14 ms·
Reminder: Oh, Won't You Please Shut Up? (2011)
- lgierth 12y agoAlso very enlightening, and many probably already have watched this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc > Dont Talk to Cops > Mr. James Duane, a professor at Regent Law School and a former defense attorney, tells you why you should never agree to be interviewed by the police.
- SilasX 12y agoThanks, but I'll continue to report crimes and assist canvassers looking for anyone who saw a suspect. "But he obviously didn't mean that!" Then why the extreme repetition of "never"?
- girvo 12y ago> Then why the extreme repetition of "never" Because if you're the "wrong" colour or class, even reporting crimes or assisting canvassers can get you in trouble.
- dghf 12y agoOr the "right" colour and class: viz Christopher Jeffries, a (white) landlord and retired teacher, somewhat eccentric but otherwise respectable, who was arrested for the murder of his tenant (and vilified in the national press) after volunteering what he thought might be relevant information about the night of her disappearance. (He was later released without charge and won substantial libel damages from a number of newspapers.)
- praptak 12y agoI would seriously consider reporting anything non-lethal in US, see "Good Samaritan Backfire or How I Ended Up in Solitary After Calling 911 for Help": https://medium.com/human-parts/good-samaritan-backfire-9f53ef6a1c10 https://medium.com/human-parts/good-samaritan-backfire-9f53e...
- edc117 12y agoThat story had a bit of an exaggerated feel, but I also got the feeling there was quite a bit of truth as well. Sad to read.
- Torgo 12y agoThere is a corollary to "don't talk to cops" which is "if you do talk to cops, minimize the encounter" closely followed by "always obey direct order from cop to leave" and concluding with "if you are incarcerated, shut up until you're completely out of confinement."
- baddox 12y agoNo, he meant that too. I haven't watched the video for a few years, but I believe he explicitly uses that scenario as one example.
- SilasX 12y agoHe explicitly says not to report crimes? Note that he talks to a cop in the video.
- baddox 12y agoAgain, I haven't watched the video for several years, but I thought I remembered him using the example of a police officer coming to an apartment complex and asking residents questions about a recent reported crime. I don't think reporting crimes came up, and it probably doesn't apply, since when you call 911 you (as far as I know) do not talk to police officers.
- SilasX 12y agoIt applies. Again, note how many "nevers" he gives and how exceptionless his advice is. Is the idea that, when the police follow up, you keep saying, "sorry I can't talk to you even though I want your assistance; give me that 911 lady again"?
- hawkice 12y ago> Hence, the government's chickenshit false statement trap works — even though the government agents set it up from the start. If you don't read Popehat, this might be the moment you realize it's a good idea to start. Very rarely do you see legal discussion detailed enough to be meaningful, while informal enough to hold your attention. Other discussions of note is the bizarre sentencing of Petraeus: https://www.popehat.com/2015/03/03/a-few-comments-on-the-david-petraeus-plea-deal-what-money-and-connections-buy-you/ https://www.popehat.com/2015/03/03/a-few-comments-on-the-dav... and the way Darren Wilson's potential prosecution was evaluated: https://www.popehat.com/2015/03/04/darren-wilson-and-the-benefit-of-doubt/ https://www.popehat.com/2015/03/04/darren-wilson-and-the-ben... Double standards are a recurring theme, you could rightly deduce. As a largely technical crowd it might bother us as much as it bothers lawyers.
- Zaephyr 12y agoAlso of note for those new to Pope Hat, Ken White is a former Federal Prosecutor. His perspective from both sides of federal law makes for some interesting posts.
- Symmetry 12y agoAnother thing to note is that Popehat is a group blog. Ken does most of the posting and is the reason most people read but there are other posters too.
- gregory144 12y agoBut in the last 12 years, I've seen it in a dozen cases... Once a year, throughout the country? How many thousands of investigations are performed per year? Doesn't seem very likely to happen.
- cespare 12y agoThe sample was not "every federal investigation of the past 12 years".
