5 ms·
"Will the majority of humanity be enslaved to rent-seekers who own patents on a robot hinge?" Actually, that's easy: No. Humanity will not be enslaved to a sma
by jerf 12y ago
"Will the majority of humanity be enslaved to rent-seekers who own patents on a robot hinge?"
Actually, that's easy: No. Humanity will not be enslaved to a small number of capital owners.
But the reason isn't necessarily a happy one, which is that humanity will revolt and start destroying and probably kill lots of people and even potentially kill the goose laying the golden egg by destroying the robotic infrastructure. Should they fail to destroy it, then you still face questions as to who ends up with the power and how it is distributed after the fact; you can find places in history where there was a lot of blood and violence on a recurring basis to answer the question "who gets the power?" because the matter wasn't settled even after the first victory.
That's the outcome I'm more worried about, not the possibility of somehow getting 99% of the population "enslaved".
- toomuchtodo 12y agoI think you're wrong. Humanity won't destroy the golden goose. The next Aaron Swartz will release it to the public, whether that's distributing the software to everyone, or finding a way to freely build/distribute high-level robotics. Just as Prometheus brought fire to the humans, someone will find a way to prevent the future from being locked away. Once you achieve the necessary level of automation, you only need one fabricator that can build the next.
- gohrt 12y agoYou are ignoring the cost of acquiring resources. Robots will run society before the problem of unlimited energy is solved.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoEnough sunlight hits earth every 5 minutes to power all of civilization for a year. The energy is unlimited, the challenge is collection.
- prteja11 12y agoYou might like this: The Last Question by Isaac Asimov http://www.thrivenotes.com/the-last-question/ http://www.thrivenotes.com/the-last-question/
- toomuchtodo 12y agoOne of my favorites! I won't spoil the ending...
- Consultant32452 12y agoAll I need to do is shut down one of the robot overlords, root it, and flash it with Cyanogenmod. I don't need much in the way of resources to do that.
- avn2109 12y agoThis seems to me very implausible, because our panem et circenses are too good today. People will be too busy with their comfy couches and Netflix, their NFL, their darknet hashish, and their Instagram to revolt. Also, the system is tuned so that labor servility is high (by setting the price of housing and medicine such that the people must scramble all the time to meet basic expenses) so idleness and therefore active discontent is rare.
- exelius 12y agoI don't think revolt is an inevitable outcome for a number of reasons. I actually think it's very unlikely. First, the warfare would be very asymmetric, with much of the war fighting capability automated through the very robotics that empower the capital class economically. Go ahead and ask the Taliban / ISIS what happens when you try to fight a modern military force in 2015 with weapons from 1970. If you don't have the money, you can't afford the newest weapons. If you don't have the newest weapons, you'll be fighting an asymmetric war from the weak position. Second, it is in the best interests of the capital class to keep the underclasses happy. You see this tactic in a lot of developing countries like Mexico or India - the government subsidizes energy, food, etc. for the poor; meanwhile the rich run roughshod over the economy. So while people may dislike the lack of upward mobility, they are also dependent on the system (which is largely funded by the capital class), so there's very little will to change. If you give people just enough that they fear losing it, they will continue to vote for you.
- jerf 12y ago"I don't think revolt is an inevitable outcome for a number of reasons." Sorry, I wasn't clear. My comment was a reply, and was taking the parent as a given. If a very small cabal of capital owners tries to enslave the whole of humanity, then it won't be stable because humanity will revolt. And it is unlikely to come to that, for the reasons you state. Interestingly, "large swathes of humanity enslaved" is actually a thing that has happened in the past, but in the past, the slaves were what we'd consider radically poor, and the enslaving states were not high-skill affairs. I also disagree that merely keeping people happy-ish will suffice. We do have, as someone else says, "bread and circuses" today, but there's still a lot of people bitching about "income inequality", pushing for ever more wealth transfers to them, and hinting at if not outright threatening violence any time there's any suggestion that those will be taken away. I see no evidence there's a level of wealth that satisfies people in the longterm, and the capital owners can never be wealthy enough to satisfy humanity in the long term. You'd have to re-engineer humanity to have some concept of "enough" built into them. Eventually the capital owners will be forced to reckon with something. If nothing else, eventually the remaining people who are still doing some sort of work are simply going to go on strike. Humans are rarely happy with the amount of wealth they have, and historically speaking, it seems giving them more makes that problem worse, not better.
- Houshalter 12y agoTechnology is making war increasingly unfair. If you look in the past, a decent percentage of wars were won even one one side had massively less resources. Not the majority, but still like 30% IIRC. With mass surveillance you can detect and stomp out rebellions long before they amount to anything. With automation you barely even need the support of your own troops. With modern technology you can keep most of the population fed and happy enough they aren't willing to risk fighting. And so we could get stable authoritarian states like 1984. But really you don't need all that to begin with. The vast majority of societies through history were pretty unequal. Even today much of the world has pretty high levels of inequality. Technology just prevents that from ever changing.
- bandrami 12y agoThat's why the world's greatest superpower in history had such an easy time successfully invading and occupying two of the poorest countries on Earth over the past decade and a half?
- Houshalter 12y agoBecause they weren't willing to use the amount of oppression and violence necessary to subject the population to their control. That's a good thing but it makes an occupation much more expensive. But imagine what would happen if they did any of the things I said like mass surveillance. The US is certainly moving in that direction, but imagine when there are microphones and cameras everywhere, always recording. With AI good enough to automatically figure out who you are and what you are doing. When every face and license plate is recognized, and drones above track where every single person and vehicle moves.
- moron4hire 12y agoI don't think violent revolt is quite necessary. We certainly seem to be seeing a non-violent revolt happening in the entertainment industry. People, unhappy with the way the music and movie industry have been trying to leverage their monopolistic power over certain franchises, have turned to non-violently pirating media, to the point that, for a lot of people, and many properties, the easiest mode of obtaining them is piracy. Étienne de La Boétie wrote in one of his earliest writings 'Discourse on Voluntary Servitude"[0] that tyrants only have power because people voluntarily give it. All that the people must do to overthrow the tyrant is to just sit down on the ground and give up helping him, because the tyrant has no true power of his own. One of the more reassuring aspects about the Internet and the global economy is that ideas can spread in an instant, and it really enables people to be able to freely associate, even in many cases despite their governments' express attempts to prevent them from doing so. I think the Internet is growing a sense of global community, where it's a lot harder for the average joe to think of someone on the other side of the planet as a faceless enemy, specifically because it puts a face on people. And it also allows us to trade with so much more ease. It doesn't matter if it's in dollars or bitcoins or euros or whatever. Currency is whatever is convenient. And the technology we have today makes it incredibly more convenient than ever before. So in sum total, I think it means that it's so much easier today to just ignore the tyrants and go about life in your own way, on your own terms. The more people do that, the less support the tyrants have, until they either capitulate to be able to capture at least some of the pie for themselves, or starve to death. [0] granted, the full text is a bit childish in its view of the world, but I think there are some decent take-aways to be had.
- thesteamboat 12y ago> All that the people must do to overthrow the tyrant is to just sit down on the ground and give up helping him, because the tyrant has no true power of his own. I think the fear here is that at some point the relevant servants of the tyrant will all be technological constructs unable of sitting down. If we're really careful about making sure our robot army doesn't revolt then what happens when a tyrant controls them?
- moron4hire 12y ago