3 ms·
Speaking as a "millenial": that was painfully stupid and irritating to read. Look: I don't want "jobs", not as an abstract commodity produced because someone d
by eli_gottlieb 12y ago
Speaking as a "millenial": that was painfully stupid and irritating to read.
Look: I don't want "jobs", not as an abstract commodity produced because someone decided everyone has to have a job, and that's that. I want a job that matches my skillset (it's reasonably good), compensates me well, and lets me actually contribute to human progress. If human progress has advanced so far that even someone with my skills is mostly unnecessary, I want a means of supplying for myself that minimizes the personal burden of labor on other people (note: not robots, not corporations, people), and enables me to get on with my life and have fun -- there's more to the world than careerism.
Yes, the sharing economy has been built on the extreme precarity of its workers. Yes, technology destroys "jobs". But overall, the problem here is not technology: it's capitalism.
- grayfox 12y agoExcellent response!
- lstyls 12y agoI agree to a point, but would qualify this to the problem being unfettered capitalism in a vacuum of social investment. The growth in the knowledge economy has such a huge potential to level the playing field - but it can only do so if there is fair access to good education. Here in the US, only those with means have a decent chance of getting the kind of education that enables them to join in the new class of workers, which results in a feedback loop and a widening income gap.
- jkoudys 12y agoIt's a problem with capitalism insofar as under capitalism, the most successful companies will directly influence their government to protect their existing business model. You had a prime opportunity to rethink the entire auto-market, yet the US government instead gave massive bailouts to your big-3 auto makers, and your streets continue to be full of single-passenger Ford F-150s. In spite of massive regulatory resistance, companies like Uber, or Tesla (which yes, get some environmental tax credits, but it's a drop in the ocean compared to being considered "too big to fail") have still managed to grow. It's not that there aren't jobs that need to be done. Instead, your laws and economy are structured to give an advantage to those who used to offer jobs that are no longer valuable.
- balabaster 12y agoYes, but your perspective does nothing for CNN's party line that capitalism is good and everyone needs to have a J.O.B. Those that are capable of getting off their ass and finding niches into which to apply their skills are largely irrelevant to their propaganda - which is mostly to fuel the fear and uncertainty in life and feed the witch hunt against anyone that stands in the way of their message. In my mind, the thing that makes humans greater than machines is our talent to think, design, create and reason our ways to greater things; to do things that require a human touch - like caring for people. If machines are taking care of all the BS jobs that don't make use of our cognitive abilities, that leaves us to do what we do best - think, design, create and be human... and that is what everybody's J.O.B. should be, anything less than that is a complete failure of technology as far as I'm concerned.
- Animats 12y ago"But overall, the problem here is not technology: it's capitalism." Right. Capitalism is designed to maximize shareholder value. A higher standard of living for workers was a side effect. Was. No other country has a working solution. Japan had their real estate collapse 18 years before the US, and never fully came back. Japan is an innovative country, yet they couldn't crack this problem. They tried heavy infrastructure spending to pump up the economy, and it helped a little. The golden age for American workers coincides with the Communist period in Russia. That's not coincidental. From the 1920s to the 1970s, capitalism had competition. There was real fear among capitalists that if capitalism didn't deliver the goods to workers, the workers would vote to socialize industries. Britain did that, with the government running the coal, steel, railroad, airline, electric power, and telecommunications industries. It wasn't an unreasonable fear. So the US had the New Deal under Roosevelt, and strong unions. After WWII, unions worked to keep wages high. There were explicit arrangements in the auto industry requiring wages to track productivity, so workers kept up. The auto and steel industries set the pattern for the rest of the economy. In the 1950s and 1960s, the USSR started to look like a serious economic competitor. The USSR built an atomic bomb, H-bombs, nuclear submarines, and a space program. Communism as a system looked like a threat. That ended in the early 1980s, as the USSR stopped believing in its own "workers paradise". With fear of competition gone, capitalism could take a much harder line on its workers. It took a while, but now employers can do pretty much anything they want to without fear of retribution.
- Tiksi 12y agoI'd say China and India today are just as big of a threat, if not bigger, as the USSR was. Why don't we see this same competition now? Is it because it's not sensationalized? Because no one takes it seriously for some reason this time around? I honestly don't know, but if what we need is a worthy competitor, there are two just waiting for a slip up. It seems especially dire when you consider that the western world's main export isn't a physical good, and it basically all hinges on the fact that the smart and able are allowed to succeed and produce "value", where as the smart and able in poorer countries don't have those opportunities. India and China make up half the world's population, an order of magnitude larger than the "western world", so I expect that they have far, far more able and smart people there just waiting to take the opportunity if it's given. I think that when (if?) those countries catch up to our "modern standard of living", they'll quickly leave us in the dust. At the same time I'm not sure it's quite as possible in such a connected world to have a competitor as isolated as the USSR was. The economy is far more global and intertwined than it was, maybe we'll all just boost the worldwide standard of living with cooperation instead of competition? I honestly don't know what's going to happen down the road (and hold no strong ideas of what might, all outcomes seem equally as likely/unlikely to me), and neither does anyone else, but I wouldn't be surprised if the world doesn't change all that much. Factories have closed down, jobs were lost, and people ended up in a different kind of factory, now sitting at a desk staring at a computer instead of a machine on an assembly line. Many people (here on HN especially) seem to think that jobs will disappear and not be replaced. In 1930, no one could have accurately predicted the world 100 years later. When machines started replacing factory workers, I doubt anyone would have expected us to all be staring at glorified tv screens and while banging away on our typewriters as a job, and that the some of the biggest companies around wouldn't actually sell anything physical, yet here we are. So who's to say that the next step is indeed something like basic income, instead of yet another version of the same factory? What if the next change in type of employment seems just as ridiculous and unimaginable today as today's world would to someone 100, even 50, years ago? Job Opening: Virtual Reality Tour Guide, must have at least 5 years experience in navigating WorldBook.com's(Facebook's VR world, launched 3 years ago) . Well this got really off topic towards the end.