4 ms·
>Arguments that attempt to write off tech full cloth as evil are useless, as are the pollyanas who think tech will solve everything. As is techno-determinism,
by eli_gottlieb 12y ago
>Arguments that attempt to write off tech full cloth as evil are useless, as are the pollyanas who think tech will solve everything.
As is techno-determinism, in which we pretend that technology determines the structure of society rather than society choosing what sorts of technologies it builds.
- llamataboot 12y agoI'm pretty sure there is a feedback loop here - not one way causation in either direction.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoLike 'llamataboot I think that ultimately it's a feedback loop, but come to think of it, it's hard to deny how technology changes society. Look at agriculture, or printing press. Moreover, society itself doesn't really control itself, it's just a big group of agents with different goals and ideas, that all follow incentive structures. It seems much easier for a new technology to change the society than for the society to decide "what sorts of technologies it builds".
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoOf course it's a feedback loop. But, just as truly, the design and incentive control we exercise over institutions is a "social technology" that can radically alter which way history goes. Society does decide what sorts of technologies it builds. That's why we're years behind on green energy, for instance: we could have been funding all research proposals regarding thorium reactors or, more speculatively, nuclear fusion decades ago. Society chose to stick with fossil fuels. Likewise, we could have built modern networked operating systems with capability security from the ground up -- but we chose, collectively, to stick with a weaker security model that bore more resemblance to what came before it.