3 ms·
Not necessarily. There are a lot of things that the article left out. Number 1 is that the Y chromosome is about 25% of the size of the X chromosomes and is als
by Balgair 12y ago
Not necessarily. There are a lot of things that the article left out. Number 1 is that the Y chromosome is about 25% of the size of the X chromosomes and is also the fastest evolving portion of the human genome. Since this was a DNA based study, you have to control for this as well. I assume they have, but I don't know for certain. Additionally, aneuploidy (XXY, YYX, etc) may also account for some differences along with chimeric (2+ genomes per person due to fraternal twin merging in womb) anomalies. You also have to control for outliers such as Ghengis Khan and those types of mass rape and pillaging, as he has skewed the statistics a fair bit.
Still, if they controlled for all this, it is an AMAZING finding. That only 6% of males will reproduce is fantastical, especially within an agrarian society. I would love to know of other mammalian species that have such low reproductive rates compared to females.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y_chromosome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y_chromosome
- brazzy 12y ago> I would love to know of other mammalian species that have such low reproductive rates compared to females. Some species of deer probably match it.
- Balgair 12y agoTrue! Then it seems that the early agrarian humans had more of a herd mentality or reproductive structure of winner take all. Do other apes or monkeys have similar breeding structures? Fascinating stuff.
- brazzy 12y agoGorillas form harem-like groups, but they're not as large, 3 to 6 females per male (often the groups have multiple related males). Chimps have dominant males, but females can and often do have sex with other males in the group. Bonobos are just ridiculously promiscous :) I just found a book called "Human Natures: Genes, Cultures, and the Human Prospect" which claims that southern elephant seals have harems of 48 females on average O_O - that's probably the record among mammals.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoNone of the things you mention are large enough to account for more than a tiny fraction of this observation. There are only a handful of cases like Ghengis Khan and that Irish king who are ancestors to a fraction of a percent of the human population, which in any case don't exclude other men from ancestry. If you have ten children and I have one, I am still an ancestor, although your DNA will show up more frequently in future generations than mine. These results suggest the actual exclusion of 95% of the male population from reproduction. Chromosomal disorders affect less than 1% of the population, which would be deep in the noise in this study. With regard to the rate of evolution on the Y chromosome, I think it's pretty plausible that people who do this stuff for a living are aware of it and corrected for it. We don't know that for certain, but since we don't know anything with certainty--only with an overwhelmingly high degree of plausibility--that isn't a big criticism. Edit: also, any harem-keeping species is likely to have a high proportion of genetic losers amongst the males: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harem_%28zoology%29#Mammals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harem_%28zoology%29#Mammals