2 ms·
The crux of what USG is saying 'Helping a person who exposed our spying programs shows that you must not want the benefits of them'. Please detach yourself and
by mindslight 12y ago
The crux of what USG is saying 'Helping a person who exposed our spying programs shows that you must not want the benefits of them'. Please detach yourself and look at it from their perspective - does this really seem unreasonable?
The vice chancellor's statement is phrased to be as incendiary as possible, to throw USG under the bus and make it sound like the German government and USG are two separate entities with some high level information sharing. But given the USG military/listening outputs in Germany, how could anyone possibly think this is the case? The people in both sides' intelligence services are trying to protect against similar "threats" and their perspectives are more alike than different. We've seen specifics with FVEY, and it's prudent to assume that all USG allies are in similar conspiracies, with the countries' relative power just determining how many bargaining chips they have. Make no mistake - The German government is benefiting greatly from this information exchange and would never want to lose access.
Now, please don't peg me as defending this state of affairs. I'd love to see justice be served through political means, and I'd really love to see USG get taken down a few pegs to prevent the otherwise inevitable catastrophic collapse of the US. But justice isn't the driving force here - power is. And power tends to coalesce. If you find yourself thinking of a distinction between strategic information (wouldn't be shared with Russia) and protecting against terrorists threats (should be shared freely), you've entered their operating paradigm wherein governments protect each other by monitoring all individuals for threats.
NSA isn't the only entity doing full takes; it's just a (now prominent) nucleation point. Even if they disbanded tomorrow, many others will still be tapping those cables. The only way to protect against black hats, especially well coordinated global ones, is to secure the communications themselves.