2 ms·
The use of outlandish thought experiments is fraught with problems, not the least of which is philosophers' predilection to accept intuition and common sense in
by mannykannot 12y ago
The use of outlandish thought experiments is fraught with problems, not the least of which is philosophers' predilection to accept intuition and common sense in supposing what the outcome would be. This is particularly clearly demonstrated in Searle's Chinese Room argument, which is really just an attempt to disguise a personal opinion as a rational conclusion.
The fundamental problem here is that, unlike in science, philosophical thought experiments are not constrained by reality, so they tend to ultimately become self-referential arguments over which axioms to accept, but with no objective basis for deciding between them.