- mikeash 12y agoHow many thousands of investigations is he personally involved in per year? I'd guess something on the order of 0.05.
- mod 12y agoNot to mention, I imagine they only play that card when it seems like they need to for one reason or another.
- caseysoftware 12y agoMore likely they do something similar relatively often and only spring the trap if they feel it necessary.
- mod 12y agoYeah I didn't mean they don't trap you often, rather they don't have to use it that often--certainly not prosecute it often--and therefore the guy doesn't see it that often. I should have made my opinion more clear, judging by the downvotes.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rosser 12y agoThey play that card as a matter of course, because once they've got you for felony false statement, that's leverage to get you to play ball on the real reason they were talking to you in the first place. "That's a nice, felony conviction-free life you've got there. It would be a shame if something were to happen to it..."
- chimeracoder 12y ago> The lesson — other than that criminal justice often has little to do with actual justice — is this: for God's sake shut up. Law enforcement agents seeking to interview you are not your friends. You cannot count on "just clearing this one thing up." Demand to talk to a lawyer before talking to the cops. Every time. This is a very good reminder, and everything he says is both important and true. Unfortunately, it's sadly much easier said than done. I know my rights. Both nationally, as well as the specific nuances of New York[0] (both city and state). I have even conducted multiple "Know Your Rights" training events educating people (generally students) about the rights that they do and don't have when speaking with LEOs, and how to exercise them. But even then, when push came to shove and I was in this position, I found myself hesitating and second guessing my knowledge, despite all the practice I had and the trainings I'd helped conduct myself.[1] LEOs - especially Feds - will do everything they can to intimidate you, make you uncomfortable, lower your confidence, etc. It's literally their job to make people like you make mistakes. It sucks, but that's what you're up against. [0] PSA: Did you know that possession of < 27g (not a full ounce) of marijuana is only a criminal offence in NY if "burning or open to public view"? Did you also know that this means that you should never, ever turn out your pockets if a cop asks you, because then you've exposed said contraband to "public view"? Wait for him/her to frisk you, and at least then your lawyer will have a slight chance at getting the charge dismissed. [1] It didn't help that most of my knowledge (as is often the case) centred around local police, whereas the situation regarding border crossings and the TSA is more thorny.
- themartorana 12y agoI feel like at some point in time, entrapment was frowned upon... Unfortunately it's this behavior that reinforces - not helps fix - the often maligned urban/minority fear of ever helping the police in any way ever. Does the entire neighborhood know who committed crimes X? Yes. Will anyone ever talk to the police? Na.
- WildUtah 12y ago"it's this behavior that reinforces" It's a mild reenforcement but the root reason to fear and not cooperate with the police is the same as ever. When most police resources in the USA are focused on drug enforcement and most Americans have committed federal felonies they don't think they should be incarcerated for and most underclass young men are committing them routinely, you can't expect crime ridden communities to see the police as any kind of blessing.
- NhanH 12y agoThe question that I have every time I read about something similar to this is not about the law itself, but about the human who's applying the law: how/ why/ what is the line of thought that would lead them to (supposedly) knowingly do something like this? I realize that processes, bureaucracy and generally abstraction can allow people to do less than desirable behaviours, but I can't quite figure out which abstraction that would encourage people to do things like that (note: with the term "abstraction", I meant that by using incentives or measuring the wrong intermediate metrics, we've created a wrong set of objectives, which might be completely misaligned with the actual goal we're trying to achieve). Laws are complex set of statements, which naturally will have more accidentally complexity as they're developed, a phenomenon that hackers are extremely familiar with. That's something to be expected. On the other hand, human, abusing the accidental complexity of law, is not ideal - as anything else, there should be place and time for trickery, but not the SOP. That said, what's the rationale for the behaviour of law enforcement officer in pursuing various type of trap-y actions? - Do LEO routinely believes that everyone they investigate to be committing the crime. Do we have a good priori of P(criminal | under investigation) that would support this? - Did we actually manage to create a powerful enough abstractions that let actors within the system to, well, behave psychopathically (ie. this button should be pushed because I'm supposed to do that, I don't really know what happen behind it)? - Trickery are generally being reported out of proportion, and should not be a general concern for the the majority of us. - Malicious intention -- I will assume this percentage to be not higher than those from a general population.
