4 ms·
You witness a mugging. You get a good look at the person who did it. A cop comes up to you and says "did you see what happened?" What's the right thing to do h
by snowwrestler 12y ago
You witness a mugging. You get a good look at the person who did it. A cop comes up to you and says "did you see what happened?"
What's the right thing to do here? Shut up and demand a lawyer before you'll answer any questions?
You hear about a shooting in your neighborhood on the radio. Walking to the subway, you see a person with a gun run down an alley. At the subway station a cop asks you if you've seen anything suspicious.
What's the right thing to do here? Shut up and demand a lawyer before you'll answer any questions?
Personally, I don't want to live in a society in which no one helps anyone because of fear.
It's worth keeping in mind that Ken White is a defense attorney, writing from a particular perspective, which may not cover all possible situations. His advice is great if you are the subject of a criminal investigation. Most people are not subjects of criminal investigations.
Specific to traffic stops, neither officers nor attorneys recommend shutting up and demanding a lawyer as the first move. They recommend: make the officer feel safe, be polite, don't lie, and decline a search if requested.
Editing since I can't reply to rosser (what's the point of a discussion forum if I can't have a discussion?):
My point is that writing as either a defense attorney or a prosecutor, his posts take a more a narrow view of police interactions than the entirety of how someone might interact with the police. I doubt he would recommend against reporting a crime if you are the victim or a witness, for instance, or if he did, I doubt he would find many peers to agree with him.
"Keep your head down, never talk to a cop," is certainly a strategy for getting through life, but it's not necessarily globally optimal.
- rosser 12y agoIt's worth keeping in mind that Ken White is a defense attorney... It's also worth keeping in mind that he's a former federal prosecutor. He knows of what he speaks, and you would do very well to heed his counsel.
- eropple 12y agoCops are an active deterrent towards good citizenship because good citizenship is punished. The citizenry is under no obligation, moral or ethical or it-would-be-nice-if, to help them when they have proven unwilling to help the citizenry in aggregate or, especially as regards minorities and those weaker than they are, in particular. It's economics. People respond to incentives. I am not incentivized to help the cops because it's never going to be better for me to do so. I'll act differently when they are different, get me? . (You make a good point about traffic stops, though it speaks remarkably of the shitty nature of police interactions that somehow it's on you to make an officer feel safe. Never mind that an officer will regularly attempt to make you feel threatened or unsafe to get you to say something stupid...)
- baddox 12y ago> Personally, I don't want to live in a society in which no one helps anyone because of fear. You shouldn't talk to police in the situations you describe. And of course we don't want to live in this type of society. It would be great if police behaved differently.
- ptaipale 12y agoWhen we're this deep into a comment chain, you just need to wait for a few minutes before the "Reply" button appears. Design in HN to slow down flame wars, I suppose. I think you make good points. People say things like "don't ever talk to a police without lawyer", because they want to make a political point. I am not American, and not resident in the US, but I do not believe that a total "I don't talk to police without lawyer, ever" is really wise. Either in US or elsewhere - you have to understand your surroundings. My latest interaction with an American police officer was on a business trip on September 12, 2001. Independent of the bad TV shows the previous day, I was driving to the local office where I was visiting. Boss from Europe called me on my cell phone. I didn't think it was a good idea to speak on the phone while driving, so I took the exit from highway and stopped on the curb of a smaller road. After talking for a moment, I noticed a police car stopped next to me. I rolled down the window, and the police asked me why I stopped there. I told him, to speak on the phone. He told me to move over because I would be blocking other traffic. I hadn't noticed it but he was right. I said "sorry, I didn't notice, I'll get moving", put the phone away and got moving. End of story. Instead of telling him "Speaking on the phone", should I have responded with "No comment, I want my lawyer"? That would have been absurd, and probably a very good reason for this officer to get suspicious of me, possibly starting to check my papers - which I'm sure he's the right to do - and possibly ticket me for simply breaking the traffic law and then being a prick about it.
- Spooky23 12y agoObviously there's a balance here. You don't want to put people in danger with your silence. The answer depends on what you look like, what you are doing (are you carrying contraband?), and the situation. Being a witness in general is a real pain in butt in any case, particularly if you are witnessing a non-trivial crime.
- mikeash 12y agoIt might be reasonable to talk to cops in those situations. I don't know. "Don't talk" seems to apply to when you are, or might be, accused of a crime. There, your guilt or innocence does not matter in the least. Don't talk. You're right that nobody recommends demanding a lawyer for a traffic stop. But they do recommend not talking to the officer beyond the minimum requested. For example, it's standard for an officer who catches you speeding to ask "do you know how fast you were going?" If you give a number that's over the posted limit, then they have you admitting to breaking the law. If you give a number that's under the limit and they know you were going faster then they have you lying to an officer. I don't think it's worth keeping in mind that Ken White is a defense attorney because I've seen this exact advice from many places, both lawyers and cops, and there's never any disagreement. I have seen cops say that traffic stops will go a lot easier if you're nice and polite to the officer. But that does not mean you have to answer all their questions. Immediately shouting "I demand a lawyer!" is a good way to get written up for every minor infraction the officer can find, but nicely declining to answer questions you're not required to answer is fine.