good analytics typically help save money through better decisions and focusing effort on what's actually being used. [1] http://searchenginewatch.com/sew/news/2062461/google-to-acquire-urchin-web-analytics-firm http://searchenginewatch.com/sew/news/2062461/google-to-acqu...
- teacup50 12y agoOpt-out, really? We shouldn't have to opt-out of something that shouldn't be happening in the first place. The government shouldn't be inserting a 3rd-party -- Google -- into my communications with them! As for this: > ... and good analytics typically help save money through better decisions and focusing effort on what's actually being used. Pffft. That's only true for startups whose sole goal is maximizing traffic/retention/whatever while absolutely minimizing the amount of creativity they expend on moving those "key performance metrics".
- nemothekid 12y ago>The government shouldn't be inserting a 3rd-party -- Google -- into my communications with them! I'd think you would be surprised to discover that the government has been using 3rd parties for years to manage various services. Did you know the government also uses Oracle databases to store your information?
- coroutines 12y agoSimilarly, we should stop caring about domestic surveillance by the gov because the gov has been doing it for years and we've only learned of it now. /s Btw, using Google Analytics is a lot different than using an Oracle database - Oracle isn't privy to what you're storing.
- nemothekid 12y ago>Oracle isn't privy to what you're storing. Do you work at Oracle? Are you 100% sure this is true? Have you audited all the hosted 3rd party solutions for the Government, and interviewed every employee to ensure that they aren't privy to your data? Have you ensured that all code written for the US govt has no cryptographic errors? The claim that the US Govt. shouldn't use google analytics because Google can read their data is hardly any different than arguing they shouldn't use managed Oracle solutions because some Oracle exec has access to their data. Where does it end? Should the US Govt. now spend and build their own analytics infrastructure? Should the US Govt. write their own databases? Print their own silicon? And what about everyone else? If a US company isn't trusted by the US Govt to keep data secure, what about insurance companies? Or Healthcare companies? Should these companies too, be also printing their own silicon? How is this a solution? If the problem is privacy, the solution is to create processes that respect privacy. Sitting in the dark because electricity might burn your house down is not a solution. And God forbid that the Govt coerces Google to share data on how people are using their own servers and that they are already making public.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 12y ago
- hobarrera 12y agoHaving to install software so that a government doesn't give your details for free to a for-profit company is actually awful. 30M isn't much, considering the scale at which they run, and considering that it would be something freely available to the public as well. There's also the fact that open source alternatives exist today.
- corobo 12y agoYou'd rather them pay {m,b}illions more making their own system?
- mycroft-holmes 12y agoI'd rather they spend nothing.
- corobo 12y agoSo now they're spending nothing they have no way to know if people are using their sites. They have no idea what sites are useful and what sites are not. Do they assume sites are not being used and have just a "Hi we are the USA" homepage or do they spend money on sites that are never visited Even the government needs analytics friend
- mycroft-holmes 12y agoI'm all for the government not spending any money on any sites.