- mikeash 12y agoI would say "all of the above." LEO do routinely believe that people they investigate must be guilty. They don't investigate at random, but rather are prompted by some evidence of criminal behavior. That certainly doesn't mean that you must be guilty if they investigate you, but it sets them up to believe you are. The system is set up with compartments so nobody sees the full consequences of anything and this sort of misbehavior is encouraged. If you send somebody to jail, they disappear from your life the moment the verdict is reached and you have no reason to dwell on the harm you've caused them. (And if you do, you probably think it's a good thing, because you think they're a criminal!) And you probably get a commendation for putting a bad guy away. Bad behavior does get reported disproportionately. Most cops are good cops. For everyone like this, there are ten cops who find a lost cellphone and personally deliver it back to the owner, as happened to a neighbor of mine a few months ago. That doesn't make the news. Although that doesn't mean it shouldn't be a concern for the majority of us. Even a small risk of being falsely imprisoned is important, and there's no harm in taking the "SHUT UP" route with a good cop. Finally, I would be wary of assuming that malicious intent is no higher than among the general population. Bad people tend to seek power over others, and what better way to wield such power than to do so legally as a member of the police? No doubt, the legitimate "protect and serve" folks still greatly outnumber the bad guys, but I would bet they're more concentrated.
- bcg1 12y agoActually over the years, I've found that shutting my mouth would be helpful not only when talking to law enforcement. Not always so good at carrying that out though. Anyways, it reminds of the time I was arrested for smoking the forbidden devil vegetable. We were brought into the city court room to be indicted while we were waiting two suburban white teenagers were in from the bench getting chewed out by the judge, saying that he's sick of seeing these kids from the suburbs coming into the city to buy drugs and encouraging crime in his neighborhood. After he finished his rant, he asked them what they plead and they said not guilty of course. Then one of them felt the urge to speak up and said, "I just want to point out one thing before we go... the police officer wrote down that it was crack cocaine, but it was regular cocaine, not crack." After the judge picked his jaw up off the floor he broke character and told them to shut up until they had a lawyer.
- dantillberg 12y agoI can't help but wonder if those kids would have gotten the same apparently-lenient/gracious treatment from the judge if they'd instead been POC teenagers from the inner city.
- bcg1 12y agoActually he seemed genuinely ticked off at those kids, and I wouldn't say he was lenient (I wasn't really trying to make a statement about that with my story, so maybe I gave a false impression by mistake). I'm white and my friend that I was arrested with was black, and we received the same treatment from the judge (not from the cops though, but that is a different story) - and from what I saw those two kids were the only ones who got chewed out, the rest of us were just arraigned and sent on our way for further processing.
- chiph 12y agoNot always so good at carrying that out though. Ron White has a good line about this in his standup routine: "I had the right to remain silent... but I didn't have the ability"
- tux 12y agoFor anyone else that site no longer loads there is a mirror @ https://archive.today/daFxI https://archive.today/daFxI
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- serve_yay 12y agoThe only time I ever did this, it was a routine traffic stop and I was with my wife and my parents. The cop was asking me a bunch of questions about why I was driving so fast, and I just played it off like I didn't understand, just trying to say as little as possible. It was a bad tactic - it raised suspicion and I later learned that my mother thought I was actually holding drugs or something because I was being evasive. I still in general agree with the advice, but... it requires some subtlety.
- ars 12y agoI've written that before on HN and got massively downmodded, hopefully that doesn't happen to you. If you are actually guilty then keep your mouth closed. But if you are not guilty then staying quiet is not necessarily to your benefit.
