11 ms·
Analysis of DNA uncovers a rough dating scene after the advent of agriculture
- Fuxy 12y agoMakes perfect sense to me. If you look at our culture now there is always that one male all the females in a group tend to go for. Same for males there's always that 1 mega hotie you want to meet. The only difference is even average females can have any guy they want while the same doesn't apply to guys. The advent of agriculture gave females the ability to support their children more easily without the help of males and the more desirable males could have more offspring with so much food available. Basically less females had to settle for second best to have offspring.
- tomp 12y ago> Same for males there's always that 1 mega hotie you want to meet. > The only difference is even average females can have any guy they want while the same doesn't apply to guys. I'd rather say that the major difference is that while there is no (or very little) opportunity cost for a male that mates with the top woman and the next 100 women as well, there is a big opportunity cost for a female regardless of which male she chooses, so she is much more motivated to choose the top male.
- Houshalter 12y agoRight. This is not a new theory. It's well known that evolution tends to favor polygamy where females are more selective and males are more promiscuous. What's interesting is that this apparently started after agriculture rather than before. I had previously thought that maybe hunter gatherers practiced polygamy but it faded away as we become more agricultural. Also 17 females to 1 male is pretty absurd. Even if you look at cultures that practiced polygamy in recent history it wasn't to that extent. And even when it was practiced, it wasn't necessarily common except in the very upper class, so the average female to male ratio would have been more reasonable. We can only speculate to what degree this might have shaped our (recent) evolution. That's a huge selective pressure on males to have traits that would lead to them being the local king or whatever they were. And everyone alive today would be descended from those people.
- ManFromUranus 12y ago>I had previously thought that maybe hunter gatherers practiced polygamy but it faded away as we become more agricultural. I would have thought otherwise, there is very little incentive for you to labour for the tribe if you have no skin in the game, so to speak. So they would give you a wife otherwise, why fight for them? Why hunt? Why do anything to benefit anyone other than yourself? Since you have nothing to lose, you can even steal from them since no one you care about suffers.
- MichaelGG 12y ago>lead to them being the local king or whatever they were Or lead them to "steal" secret reproductions? There's only "one" king, but there could be more than 1 "illegitimate" fathers.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> What's interesting is that this apparently started after agriculture rather than before. Well, the effects become much more pronounced after agriculture. > Also 17 females to 1 male is pretty absurd. Even if you look at cultures that practiced polygamy in recent history it wasn't to that extent. 17:1 ratio in females vs. males having descendant lines surviving to appear in modern DNA doesn't imply 17:1 female:male polygyny. Heck, the reverse (women having multiple partners, especially a higher-station one with better prospects for having offspring and having them succeed in youth and a lower-station one with worse prospects later, perhaps after the previous one died) could contribute to this, though polygyny is probably part of the explanation.
- brc 12y agoAgriculture created surplus which meant that someone could feed a larger family. If you are a hunter gatherer you need to be a very good one to support more than one wife, even if you are the chief. With surplus generated by agriculture, spare time can be spent innovating to increase the surplus. Inequal skills in building a personal surplus - whether by conquest, investment or thrift - means that some people get richer. Richer men gain power and are able to not only attract more females but rewrite the rules to make it so. A few generations of this and you change the population considerably.
- noiv 12y agoJust started reading Harari's brief history of humankind and this gem perfectly fits in the rather unsettling story of our genetic pool. It is no longer the natural environment setting the conditions for who's fit to survive/chosen for reproduction but the present human culture which in turn is just the result of the previous. If I had to choose an algorithm as an analogy, I'd say it is a recursion waiting for stack overflow. :)
- asdkl234890 12y agoWe are a very social species, the culture we create is our natural environment.
- Padding 12y agoWhat you're saying isn't wrong, but I doubt that societies where rulers have a monopoly on violence have existed long enough to have had an impact on evolution.
- ll123 12y agoThe invention of monogamy is what brought about the 4-5 female to male reproduction ratio.
- undersuit 12y agoWhat do you mean by that?
- ll123 12y agoUnder monogamy, women who previously would have become part of a powerful man's harem now reproduced with a man who previously would not have reproduced, therefore reducing the female/male reproduction ratio.
