7 ms·
Why Egg Freezing Is an Impossible Choice
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jkot 12y agoInstead of this, Apple or Facebook could pay $20,000 to their partners, if they stayed at home with a kid.
- nsxwolf 12y agoMy college educated wife chose to stay home. Some of her friends and family view this as a deliberately provocative anti-feminist choice, and we're in the midwest. I can only imagine those sentiments would be even more common in SV.
- knicholes 12y agoMy wife is also college educated and stays home. I don't see how this is anti-feminist, though. The way I see it, it's a woman choosing to live the way she wants to live. It had never occurred to me that this could be anti-feminist. Then again, I live in Utah where a sizeable portion of the college-educated women major in Family and Consumer Sciences at BYU. Seriously, though. http://registrar.byu.edu/catalog/2011-2012ucat/departments/FamilyLife/FamConsSciEduMajor.php http://registrar.byu.edu/catalog/2011-2012ucat/departments/F... My wife graduated in marketing and has worked and is fully able to work as a professional. I kind of view it as noble for her to bear the responsibility of full-time child rearing. It's undoubtedly a more difficult task than my sitting around on a computer all day occasionally going to meetings with catered lunches. ;)
- webnrrd2k 12y agoI agree - I understand that a key aspect of feminism is "a woman choosing to live the way she wants to live". That means women, as well as men, staying home with the kids, if that's their choice. They shouldn't be forced into traditional roles, but are perfectly welcome to choose them.
- Domenic_S 12y agoMy college educated wife also chose to stay home! She knew that's what she wanted to do before college. I think it's hard to disparage when any partner chooses to stay home -- and isn't choice a core tenant of feminism?
- needacig 12y agoSee my theory here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9236049 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9236049 EDIT: Please, and if you want.
- icebraining 12y agoI agree, and celebrate the choice, but if you feel more strongly about the oppression imposed by customs, it may feel something like seeing a battered wife returning to her aggressor (except the "aggressor" is society, not the husband). That said, even if you think the person made a poor choice, criticism and cutting off relations is a terrible response - in either case!
- blhack 12y agoSomething more important that working? Blasphemy! /s
- Apocryphon 12y agoIndeed, staying at home shouldn't be seen as anti-feminist. It should be seen as contra-modern-capitalism.
- danielweber 12y agoHer friends can suck it. It's your family, you make the decisions, because you live with the consequences. It's cliche, but: if someone stops being your friend because you leave the job market for personal reasons, they were never your friend.
- icebraining 12y agoThat may be true, but I'm guessing it's poor consolation when you're a new parent and have no one to talk to. Isolation and loneliness is a common theme in new mothers.
- needacig 12y agoI don't agree this is an anti-feminist choice, but I think people might see it that way because genuinely anti-feminist people like to claim that a woman's place is in the home and that women's brains aren't really suited for tasks that aren't nurturing. So women staying home to take care of the children, on a surface level, supports this traditional anti-feminist argument and this is why it could be seen as anti-feminist.
- Dewie 12y agoThey think that a woman making a non-traditional[1] choice is anti-feminist? They think that woman should fall in line and do what is expected of her (out of ideology)? How wonderfully ironic. [1] staying at home might as well be the new non-traditional choice. Feminism is now the old guard.
- msoad 12y agoIn many cases the partner is a professional himself and $20k don't get you anywhere with that situation.
- s73v3r 12y agoOr allow more remote work.
- bentcorner 12y ago$20,000 is roughly the cost of childcare for the year. It would be better spent on letting parents use that money towards that, allowing both partners to work. With a large enough population you could probably open an on-site care facility for children, which buys you better employee satisfaction, since you could integrate it with their workplace IT. That said, the $20k is a one time cost to freeze eggs, whereas the $20k you would give (to a partner or other childcare) would cover just one year. The egg freezing seems like the more economical choice, from Apple/FB's point of view.
- zelos 12y agoThere seem like lots of other options that aren't so invasive. Better childcare, flexible/part time working hours, decent maternity/paternity leave, not expecting your employees to dedicate their entire existence to the Company.
- sjg007 12y agoOr offer day care, life balance, work from home etc.. Honestly, having a kid puts you out of the office but not necessarily out of work, especially tasks amenable to remote work.
- throwaway03951 12y agoFunny thing about using the $20,000 benefit for IVF: a clinic charges a lot more, like 2.5 times more, for the same service when going through insurance than when self-paying. With the $20,000 benefit you will end up out-of-pocket paying 50% of the self-pay amount. That is better than nothing but the service is not covered in full.
