3 ms·
Microsoft has removed Billions from the economy, even above the Billions they transferred from others to themselves. I think this is incoherent, and I'm certai
by barry-cotter 17y ago
Microsoft has removed Billions from the economy, even above the Billions they transferred from others to themselves.
I think this is incoherent, and I'm certain it's wrong. A monopoly has no incentive to "remove" money from the economy. A profit maximising monopolist in the practically impossible position of being able to price discriminate perfectly such that every customer willing to buy its product at a price above the marginal cost of selling it to them will capture all value created by its product/service, but that just means there's no consumer surplus. Value is still created, it just accrues to the company, which presumably still distributes it to shareholders, suppliers and employees.
In more prosaic terms, monopolies "make articles scarce, make them dear and make them bad".
I have no idea how many copies of major MSFT products there are but scarce is not true, and quite a lot of people obviously disagree with you on dear and bad. Office utterly dominates its market niche, and it is in large part due to quality and ease of use. Network effects help some but you can't leverage a reputation in one sector too far in another, otherwise Microsoft's accounting software would be the default, and it's not, Quicken is.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]