- dragonwriter 12y agoThere are a number of factors (particularly in premodern societies) that produce the imbalance, but polygyny particularly exacerbates the imbalance (and, from a pre-existing state of polygyny, then, monogamy reduces it) because polygyny means that the most successful males are each able, in their reproductive prime, to secure, with social support, exclusive reproductive access to multiple of the most desirable females, which increases the expected ratio of females successfully reproducing in that generation to the number of males successfully reproducing. (Because of the biology of reproduction, this would seem likely to be the case even if, in institutional terms, the practice of polygyny was balanced by equal practice of polyandry, but historically that wasn't the case anyway.)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jrells 12y agoFascinating stuff, I'd like to know more. Does anyone know a better source? I found the original article but sadly not freely available. This psmag.com article is thin and the graph of the data is so small I can't read much off of it. Google couldn't find any larger versions of the graph.
- josu 12y agoHere: http://genome.cshlp.org/content/early/2015/03/13/gr.186684.114/suppl/DC1 http://genome.cshlp.org/content/early/2015/03/13/gr.186684.1...
- rhema 12y agoThis is not my research area. However, I can't help but the results seem to radical to me. The dip in male diversity seems far too synchronized among so many different regions / cultures. Are there examples in recorded history of sudden reductions in male diversity that lasted for multiple generations?
- dalke 12y agohttp://blogs.discovermagazine.com/gnxp/2010/08/1-in-200-men-direct-descendants-of-genghis-khan/ http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/gnxp/2010/08/1-in-200-men-... : > ~10% of the men who reside within the borders of the Mongol Empire as it was at the death of Genghis Khan may carry his Y chromosome, and so ~0.5% of men in the world, about 16 million individuals alive today, do so. Since 2003 there have been other cases of “super-Y” lineages. For example the Manchu lineage and the Uí Néill lineage. The existence of these Y chromosomal lineages, which have burst upon the genetic landscape like explosive stars sweeping aside all other variation before them, indicates a periodic it “winner-take-all” dynamic in human genetics more reminiscent of hyper-polygynous mammals such as elephant seals. As we do not exhibit the sexual dimorphism which is the norm in such organisms, it goes to show the plasticity of outcome due to the flexibility of human cultural forms.
- JeffL 12y agoIf you guys are interested in this stuff, I highly recommend "The Red Queen" by Matt Ridley. http://amazon.com/Red-Queen-Evolution-Human-Nature/dp/0060556579/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1426700896 http://amazon.com/Red-Queen-Evolution-Human-Nature/dp/006055...
- ardit33 12y agoThis is a great passage from the Red Queen, that might explain what was happening at the time: In the ancient empire of the Incas, sex was a heavily regulated industry. The sun-king Atahualpa kept fifteen hundred women in each of many “houses of virgins” throughout his kingdom. They were selected for their beauty and were rarely chosen after the age of eight—to ensure their virginity. But they did not all remain virgins for long: They were the emperor’s concubines. Beneath him, each rank of society afforded a harem of a particular legal size. Great lords had harems of more than seven hundred women. “Principal persons” were allowed fifty women; leaders of vassal nations, thirty; heads of provinces of 100,000 people, twenty; leaders of 1,000 people, fifteen; administrators of 500 people, twelve; governors of 100 people, eight; petty chiefs over 50 men, seven; chiefs of 10 men, five; chiefs of 5 men, three. That left precious few for the average male Indian whose enforced near-celibacy must have driven him to desperate acts, a fact attested to by the severity of the penalties that followed any cuckolding of his seniors. If a man violated one of Atahualpa’s women, he, his wife, his children, his relatives, his servants, his fellow villagers, and all his lamas would be put to death, the village would be destroyed, and the site strewn with stones. As a result, Atahualpa and his nobles had, shall we say, a majority holding in the paternity of the next generation. They systematically dispossessed less privileged men of their genetic share of posterity. Many of the Inca people were the children of powerful men. In the kingdom of Dahomey in West Africa, all women were at the pleasure of the king. Thousands of them were kept in the royal harem for his use, and the remainder he suffered to “marry” the more favored of his subjects. The result was that Dahomean kings were very fecund, while ordinary Dahomean men were often celibate and barren. In the city of Abomey, according to one nineteenth-century visitor, “it would be difficult to find Dahomeans who were not descended from royalty.” The connection between sex and power is a long one.
- 12y ago
- seokranik 12y agoSince a lot of early civilizations seemed to be very slave heavy I wonder if that had anything to do with it. Agriculture requires more labour which leads to more slaving. Male slaves would work the fields with less of a chance for reproduction, and the landowners/slaveowners would have their pick of the female slaves.
- tormeh 12y agoVery good. That's probably an important factor.
