4 ms·
Linux and the open source movement pretty much disproves that theory. Better (or "at least as good") quality kernels than the two biggest software companies and
by collyw 12y ago
Linux and the open source movement pretty much disproves that theory. Better (or "at least as good") quality kernels than the two biggest software companies and biggest defenders of intellectual property rights on the planet could manage.
We should really look at the evidence rather than repeating the mantra.
- Yen 12y agoI don't know if Linux/Open Source/Free Software disproves the theory, or actually proves it. The argument would be: Microsoft and Apple feel that existing IP protections on software would not sufficiently prevent competitors or consumers from 'stealing' the results of their work. So, they don't release the source code. Because they don't release the source code, there's a duplication of effort between Microsoft, Apple, and any other kernel-writers. If there existed extremely strong IP protection laws for software, that required release of source (like a patent, basically), then Apple and Microsoft might release source, duplicate less effort, and their disadvantage to Linux would be reduced. Open Source is what happens when you have a system that encourages these secrets to be shared. The only difference is, Linux manages to get R&D effort without the benefit of a monopoly-grant, or indeed, without any direct profit motivation.
- collyw 12y agoApple didn't manage to build a decent kernel themselves so took a "free" one. Nothing to do with stealing their work. You are aware that Apple uses an open source kernel?
- spinlock 12y agoFirst, I was trying to relate the ideas behind the patent system not to describe how it works in practice. So, while I always like to talk about how gnu and Linux took over the world, it's not relavent to the discussion of rents vis a vie patents. Second, Unix is a bad example because AT&T never tried to patent it. I'll ask my dad about it. He worked at bell labs during this time (he has about 2 dozen patents and an IEEE medal). I think the attitude around there was that software wasn't something you could patent. My dads research was in lasers so I heard much more about lightwave devices than software growing up.