10 ms·
> Precisely because the industry is so highly regulated I don't see how Uber offers anything that I don't get with a regular taxi. This seems to be a common ar
by wyager 12y ago
> Precisely because the industry is so highly regulated I don't see how Uber offers anything that I don't get with a regular taxi.
This seems to be a common argument against private competition to government-managed services. "Well, I don't see how a private company could do this better than the government." And yet, Uber is so obviously superior to any regulated taxi service.
- detaro 12y agoWhat is "obviously superior" about Uber?
- Karunamon 12y ago* A median 2 minute pickup time * Knowing where your driver is and how close, who they are, what they're driving, and what their ratings are before you even climb in. * Payment is all handled on the back end. You call the cab and don't have to worry about it. Tips are not a thing. * Bad ratings cause drivers to get kicked out of the program - and since they're automatically prompted for as soon as you get out of the car, they're going to be done more often (and therefore be more accurate) than a complaint-based model. It solves the problem of "Well, this driver was surly and slow, but I've got better things to do than go on the taxi commission's website and fill out a complaint form" * MUCH cheaper rates than taxis, though that no doubt varies by area. I know in SF, it only cost me $15 to get from SFO to the wharf. (About an hour drive, IIRC) Equivalent shuttle: $34-50. I priced it. * Random everypeople drivers, rather than career folks. I've met some pretty interesting people via Uber. * Drivers can't arrive and then refuse to drive you - they know where they're going when the app pings them. If they don't want to drive you, one of the others surely will. Drivers are penalized for dropping rides. None of this is specific to Germany, the topic of the story notwithstanding. These rideshare outfits face the same government interference in every single country they operate in. After tooling around California for about a week or so, I am 100% on board with these guys. Uber was consistently awesome and less expensive, taxis were consistently more annoying and more expensive.
- detaro 12y agopickup time: nice, but I assume that also only is in saturated areas Prices as far as I've seen were similar to Taxi prices. Payment: just checked, I thought the current apps already took care of that, but didn't seem so. Not yet that big of a problem, since Germany is still very cash-based anyways. I have to admit I don't really care about the other points, since the current state of things seems mostly fine to me. So for me it is not "obviously superior", since I value the downsides higher (insurance, availability (a german taxi can't deny a route inside it's area of responsibility, which is a large part of why competition is restricted), ...) //Edit: extended some points, spelling/grammar
- ptaipale 12y agoOne problem with German taxis is that they often don't accept credit card. So you need cash. If Uber isn't changing that, then it's not helping either.
- darklajid 12y ago'Problem'? As the GP points out, cash is still very common here. A _large_ supermarket over here (Kaufland) doesn't accept CCs, but does accept direct debit. Listing 'accepting CCs' as a bonus for Uber seems.. weird in this environment.
- pgeorgi 12y agoTo add: few supermarkets accept credit cards. Neither does the public railway for short distance travel. Or pretty much anybody else. Might be because we were able to keep the middle man (CC companies) out by having the banks cooperate on electronic cash directly - since the 80s. Uber is just another such middle man we have no need for (and at 20% commission, they make CC companies look cheap).
- ptaipale 12y agoJust to clarify, I said "credit card" for simplicity but I use my card primarily as a direct-debit card; taxis (and everyone else) accept that here, and have been since 1980's. So the credit card company is not involved.
- anon1385 12y ago>Uber is so obviously superior to any regulated taxi service. Please do tell us how a taxi service with uninsured drivers is superior.
- reasonish 12y agoIt's cheaper. Until something horrible happens or goes wrong. It's exactly the same as airBnB. There's a reason these things are properly regulated.
- toyg 12y agoIn a way, services like AirBnB and Uber remind us of how very rarely things actually go wrong. In a way, they act as correction to the usual scaremongering we get through most mass-media: "you can ride in uninsured cabs with complete strangers and sleep in unregulated and potentially dangerous flats, and you'll likely be fine anyway". This said, good on the German government for forcing the company to actually respect their laws. Being a trendy net-based startup is not a license to flaunt all rules, especially consistent rules that exist for very good reason.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoInsurance isn't there because you have a good chance of having something bad happen to you. It's there because bad things happen predictably and often, and victims of those would have serious problems for the rest of their lives if not for insurance.
- Tomte 12y agoOne thing most commentators cannot seem to grasp: the German government hasn't applied for the injunction, and it isn't running the taxi service. Government regulates private companies running the service. And those private companies are standing up to a shitty company that openly says that they won't comply with laws or verdicts, because they are the future. Or something like that.
- wyager 12y agoIn every way. Have you ever used Uber? The whole experience is so nice compared to the low-quality/bad-service experience typical of a government-approved taxi. I'm not introspective enough to enumerate every single reason I love Uber, but here are a few: It's cheaper. It's faster in less densely populated areas. The service is better and the drivers are friendlier. The cars are nicer.