4 ms·
> And I'm of the opinion that an attitude and approach like Linus' is fine - if you're Linus. I'm of the opinion that it's not. And, it provides a really poor
by bsder 12y ago
> And I'm of the opinion that an attitude and approach like Linus' is fine - if you're Linus.
I'm of the opinion that it's not. And, it provides a really poor example to the younger people in the field.
I've known a lot of programmers. Many of them far smarter than Linus. Funnily enough, the better they were; the nicer they were.
- EpicEng 12y agoI don't think you know anything about Linus beyond his widely publicized outbursts (Which also means you have no idea how smart, or not, he is).
- moomin 12y agoOMG is he a 10x engineer? 11??? Seriously, there's no productivity benchmark beyond which you shouldn't treat people with respect. There are broken cultures where you can get away with it, but you'll still be an asshole. Linus is an asshole not because it's some deep essential part of his nature, he's an asshole because people give him a free pass.
- pyre 12y agoParent post was asking whether your knowledge of how much of an "asshole" Linus is comes from only reading the publicized outbursts, and not interacting on a day to day basis. While it's not preferable, I think that we can be understanding of the fact that people can sometimes have outbursts due to stressors in their life. That said, whenever I've seen people bashing a Linus outburst, I've gone and read said outburst. It's never as bad as the "tech press" make it out to be.
- anon1385 12y ago>While it's not preferable, I think that we can be understanding of the fact that people can sometimes have outbursts due to stressors in their life. Sure. The question is, do the rest of us treat those incidents as mistakes where somebody went over the line and behaved poorly, or do we defend the behaviour and even try to argue that it's a sign of good project management that should be emulated because it 'tells it like it is' and keeps away the 'idiots'? Sadly the latter is a common attitude, as seen in other comments in this thread.
- raverbashing 12y agoI'm not sure, but given his cultural background, I'd say he's less of an asshole than most people think he is. The level of rudeness in conversation is very dependent on cultural background and those ignoring it display cultural insensitiveness Europeans are more straightforward than Canadians and Indians where everything is said in a mild passive-aggressive tone that goes nowhere.
- wutbrodo 12y agoI understand and have experienced what you're talking about, but I don't think it gets to the meat of what people dislike about the way Linus (occasionally) communicates with people. Being more straightforward as in "no that's a dumb idea because X" may put people off, but can be chalked up to "cultural differences in communication". This doesn't really apply to the kinda stuff Linus has said that people complain about: "Mauro SHUT THE FUCK UP" "I don't _ever_ want to hear that kind of obvious garbage and idiocy from a kernel maintainer again. " "fix your approach to kernel programming." "There aren't enough swear-words in the English language, so now I'll have to call you perkeleen vittupää just to express my disgust and frustration with this crap." It's ridiculous to claim that that's just avoiding unnecessary civility. Those statements aren't "blunt", they're just him being a dick.
- raverbashing 12y agoWhile they are blunt and I don't disagree about "him being a dick" written communication is very different from spoken ones, I can imagine someone using such words in a certain context and they sound less harsh. But in the written medium it really come across is the most harsh way. But while maintaining the kernel sometimes he needs to get the point across and saying "this is unacceptable, I am disappointed" will not work. For those examples, when reading the context I (usually) agree with Linus (and with his attitude), and this usually happens when the situation has been building up and people keep repeating those mistakes. Also, there are people much worse than Linus on the LKML (and subsystem lists), also some people are very polite and helpful.
- icebraining 12y ago
- ncza 12y agoI think you should treat Linus with more respect.
- agumonkey 12y agoIt's also a mass communication strategy. Concise and harsh. No time wasted.
- wvh 12y agoLinus has a sense of humour that is often misunderstood, especially by the PC crowd. Abrasiveness is an innate Finnish quality. Just think you're in a Monty Python sketch.
- topynate 12y agoWhat are you proposing? Because if it involves preventing him posting to mailing lists or restricting his contributions to kernel development I'm against, and on pretty fundamental ethical principles: you appear to think there's a deontological injunction against permitting someone to do harm by disrespecting others, whereas I think that harm should be weighed against the benefits that would be lost thereby. I also think that your opinion on why Linus behaves as he does is wishful thinking, sorry. There's a decent chance he'd take his ball and go home if the above were done. That would be bad.
- venomsnake 12y agoLinus is nice ... I have not seen him being jerk just for jerkness. But if you cannot take having a new one teared when you do something stupid - you are in the wrong field. Bullshit, stupidity and thin-skinniness should not be tolerated.
- toothbrush 12y agoJust my €0.02, but i think it's precisely the "new ones" that should be treated carefully. The kernel (or whatever other FOSS project) won't develop itself, so it's purely economically bad strategy to scare off newcomers who might well turn out to be very talented devs. Aside from the economics, it's also simple civility to not shout at people if (you believe) they're idiots.
- the_af 12y agoI agree with you about treating newcomers nicely, but do note "having a new one teared" is an expression that doesn't refer to new people :)
- toothbrush 12y agoRight, i totally didn't parse that sentence correctly on account of not being familiar with the (arguably distasteful) idiom. Thanks for the clarification, though.
- krylon 12y agoLet me first point out that pretty much every single programmer I have met in person has been pretty easy to get along with, and that I try myself to be as accomodating and friendly to other people as I can. (My day job as a sysadmin includes what is essentially helpdesk work, so this attitude comes in rather handy.) But it seems there is a kind of tradition among hackers of people that are exceedingly smart but also jerks. They get away with it if they are sufficiently smart, because many hackers tend to value a certain kind of cleverness above most other things. And honestly, I would rather deal with a smart jerk, as long as he/she was not trying to feed me bullshit than a friendly but ignorant buzzword-slinger. Having said that, let me repeat that I would prefer a friendly smart guy over both of these extremes, and so far, I have been lucky.