- mikeash 12y agoYour guilt doesn't matter. You can still incriminate yourself even if you have committed no crime. It sounds like grandparent didn't go to jail, so even though he calls it a "bad tactic" it seems to have worked out fine. The people who actually know this stuff, i.e. lawyers and cops, all universally advise people not to talk to the police without counsel. Never have I seen one add the qualifier "but it's fine if you're not guilty." I'm inclined to take their word for it.
- snowwrestler 12y agoYou witness a mugging. You get a good look at the person who did it. A cop comes up to you and says "did you see what happened?" What's the right thing to do here? Shut up and demand a lawyer before you'll answer any questions? You hear about a shooting in your neighborhood on the radio. Walking to the subway, you see a person with a gun run down an alley. At the subway station a cop asks you if you've seen anything suspicious. What's the right thing to do here? Shut up and demand a lawyer before you'll answer any questions? Personally, I don't want to live in a society in which no one helps anyone because of fear. It's worth keeping in mind that Ken White is a defense attorney, writing from a particular perspective, which may not cover all possible situations. His advice is great if you are the subject of a criminal investigation. Most people are not subjects of criminal investigations. Specific to traffic stops, neither officers nor attorneys recommend shutting up and demanding a lawyer as the first move. They recommend: make the officer feel safe, be polite, don't lie, and decline a search if requested. Editing since I can't reply to rosser (what's the point of a discussion forum if I can't have a discussion?): My point is that writing as either a defense attorney or a prosecutor, his posts take a more a narrow view of police interactions than the entirety of how someone might interact with the police. I doubt he would recommend against reporting a crime if you are the victim or a witness, for instance, or if he did, I doubt he would find many peers to agree with him. "Keep your head down, never talk to a cop," is certainly a strategy for getting through life, but it's not necessarily globally optimal.
- elchief 12y agoAre we talking about their cool HTTP 503/522 error page?
- Qwertious 12y agoDoesn't include italicising or links or title, but: There's really no excuse for the fact that we don't have a "SHUT UP!" tag; I shall have to remedy that. After all, "SHUT UP!" is one of our most venerable and consistent themes. There's a reason for this. The reason lies at the heart of law enforcement methodology in general and federal law enforcement abuse of Title 18, United States Code, Section 1001 in particular. Imagine this scenario, based on an actual situation: A business associate calls you and says, "my dear business associate, the shit has hit the fan; Federal Agency X is investigating Project Y we did together. Two Agency X agents are interviewing people." "Oh coitus," says you, or words to that effect, and terminate the conversation. Later that day, two well-dressed and polite agents of Agency X visit you. Because you despise me and want me to weep and gnash my teeth, you consent to be interviewed. At some point, they ask you "have you talked about this investigation with anyone?" "No," you say. They smile. At the end of the interview, it occurs to you to ask, "Hey, am I in trouble? Do I need a lawyer?" The agents smirk. "No," they say. "I mean, unless you lied about talking to anyone about this investigation." See, you've fallen into a false statement trap, which I've talked about before. The feds know that you've talked to somebody about their investigation. They were probably standing next to your friend when he made that call this morning. And now you've talked your way into a felony. Here's how it works. The feds identify some fact that they can prove. It need not be inherently incriminating; it might be whether you were at a particular meeting, or whether you talked to someone about the existence of the investigation. They determine that they have irrefutable proof of this fact. Then, when they interview you, they ask you a question about the fact, hoping that you will lie. Often they employ professional questioning tactics to make it more likely you will lie — for instance, by phrasing the question or employing a tone of voice to make the fact sound sinister. You — having already been foolhardy enough to talk to them without a lawyer — obligingly lie about this fact. Then, even though there was never any question about the fact, even though your lie did not deter the federal government for a microsecond, they have you nailed for a false statement to a government agent in violation of 18 USC 1001. To be a crime under Section 1001, a statement must be material — but the federal courts have generally supported the government's position that the question is not whether a false statement actually did influence the government, but whether it was the sort of false statement that could have influenced the government. Hence, the government's chickenshit false statement trap works — even though the government agents set it up from the start. Now, however weak or strong their evidence is of the issue they are investigating, they've got you on a Section 1001 charge — a federal felony. In