5 ms·
Yeah :/. I have tons of operational knowledge of email and have been running my own email setup since 1998. My email servers were ever only used for email I typ
by saurik 12y ago
Yeah :/. I have tons of operational knowledge of email and have been running my own email setup since 1998. My email servers were ever only used for email I typed manually by hand (due to being dumb I never even used shortcuts to auto type repetitive responses to customer messages). Then, one day a couple years ago, I realize no one @yahoo.com is getting my email anymore. Talking to Yahoo, I get barely any response and certainly no explanation. I can easily believe that my entire IP block was cut for being a hosting provider.
I now pay some company to deliver my personal mail, which is just dumb, and clearly isn't caused by them being better about spam (as I sent no spam): it is caused by a militarized anti-spam-crazed group of people who have managed to build a system that essentially requires an oligopoly for email to function. A lot of these people don't even consider it a problem to use "report as spam" as a ways to punish companies for things that aren't even sending spam (which is something I only bring up as it demonstrates the "militant" comment).
The reality is that an open internet where people can talk to each other without going through third parties requires a world in which you, heaven forbid, receive some spam. It is actually a similar construction as the one for why we should have network neutrality: large internet carriers in the world of email should, if you really believe in open access, not be allowed to say "these people can't send mail because they are too small and not paying someone". We all need to accept at least a little spam to guarantee everyone can send mail.
If this means that you have to get better at dealing with spam, as some of the heavy-handed techniques people have put in place for dealing with spam are no longer possible, well: so be it; and if that means you need to turn off the notifications for new email on your phone to keep from getting angry when you receive some spam (which tends to come up as a reason to hate spam), I hope people realize that they caused their own reason to be upset, and that getting notifications for anything is probably unhealthy, at least for you, anyway.
Sadly, the large companies who have slowly come to "own email" have no incentive to break this cycle, whether in action or in words, as the current state of affairs is what is giving them their power: whether they build solutions that can solve spam in a way that is both fair and federated, or they just try to educate users about how to better deal with spam and decrease the stress in their lives (including telling people to stop letting email interrupt them), it will just harm them. This doesn't sound like something the private sector can solve.
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> A lot of these people don't even consider it a problem to use "report as spam" as a ways to punish companies for things that aren't even sending spam I get a fair many spams that have "unsubscribe" links, or even that look like newsletters (for companies or organizations of varying legitimacy). I'm always pleased when they come through one of the major mailing list providers that provides a separate "report abuse" link, with which I can report that no, I don't just want to unsubscribe, I want to report that I never subscribed in the first place so that the list itself gets terminated. If it's possible for someone to be subscribed to your "newsletter" without having explicitly consented to doing so (and in the process proving ownership of the subscribing email address), you are sending spam.
- kijin 12y ago> If it's possible for someone to be subscribed to your "newsletter" without having explicitly consented to doing so (and in the process proving ownership of the subscribing email address), you are sending spam. A problem with this attitude is that most people have no idea whether or not they consented. Perhaps they consented in 2003 but don't remember. Perhaps they consented yesterday but want to revoke consent because they're too busy right now to read your newsletter. There's a reason why Gmail silently converts your spam report into an unsubscribe if the correct headers are set. Too many PEBCAK false positives.
- dredmorbius 12y agoIt may be a problem, but that problem is for the sender. If anyone indicates in any way, shape, or form, whatsoever, that they don't want your crap, stop sending it to them. Email is all but useless these days. Postal mail's hardly any better.
- kijin 12y agoNo, the problem is figuring out whether or not to punish the sender. If it's obviously spam, the sender's IP needs to be blacklisted, his hosting account terminated, etc. in order to protect other people. If the recipient just changed his mind about whether he wants to receive a newsletter that he explicitly signed up for less than a week ago, there is no need to punish the sender. The sender just needs to be notified that the recipient unsubscribed. I don't know about you, but if all the social networks, instant messengers, and "we're gonna replace email" startups in the world went dark for 24 hours, I probably wouldn't even notice. They're all but useless to me, after all. But if my email went down for 24 hours, I'd definitely make a big fuss about it. Ditto if someone makes the wrong decision about which senders to block.