3 ms·
The reason people keep talking about those incidents is that a lot of people defend that behaviour (see other posts in this thread) or even promote it as the be
by anon1385 12y ago
The reason people keep talking about those incidents is that a lot of people defend that behaviour (see other posts in this thread) or even promote it as the best way to manage a project and deal with 'inferior' programmers.
If everybody was just saying that those were unfortunate incidents where he lost his temper and agreed they were inappropriate then this debate wouldn't keep happening. Some people aren't prepared to admit that Linus is ever at fault in any way during these episodes. There is even a group of people who think that those episodes are examples of 'telling it like it is' and 'sticking it to the PC crowd' and thus should be replicated as much as possible to make sure your project isn't 'swamped by idiots'. Unfortunately some of the people with that attitude maintain open source projects (and have downvote powers on HN).
I have found buffer overflow bugs in widely used open source projects that I have not informed the developers about, because when I've made previous bug reports they acted like assholes. I don't feel inclined to open myself up for public humiliation just to contribute to their project.
- raverbashing 12y ago> and deal with 'inferior' programmers. Except the people he usually deals with in a harsh manner are not inferior, rather, from the examples, it is usually the top collaborators > I have found buffer overflow bugs in widely used open source projects that I have not informed the developers about, because when I've made previous bug reports they acted like assholes I understand, but did you follow the bug reporting procedure? Also, some projects may act polite towards outsiders then direct criticism (and bugs) to /dev/null
- vidarh 12y agoWe defend that behaviour because this debate keeps happening and people keep blowing his (few) outbursts way out of proportion. I don't think it's the best way to manage anything, but I also don't think these outbursts are a big deal.