effect, they are manufacturing felonies in the course of investigations. You think this is an improbable scenario? You think I'm talking about rare and extreme cases to color the entirety of federal law enforcement? To the contrary, as a federal defense attorney, I'm encountering this more and more often. Not to sound like an old fart, but we never indulged in such bullshit when I was a federal prosecutor (cue the scoffing from many defense attorneys). But in the last 12 years, I've seen it in a dozen cases, and heard about it from colleagues across the country. It's now routine for federal agents to close out an investigation with a false-statement-trap interview of a target in an effort to add a Section 1001 cherry to the top of the cake. The lesson — other than that criminal justice often has little to do with actual justice — is this: for God's sake shut up. Law enforcement agents seeking to interview you are not your friends. You cannot count on "just clearing this one thing up." Demand to talk to a lawyer before talking to the cops. Every time. SHUT UP.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThe general case here is: don't lie to federal agents. The easiest way to do that is to stay silent and demand a lawyer. But understand: if you're on the periphery of an investigation, you're running a chance of raising a red flag. It's well within your rights, and ultimately you can't incriminate yourself by being silent. But you could substantially add delay, frustration, and lawyer costs to the whole experience. Another way to not lie is to speak the truth. In the specific example from the blog post, there's no reason to lie--taking that call was not illegal, so there's no reason to lie. My question is: how often to federal prosecutions go to trial based only on a false statement trap? I have no doubt that agents use it as a "cherry on top" of other charges, but I'm assuming most folks here are worried about surprise or "gotcha" prosecutions--not actually worried that their criminal ways will be exposed. So how often do federal agents clear someone of any substantive wrongdoing, but still prosecute them based solely on a false statement trap? I would be surprised if it ever happens. Edit: Downvotes but no answers are a bummer; I'm asking a question here.
- rosser 12y ago"If one would give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest man, I would find something in them to have him hanged." — Cardinal Richelieu
- brohee 12y agoThis quote is often misattributed. Actually by Laubardemont. https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean_Martin_de_Laubardemont https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean_Martin_de_Laubardemont (no English wikipedia page). He's well known for the Loudun withcraft trials (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudun_possessions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudun_possessions)
- aptwebapps 12y agoThey can use it as a stick to beat you with to get a plea deal on whatever it is they think you did. Do you think they only indict guilty people? The other thing is that you could get section 1001'd for something you didn't actually say as FBI agents, for example, usually don't use recording devices and just take notes. If their notes said you said it and you don't have a witness, guess what happens?
- chx 12y agoRead http://www.amazon.com/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/1594035229 http://www.amazon.com/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/... even if it's exaggerating, even if it's twisting the truth as some claim there are some frightening amount of felonies you can commit and because of that you can't ever presume you are innocent. But even if you are, as the wonderful video linked by lgierth shows you can be in trouble. Just don't talk to the police.
- bsgreenb 12y agoI thought this post was going to be about the "Restart or Details" update dialogue on Macs
- zkhalique 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
- spiritplumber 12y ago"My name is (name), what is yours? Nice to meet you. Am I free to go?" "Please, I do not wish to talk to you." "Please, if you want to talk to me further, I will want my lawyer present." "Please, I do not wish to participate in a fight with you." "Please, let us leave each other alone, or I will destroy you and your organization via technology beyond your understanding." (Be sure you can back this one up before using it). Be polite, be professional, speak little unless there's profit in speaking much. Works with most everyone that is outside your monkeysphere, this includes cops.
- tsotha 12y agoI thought everyone knew this. Never talk to representatives or agents of the US federal government without your lawyer present. Never, ever, ever. When they make contact, ask them for a phone number your lawyer can call. Ask them what matter the questions will be regarding. Get a card if it's in person. They're going to tell you there's no reason to hire a lawyer and you can clear the whole thing up in five minutes if you talk to them. They're lying, which is something they can do legally, but if you do it you're off to the gray bar hotel. http://corporate.findlaw.com/litigation-disputes/how-to-avoid-going-to-jail-under-18-u-s-c-section-1001-for-lying.html http://corporate.findlaw.com/litigation-disputes/how-to-avoi...
