3 ms·
This kind of silliness is why I ignore philosophers whenever I can. It is clear that the subject of how we personally experience X is not, strictly speaking, p
by btilly 12y ago
This kind of silliness is why I ignore philosophers whenever I can.
It is clear that the subject of how we personally experience X is not, strictly speaking, part of the body of knowledge about X. But the reverse is also true. Learning more about how we personally experience X does not increase our understanding of X. It is a different topic.
There is an important asterisk on this. And that is that we actually learn about things through our subjective experience. And therefore understanding our subjective experience can be necessary to get clear understanding of that thing.
This is true in a very literal way. "How long did that take?" If you give three people a stopwatch and have them record a common event, you will get 3 answers. And the answers will be consistently different in similar ways. In astronomy this phenomena is well-known as your personal equation. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_equation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_equation for verfication.
But now I return you to philosophers arguing that something obvious is something deep that has consequences that it really does not...
- coldtea 12y ago>This kind of silliness is why I ignore philosophers whenever I can. And avoiding this type of hasty comments are why it pays to study philogophical problems. >It is clear that the subject of how we personally experience X is not, strictly speaking, part of the body of knowledge about X. But the reverse is also true. Learning more about how we personally experience X does not increase our understanding of X. It is a different topic. That "it's a different topic" is a definitive statement that is not derrived from anywhere. If anything, it is itself of philosophical nature, albeit a dogmatic one. Who said that the actual experience of X doesn't increase "our understanding of X"? Even if it might be so, it remains to be argued. Whereas the opposite, that experience, as an extra informational element regarding X, and as the main component of X as it concerns us, adds to our understand of X, is the obvious (correct or not) conclusion. >* This is true in a very literal way. "How long did that take?" If you give three people a stopwatch and have them record a common event, you will get 3 answers. And the answers will be consistently different in similar ways.* No, you wont, except within the margin of acceptable error (e.g. time to press the stopwatch button for each, etc).
- btilly 12y agoFirst on the personal equation, the actual measurement difference from person to person could range up to 0.7 seconds. See http://www.jstor.org/stable/1627157?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents http://www.jstor.org/stable/1627157?seq=1#page_scan_tab_cont... for verification. This was far above acceptable error for measuring the positions of the stars, and is far longer than most could believe possible. As for "it's a different topic", well, it is. The one topic is the objective reality of how something works. The other topic is the subjective reality of how we experience that same thing. Take the example that was given. Suppose that I tell you about electromagnetism. I tell you about the absorption spectrum of various colors. I tell you about the fact that when we process color we subtract red from green and yellow from blue so that we can never perceive a mix of those. I tell you about various forms of color-blindness, and the rare forms of tetrachromacy. I can tell you everything there is to know about how the process works, and what colors will be perceived, when. And how that differs for different people. You still know nothing about what it is like to experience it for yourself. And conversely, learning to experience it for yourself tells you very little about everything that I just told you. For example you've been seeing in color for your whole life and likely are not color-blind. If so, were you aware that it is impossible for you to see a mix of red and green as a mix of red and green? Probably not! Which returns me to my point. Subjective experience is a necessary filter through which we perceive the objective world around us. That experience is neither necessary nor sufficient to gain objective knowledge. And conversely objective knowledge is neither necessary nor sufficient to gain subjective knowledge. They are different kinds of things.