- swagasaurus-rex 12y agoI've suspected as much would happen during the agricultural revolution, but I did not expect such a huge disparity. If the 51% male/female ratio did not change, then 16 out of 17 males must have either been killed, enslaved, or been left frustrated. This would imply a highly patriarchal society where the local king and his cronies are the only ones fed, and to whom you would sell your daughters to. The only other explanation would be mass infanticide of males, but to see this in multiple regions is suspect. "It wasn't like there was a mass death of males. They were there, so what were they doing?" The article raises a very good question. In all places studied, agriculture must have favored a highly stratified society.
- swagasaurus-rex 12y agoOne other hypothesis I can think of is the advent of barbarian warfare. Many parts of the old testament details how brutal life was, where various tribes are constantly at war and conquering other tribes. Even several generations of warfare, where each village sacked involved killing the men and abducting the women, would filter out y-chromosomes to see such a large disparity.
- bilbo0s 12y agoThis is the actual explanation. With one caveat... slavery. Basically, agriculture allowed people to specialize. This included specializing in killing. (Soldiers). You would use these specialists to conquer other lands. Which, in turn, provided slave labor to increase production in agriculture and other sectors. So the conquered females would be used as "rewards" for the conquerors. And the conquered males would be used to increase production across the conquering society via slave labor. So the explanation is pretty simple. In fact, the 17 to 1 figure is so low that I question whether they aren't missing something ??? Societies that developed later generally required enormous amounts of slave labor. That, coupled with the fact that there would have been an enormous amount of killing involved in taking the slaves in the first place, makes me wonder how the numbers turned out so evenhanded? I would have expected it to be an order of magnitude higher. But they did the study and have the data... so life must not have been quite as brutal as I thought it was. I suppose it is possible that life was brutal... and less desirable females simply may not have been taken? This happened a lot in our own history. Slave auction records show that some female slaves in America sold for as much as 100 times the rate of a "regular" female slave. (And even more in some private trades we have records for). We can speculate on why that may have been... but I think it's safe to assume that in a less sophisticated time they may have simply dispensed with females and males who were in some way undesirable, or were not likely to survive the journey back.
- ccvannorman 12y ago"somehow, only a few men accumulated lots of wealth and power, leaving nothing for others" Yeah, thank god we're past this as a species
- phkahler 12y agoI thought it had been observed with monkeys or apes that in times of scarcity they will share, but if you dump a whole truck load of bananas they will fight over them. The rise of agriculture would be a similar time of plenty which may be what triggered all the fighting and hoarding.
- andyl 12y agoMy 16 yr old is interested in pursuing this field (not sure what to call it - 'Genetic Anthropology'?). Can anyone recommend online resources to help a newbie get the lay of the land? Or in-person resources (talks, exhibits, clubs etc.) near Palo Alto CA ??
- CreRecombinase 12y agoI would say if Carlos Bustamante or Stephen Montgomery are ever giving a talk to the public to check them out. They're both based out of Stanford Med, but their research touches on tracing Human demographic history. If she's still interested when applying for colleges, Harvard and The University of Chicago should both be on her list.
- clarkm 12y agoYou should email Razib Khan at UC Davis. He's been blogging about this stuff for years. And just earlier today, the NYT announced that he's been brought on as one of their new opinion writers.
- sloreti 12y ago"In more recent history, as a global average, about four or five women reproduced for every one man" Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't this the same as saying one man, on average, will father a child with about four or five different women? I suppose given the timescale being discussed, "recent history" may mean the last few centuries, but this average still sounds very high to me.
- swagasaurus-rex 12y agoYeah, it isn't clear what timescale they are discussing, but the graphic suggests that a near 1/1 pairing is a very recent phenomenon.
- saalweachter 12y agoYou still get at least an element of this with pretty recent til-death-do-us-part versions of serial monogamy: Gauss, for instance, had two wives, marrying a friend of his first wife after she died, and had children with both of them. (I'd be surprised if serial monogamy alone were enough to get a 4:1 ratio, but you can definitely get > 1:1 ratios out of it.)
- steven777400 12y ago4 or 5 might be high, but it's still noticeable anecdotally (although more rigorous analysis would be interesting). My ex-wife and I have no children, but her current fiancee has children with his ex-wife (who has no other children), and she and him plan to have children together. My dad has children with his ex-wife (who has no children with other men) and current wife, but my mom (his current wife) has no children with her ex-husband. So in a very small anecdotal sample, men who have children may often have children with 2 (or more, presumably) women over a lifetime, even though at any given time, monogamy prevails.