- ptaipale 12y agoThat is slightly weird. How would I, for instance, arrange a lawyer to be present when I step out of a plane at JFK and talk to the immigration officer, who quite legitimately just wants to see my passport? He'll also be asking questions which I'm obliged to answer. There's no choice, but there's seldom any trouble, either.
- tajen 12y agoThe OP talks about local police. In US, the customs are unfortunately a very different form of jurisdiction. Sometimes I hear citizen aren't in the US jurisdiction until they've crossed the border. Which is a problem that US citizens probably need to solve through their democracy. Centuries ago, constitutions were written to protect citizen with a heavy focus on local police scopes, but now that we all routinely walk through borders and on planes, we probably need to rewrite those constitutions with international police checks in focus. We can't afford to be in a no-law situation a dozen times a year.
- pluma 12y agoActually, the "airports aren't national territory" myth has no legal basis and is mostly just propagated to make it easier to turn people away. Legally, once you leave the plane, you're under the jurisdiction of whichever country you landed in. Unlike embassies, airports aren't anything special in that regard. But sadly it doesn't really matter what international law actually says but how laws are enforced. Good luck escalating to the Hague over whether or not the TSA can detain you or refuse entry.
- fijal 12y agoThis is precisely why in Poland (and likely more european jurisdictions) lying as an accused is not a crime (even if you muddle stuff completely), only as a witness. It's a bit shocking this is not the case in America
- netrus 12y agoIn Germany, not even prison escape is a crime per se (unless you hurt someone or damage property, of course - so it's mostly the "door-left-open"-scenario), because we recognize the elementary human desire to be free. And you do not have to accuse yourself, and that includes lying, if necessary. I'd say it works pretty well.
- the_mitsuhiko 12y agoOne thing that is very important to know about this behavior, is that while it works in the US in your favor, it will not in other states of the world. A good example is Austria where refusing a statement generally works heavily against you.
- skrebbel 12y agoI'm not American and I have a question. Everybody in this thread repeats to "never talk to law enforcement without your lawyer present". I don't have a lawyer. I don't know a lawyer. I've hardly ever even talked to a lawyer. If I were in the USA and I'd get picked up for questioning, I wouldn't know who to call. Does every American "have a lawyer"? Do you know their phone number by heart? Is having a lawyer like having a health insurance, in that you could do without but it'd be pretty stupid? Isn't that a suffocating thought? How do you deal with it?
- techstrategist 12y agoNo, I think that most Americans don't have a lawyer on call. The typical advice I have heard is to do a little research on lawyers in your city, and have a phone number of a reputable lawyer (or a few) in your wallet in case of a potentially severe legal situation. When you call them and establish a relationship where you are paying for their services they become "your lawyer". (this is not advice, I'm not a lawyer, etc)
- skrebbel 12y ago> (this is not advice, I'm not a lawyer, etc) Related: will people sue you if you don't include that disclaimer?
- jessaustin 12y agoIANAL, but I believe that in this case the disclaimer is just a courtesy. That is, before one makes a life-altering decision, one should consult a real attorney, not just us morons on HN.
- cookiecaper 12y agoIf you don't include it when discussing any vaguely law-related matter, Internet Tough Guys will be quick to call you out for "practicing law without a license". [1] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9088475 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9088475
- uts 12y agoI want to clarify the scope of this advice. If I've actually committed a crime and a cop is interrogating me about it, I should shut up and talk to my lawyer. (e.g. I robbed someone's house) In the other extreme, if someone's committed a crime against me, I should actively call the police to talk to them (e.g. someone robbed my house). The majority of interactions with police fall somewhere between these two examples in terms of susceptibility. What determines when I should be talking to the cops and when I shouldn't?