- golemotron 12y ago> Similarly, Noyes’ team, surveying 183 egg-freezing patients on why they were delaying childbirth, found that just 24 percent cited professional reasons, while 88 percent cited lack of a partner. Are they more likely to find a partner as they get older? That bet could be as large as a bet on the viability of the frozen eggs. Finding a partner and raising a child on one's own both become harder as time goes on. My bet is that most eggs frozen will by younger women for themselves later in life will not be used.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoI feel like I'm uniquely qualified to comment on this, as I'm going through the IVF process with my wife currently. > Are they more likely to find a partner as they get older? Possibly. Maybe not, but you're essentially paying for insurance. > That bet could be as large as a bet on the viability of the frozen eggs. Frozen embryos are extremely viable, as long as you were able to observe their cellular division 3-5 days after fertilization. As long as you can confirm they're viable before freezing, you're almost assured they'll be viable when thawed at a later data in the future (this isn't only from my pubmed research, but also from the top fertility doctor in the Chicagoland area we're using). > Finding a partner and raising a child on one's own both become harder as time goes on. Disagree. In most cases, you're further advanced in your career when older, giving you more income, thereby more purchasing power. You may not find a partner, but daycare is easier to afford, or a part time nanny. Delaying childbirth most likely affords you opportunities not available to those who cut their career prospects early to have children (or who left their career entirely because they had a partner to rely on). Also, more resources available to you means you can be more discerning about your partner selection. > My bet is that most eggs frozen will by younger women for themselves later in life will not be used. Its possible, but like I said above, its insurance. My wife is 30. Whatever eggs we freeze now that we don't use, they are essentially her eggs at 30, and could be used by her at any date in the future. She even has the option to use those eggs with someone else if we're not together at some point in the future (life is long). TL;DR Freezing your eggs is an insurance policy against the future. EDIT: Due to reasons I'd rather not make public beyond what I've shared above, I've contacted institutions who are doing research in coercing stem cells into egg or sperm cells. I expect in the next 10 years for this to be a solved problem, and the egg retrieval process to be deprecated in favor of a quick blood draw and incubation period to coax stem cells to reproductive cells. But unfortunately, this isn't solved yet.
- Domenic_S 12y agoCtrl+F "pain" - nothing. Egg retrieval hurts, and OHSS is severely underreported. REs for whatever reason do NOT like to officially diagnose OHSS.
- jpatokal 12y ago> Female fertility declines sharply at 37 This, by the way, is largely a myth. Obviously fertility decreases with age, but it's a gradual tapering off until menopause, not a cliff at 37 (or 35 or 40 or any other red line). ~80% of women aged 35 to 40 can still conceive within a year. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fertility#Female_fertility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fertility#Female_fertility
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Domenic_S 12y agoThe risk of defects is more salient and does indeed cliff. Risk of having a child with Down Syndrome: At age 20, 1 in 1,441 At age 25, 1 in 1,383 At age 30, 1 in 959 At age 35, 1 in 338 At age 40, 1 in 84 At age 45, 1 in 32 At age 50, 1 in 44 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_maternal_age#Risk_of_birth_defects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_maternal_age#Risk_of_b...
- cjbprime 12y agoIt's a different kind of risk, though. In the last few years "cell-free DNA tests" -- sequencing fetal cells that are circulating in the mother's bloodstream -- have become common (and paid for by health insurance), and they detect chromosomal abnormality as early as 8 weeks into the pregnancy. If you aren't ethically opposed to abortion, the risk of Down's can be the "well, damn, guess we'll try again in a few months" sort of risk.
- differentView 12y ago>If you aren't ethically opposed to abortion, the risk of Down's can be the "well, damn, guess we'll try again in a few months" sort of risk. You say that as if there is no emotional, psychological, and physical costs to an abortion. The costs is often to both partners and marriage/relationship.
- 12y ago
- dougmccune 12y agoThis has been a huge topic of conversation for my wife and I for the past few years. Our entire social circle is the exact target demographic: early thirties, highly educated, career focused, etc etc. We got married earlier than nearly all our friends (age 28). We've had two kids before most of our friends are married. Our friends are now closing in on 35 and now thinking about how to have a family is becoming a serious concern. We were a generation raised being told consistently that a woman should be career focused, pursue as much education as possible, and that you don't have to ever worry about finding a partner and having kids until you're ready. And now we have friends freezing eggs, considering how to start a family without a partner while they can still easily have kids, etc. It just feels like the pendulum has swung too far in terms of my generation's expectations (or maybe naiveté). You can't change biology. It will be interesting to see what kind of advice I give my daughter when she's an adult, but I'm hoping her generation has a bit more of a middle-ground approach to thinking about the balance between career and starting a family.