- clay_to_n 12y agoUpon Googling, I think this comes from genetic analysis which suggests that people alive today have 4-5x as many female ancestors as male. I don't know if this statistic is actually limited by "recent history" or not.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Mikeb85 12y agoNot particularly surprising. In the ancient world, men were often killed in various ways (conflict, hunting accidents) or enslaved so the gender ratio was quite skewed. I mean, typical ancient warfare meant you attack a town, kill/enslave all the men and boys, rape all the women, and ensure your culture's dominance over them for the next generation or two...
- tormeh 12y agoI have a hunch that this ancient way of warfare is still the optimal way to destroy a culture and achieve total victory. Not that it's acceptable in any way, but imagine if the US had done this in Iraq and Afghanistan. It is heart-wrenching to think about, but I think it would have worked.
- swagasaurus-rex 12y agoThis is pretty much how Isis conducts their warfare.
- tormeh 12y agoOnly against non-muslims, as far as I've gathered. Most of the muslim world (as far as I've gathered) isn't particularly religious, just very socially conservative. So IS isn't employing this tactic to its full advantage here. Nor is it clear how they could, because as long as you go through all the motions it's hard to check whether you really have all that much religious fervour.
- def_illiterate 12y agoAn argument could probably be made that it worked fairly well in subduing East Germany after WWII.
- semi-extrinsic 12y agoNot sure why you were downvoted, this has been well-documented e.g. by Beevor.
- bengrunfeld 12y agoEunuch's and harems. The rich and powerful males kept all their local women in a harem and forced all the other competing males to become eunuchs. Not fun, but it fits with the Monty Python version of history.... ;)
- yuashizuki 12y agoIts the same even today.
- littletimmy 12y agoIt sounds like a persistent theme through history is that a very few people at the top had a Lot of power, and most men and all women were oppressed. Feminists, take note: men are not privileged. Just those who were privileged were men. The fight must be against the few at the top.
- victorhn 12y agoThere will be always a few at the top, hierarchies among humans will always exist due to natural differences.
- rockmeamedee 12y agoFirst: The fight _is_ against the top. 'The top', more precisely the structure that enables 'the top', is the patriarchy that feminist have always been fighting against. Second: Even thinking of it as 'the top', 'the few that get to have all the pro-creation' as another commenter wrote is bad. Because the 1700 concubines, they weren't treated fairly. They taken away from their parents at age 8, held captive for sex and raped if they didn't comply. Feminists are fighting for the women first. But the structure that enables this hurts everybody.
- MollyR 12y agoYea, I'm beginning to think the only real privilege is being born to a powerful and wealthy family.
- robbrown451 12y agoSounds to me like slavery. The women slaves had babies, the male slaves were workers and soldiers. In a way, it sort of sounds like a eusocial sort of society, like a bee colony (but with the male female roles reversed). One reproducing male, many reproducing females, many non-reproducing males.
- stillsut 12y agoIn populations studies at all scales, Adam is more recent than Eve. 10 years ago, I read it was Eve 120,000 years ago and Adam 60,000 years ago for the out of Africa theory.
- evv 12y agoWhat do Adam and Eve refer to in this context? Also, what do you mean by "more recent"?
- roywiggins 12y agoI assume: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitochondrial_Eve http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitochondrial_Eve
- StopWhining2 12y ago- Initial kings collect women like Pokemon. - No contraception. Much baby. - Many claims to throne in 18 years. - Claimants go to war with one another. Soldiers are invented, voluntary and noble at first. Religious later. Can't do mass conscription from the common man as he's working the essential farms. - Losers happen made. Slavery is invented. - Slaves work the mines and other harsh labor, allow for post-agrarian activities and advanced economies. - King sits back and lets the the whole clusterfuck evolve in his favor. A self-regulating male shortage. Easy peasy.
- AhrowTway 12y ago- Initial kings collect women like Pokemon. - No contraception. Much baby. - Many claims to throne in 14-18 years. - Claimants go to war with one another. Soldiers are invented, voluntary and noble at first. Religious later. Can't do mass conscription from the common man as he's working the essential farms. - Losers happen. Slavery is invented. - Slaves work the mines and other harsh labor, which allows for post-agrarian activities and advanced economies. - King sits back and lets the the whole clusterfuck evolve in his favor. A auto-catalytic male shortage. Easy peasy. Inadvertently, I have just Twitterized the Old Testament.
- deciplex 12y ago> Another member of the research team, a biological anthropologist, hypothesizes that somehow, only a few men accumulated lots of wealth and power, leaving nothing for others. This line cracked me up. Yes, "somehow" indeed. Quite a mystery we have on our hands here!