- Karellen 12y agoIf the police initiate the contact, shut up and talk to your lawyer. Because someone else might have robbed a house, and the police have you as a suspect (maybe you look like the perp) and if you open your big mouth without a lawyer, you could accidentally get yourself into trouble. See the "never talk to the cops" youtube vid, which is undoubtably already linked somewhere else in the thread, about why you need a lawyer in those circumstances, and why your right to a lawyer is especially there to protect you when you are actually innocent.
- Udo 12y ago> If I've actually committed a crime The article (and other such presentations on the subject) indicate very clearly that innocence is not a factor. It doesn't seem to matter if you've committed a crime or not - and whether your assessment your own innocence itself actually holds true or not is yet another uncertain factor. > if someone's committed a crime against me Then your lawyer will facilitate all the necessary measures, and he/she'll do it better and more efficiently than you ever could. > What determines when I should be talking to the cops and when I shouldn't? Beyond basic cooperation at, say, a traffic stop or during an emergency, most experts seem to agree that you should never, under any circumstances talk directly to any law enforcement personnel.
- baddox 12y agoYou should have a lawyer before you talk to police about a crime committed against you as well.
- mellavora 12y ago
- gadders 12y agoIIRC, this was what got Martha Stewart her jail time. Not insider trading, but lying to a federal investigator.
- chippy 12y agoAnyone have any similar advise for Brits?
- dghf 12y agoIANAL, but I would imagine it's a bit trickier, as our right not to incriminate ourselves is more restricted than that of our American cousins (at least in England & Wales -- Scotland and Northern Ireland may be different): the warning given by police is, "You do not have to say anything, but it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in court. Anything you do say may be given in evidence."
- DanBC 12y agoI think the advice isn't "say nothing", it is "say nothing until your lawyer is there". So, for someone arrested (or questioned) in England or Wales the advice is to politely say something like "I'm happy to answer your questions officer, but I am waiting for my lawyer to get here".
- mellavora 12y agoSo my question is what can we, the hacker community, do to change this? Would pervasive sousveillance help? Thinking deeper: we need to change the culture of LE in the US. What needs to change such that LEOs become part of the wider community, so they are held accountable etc.. Silly idea: a "trip-advisor" or "4-square" for police encounters. Any encounter with a LEO, you upload the location, their badge number, and give them a ranking. Did they show compassion/understanding? 5 stars.
- ctdonath 12y agoI've considered an app that would, once initiated, aggressively record audio/video/location/movement/etc, no stop button (!), resisting app termination, strong encrypting the content, and (key point) immediately uploading to a deep-storage service like Amazon Glacier. Usage would be free, retrieval of content would require service-support costs and proof of ownership or warrant/subpoena.
- mellavora 12y agoRemember also we need to end civil forfeiture, which lets police take your stuff without charging you with a crime. It is a growing business in the US, police are now regularly trained in the game and rewarded based on their daily take. more reading: https://www.aclu.org/criminal-law-reform/civil-asset-forfeiture https://www.aclu.org/criminal-law-reform/civil-asset-forfeit... and google suggests the following: http://fear.org/1/ http://fear.org/1/ http://endforfeiture.com/ http://endforfeiture.com/
- pluma 12y agoOr if you're more into being educated by comedy, John Oliver did a nice take on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEpZWGgJks https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEpZWGgJks
- kghose 12y agoIf you have a competent lawyer, not even a high powered one, a jury of your peers will be convinced that is indeed bullshit. The problem, of course, is all the other shit you've done, which HN types think is ok, like running a drug site on the dark web, which is the actual problem ...
- jheriko 12y ago> Law enforcement agents seeking to interview you are not your friends. oh dear. this is a very sad statement all on its own, without any of what came before it. law enforcement should be our friends.
- gregors 12y agoDont talk to police https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jrs235 12y agoRemaining silent can hurt you though. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/17/supreme-court-silence_n_3453968.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/17/supreme-court-silen... You need to simply say something along the lines of "I need legal counsel present while talking to you." After that then shut up.
- chrischen 12y agoHow do they prevent the two investigators from lying about what I said?