3 ms·
The one which had me sad recently is the soundtrack to the game Bastion: http://supergiantgames.bandcamp.com/album/bastion-original-soundtrack http://supergiant
by mikepurvis 12y ago
The one which had me sad recently is the soundtrack to the game Bastion: http://supergiantgames.bandcamp.com/album/bastion-original-soundtrack http://supergiantgames.bandcamp.com/album/bastion-original-s...
It's noticeable on almost every track basically as soon as the drums kick in. (About ten seconds into "A Proper Story", for example). It's depressing that this has occurred even on a piece of indie content for which so much care has otherwise been taken— Darren Korb was the sound designer for the game and gave a terrific presentation at GDC 2012.
- JoelHobson 12y agoI always thought that drum sound was on purpose. I kind of liked the way it sounded.
- rinon 12y agoYeah, I'm fairly sure this was entirely intentional. Fits the futuristic western sounds nicely.
- mmarx 12y agoIt also fits quite well with where those tracks typically play during the game.
- mikepurvis 12y agoIntentional or otherwise, the waveform certainly clips— you can see it in any audio editor, eg: http://imgur.com/a/WacOy http://imgur.com/a/WacOy Since the drums sounds all started life as hi-fi samples, the detail is certainly there in the original Logic sessions. It would be an interesting experiment to do a listening test comparing the CD versions of the tracks against versions mastered with more headroom, either less loudly or to a 64-bit format. It may well be that a certain degree of the grunge is artistic versus technical, but I suspect that in a blind test I would still prefer a version with slightly less muddy drums.