- rayiner 12y agoIf you want to get married and have kids, you should just do it. My wife and I had our daughter while we she was still in law school and I had just graduated. Taking care of a kid is a lot of work while both working long hours at big firms, but why that's what grandparents are for. There is no good time to be sleep deprived for months doing night feedings. At least in your 20's you have the energy and your parents are young enough to help out!
- patmcc 12y agoThe hugely surprising fact of the article, for me, was: "Just 2,000 babies have been born from cryogenically frozen eggs in the world" That's crazy to me; this all sounds like a huge bet on complete unknowns. I also wonder if this is going to be the end of grandparents in affluent circles - if people wait until their 40s for kids, and their kids do the same...not much time to hang out with grandma and grandpa.
- chriskanan 12y agoThis issue has been weighing heavily on me. My Dad was 36 when I was born and is now 70 years old. My fiance and I are both professionals and have our kids planned for 2018 when she is done working 80 hour weeks. By then my Dad will be around 74. Considering my grandfather died at 85, that doesn't leave a whole lot of time left to have a big impact. Plus, that likely means I won't have much time with my potential grandchildren either if my children also don't have kids until their late 30s and assuming quality lifespan doesn't increase dramatically.
- mjn 12y agoFor better or worse, this is more historically common with men, even in previous generations. Both of my parents' fathers were in their late 40s when they were born, in the 1940s. And yes, that left the fathers quite old when their kids grew up, and very old by the time they were or could have been grandfathers. My paternal grandfather died before I was born, and I only knew my maternal grandfather because he lived to a quite old age (he was in his 70s when I was a young kid, and lived into his 90s). There are elevated risks of some diseases with older men, but fertility declines slowly, so it hasn't needed space-age technology for that kind of generational structure to emerge.
- patmcc 12y agoI'm in a very similar boat - my parents were 48 and 38 when I was born (I'm 29), so they're really starting to get old. My wife and I decided screw it, we're going to have kids now, despite not being in the best places professionally. It might be tough, but we're still in a much better place than ~75% of people when they start having kids, and we think we'll figure it out. And so, this morning, we got to hear our kid's heartbeat for the first time. It's scary, and the idea of not being in the "ideal" job is worrying, and doubly so for my wife (who still needs some more experience to get her professional designation), but kids/pregnancy is sadly not something that can be put off indefinitely without consequences. So we bought the bullet, and we're going to make it work.
- davidf18 12y agoSeifer, et. al. 2014 - Putting 'family' back in family planning http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25406182 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25406182 A lot of people who do not understand fertility (female fecundity -- the ability to conceive) and others give wrong info from comments I've seen here. The Amerian Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) the doctors orgninzation of fertilty doctors (called Reproductive Endocrinologists) says that women are most likely to conceive in their 20's to early 30's. Elite egg donor agencies that offer $20,000 for donor eggs in Ivy League student newspapers want donors under 29 or 28. Studies show that 3 out of 4 men and women overestimate by five years the rapid decline in fecundity believing that it is 40 when it is in fact 35. The ASRM does not yet recommend egg freezing for delaying childbirht but rather for situations such as chemotherapy for cancer which would destroy the eggs in the ovaries. Fertility speicalists (S. Silber and others) recommend that if women expect to wait beyond 30 to have children they should have an antral folllicle count ultrasound at age 25. Other fertilty speciialsts have recommended other tests at age 25 (eg, FSH, or anti-Mullerian hormone). There are no non-invasive tests to test for ovarian reserve which varies from woman to woman. Unfortunately, studies shiow that doctors (include those internetists that might write birth control medication perscriptions) don't have any better understanding of ages of female fertilty than the general public. Obstetricians do know but they don't always discuss the age issues with their patients. In summary, women should consider getting a test for their ovarian reserve (antral follicle count ultrasound or above mentioned laboratory tests sooner rather than later) so that they can make informed decisions. The article listed above and its references will provide a lot of information. * Consult reproductive endocrinologists for correct information about fecundity.
- sjg007 12y agoNobody talks about this but fertility rapidly declines in your 30s especially after 35. Egg freezing should be done as early as possible, aka in your 20s, even then the odds that you will have a live birth after thawing are low. That being said, there is the viable alternative of using an egg donor which relies on fertile young women.
- cinquemb 12y agoMakes me wonder if/when the market for this grows, if we'll start to see financial products built on this (maybe to help offset the costs of such, or to hedge risks for a company that may solicit in relatively financially risky behaviors?) à la egg futures[0] concept Hanson discuses? [0] http://www.overcomingbias.com/2014/10/why-not-egg-futures.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2014/10/why-not-egg-futures.ht...
- EdSharkey 12y agoThe intensity of pain and grief one can feel when they or their spouse have fertility issues is tough to convey. Most people have no idea what a hell this fertility thing can be. It's such a lonely condition, no one wants to talk about it, and no one wants to hear about it. And when someone makes a juvenile joke about eggs, wombs, etc. around me and my wife or if we get some dumbass comment like "when are you going to have another kid?", I can tell you that that person is PERMANENTLY tainted with the #asshole hashtag and we're probably going to have a tearfilled conversation that night. If you fancy yourself a comedian and you want to make some jokes about procreation, don't be shocked when friends fall away from you. I don't know if egg freezing should be recommended, whether it might lead to birth defects or developmental issues, etc. But, if it were available to me and my wife early in our marriage and we knew we might have troubles, I think we might have sprung for it. Here's my PSA: age 35 is when egg quality and quantity starts to decline precipitously for most women. If you're interested in doing this egg freezing or embryo freezing thing, plan to get it done well before age 35 (like age 30, just to be safe.)
- gcr 12y agoIt's a lot easier to sell something when you frame the issue as one of loss avoidance. "You should do X, because if you don't do X right away, then this bad thing may happen in the future! By the way, it only costs $N0,000... But your baby's life is on the line!" I can't think of a much more convincing sell for this target market than that if I tried. Something about this feels off to me. When viewed in the right light, this almost looks like blackmail, or extortion.
- jarjoura 12y agoAre couples so egotistical that they can only imagine having a kid that is genetically theirs? If you want to delay family life and work on your career, why is it not an obvious option to adopt when you're ready? Also, I do think companies need to start offering 6-month packages for parents, both the father and mother. There's too much wealth floating around for this to still not be a thing.
- irremediable 12y agoYou make a good point, although you phrase it very provocatively. Genetics can be a big deal, for many reasons. At the basic level, the desire to have children is a desire to promulgate one's genes. I agree with you in that I don't care, myself; but I don't think it's fair to judge the people who do care.
- restalis 12y ago"I agree with you in that I don't care, myself; but I don't think it's fair to judge the people who do care." And through natural selection, those kind of people (who care, that is) will dominate the human genetic pool, while the ones susceptible to falling into the provider role will systematically be weeded out, like it or not!
- irremediable 12y agoHaha, not necessarily so. For one thing, memetics might trump genetics. Cultural changes might heavily outweigh any genetic selection effect. If enough people adopt children and then encourage those children to adopt when they're older, it could easily outweigh genetic effects. For another thing, people who care might be less reproductively successful on average. This is a bit more fanciful, but IMO is more plausible than it sounds. Perhaps people who care about that stuff won't have as many children because they're more picky, for example, or for any other reason that might correlate with that preference.
- restalis 12y ago
- shin_lao 12y agoReproduction is not just a biological act where a male gamete meets a female gamete. The hardest part of the process is finding the person with whom you want to have a child and who will be your partner in life for this incredibly complex challenge that is raising children. I question the ethics behind relieving thousands of dollars to affluent women while making them believe it will somehow solve their existential need. There is no way around balancing work and life if you want to have children.
- tiatia 12y agoIt is an outstanding idea. Do you know the best thing about having a kid in your 50ies? You don't have to worry about college costs since you will be dead....
- Sophistifunk 12y agoGoddammit, I thought this was about cooking.
- mindfulgeek 12y agoI was offered egg-freezing before beginning one of those "sterilizing" chemotherapy treatments. While it was great to have the option, the last thing I wanted to put my already dying body through was hormone therapy and surgery... Years after treatment, I was in "menopause" and not a candidate for fertility treatment (fsh > 50 AMH = .17). My only hope was a donor egg. My husband and I naturally conceived in July and our baby boy is coming in a few weeks. I share this not because I think every woman can have babies, but because our science is still limited in understanding conception. There is a lot more to creating life than what we can "see" at the moment.