4 ms·
> and orders to restaurants not to serve water to customers unless asked. And in one small sentence all the problems are laid bare. This? This is their solutio
by ars 12y ago
> and orders to restaurants not to serve water to customers unless asked.
And in one small sentence all the problems are laid bare. This? This is their solution to drought? Not serving a cup of water in a restaurant?
Can politicians really be that stupid? Or is this "we have to do something, anything, never mind if it's actually useful"?
If they feel the need to actually do something, then fund a massive leak detection and fixing program.
Or install mater meters and bill on an exponential scale based on number of people in the house and expected usage.
Or shut down any industry that uses a lot of water (and rehire the people for the water leak program).
Or fix all the well documented water waste for farming.
Or copy some techniques from middle eastern nations on how to farm with less water.
But no, they instead chose to not serve water in a restaurant.
- electic 12y agoThese are all great ideas and should be implemented. But also keep in mind that every bit helps. There are a lot of restaurants in CA and it all adds up.
- BurningFrog 12y agoThis is Hacker News, and any hacker needs to know that it's pointless to waste effort on optimizing things that already are a microscopic cost. It does NOT add up to anything useful, and it wastes time and focus to do. 80/20 rule, people!
- x0x0 12y agoYeah, but we're quibbling about a fraction of a percent going to drinking water in restaurants while 1 - the lawns in ruby hills and atherton are still green; 2 - agriculture -- and my problem here is profligate doesn't begin to describe how they use water; wantonly wastes is not even accurate -- is, collectively, delusional. CA grows rice. In desert. Rice is the most water intensive crop in the world. CA grows almonds, which use 1.1 gallons of water per almond. We grow alfalfa. We grow cotton. Etc etc. Farmers have giant sprinklers running in 90+F weather in near zero humidity at 1pm in the afternoon. CA needs to have a serious discussion about what crops should be grown here, and that probably ends with both adding at least 2 if not 4 zeros to the water price paid by agriculture, and not permitting the growth of the most water intensive crops. That's not to say cities are blameless; Sacramento doesn't even meter water. They hope to do so by 2025. Oh, and (imo) the worries about food are overblown. We export lots of those food crops, and people can live without almonds. (a quick google claims 10% of the state's water use is for almonds!!! [1]) I love almonds, but we will survive without them. Here's a quote About 70 percent of alfalfa grown in California is used in dairies, and a good portion of the rest is exported to land-poor Asian countries like Japan. Yep, that’s right: In the middle of a drought, farmers are shipping fresh hay across the Pacific Ocean. The water that’s locked up in exported hay amounts to about 100 billion gallons per year—enough to supply 1 million families with drinking water for a year. [1] In the midst of a severe drought, there is zero reason to permit export of incredibly water intensive crops. [1] http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2014/05/_10_percent_of_california_s_water_goes_to_almond_farming.html http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2014/0...
- ihaveajob 12y agoAll great points. What baffles me is that in Spain, the world's second largest almond producer, almond trees are largely not watered. I suppose production suffers, but still...
- latch 12y agoAccording to Wiki, the US gets 10x+ the almond yield by weight per hectare versus Spain. (Not saying it justifies the use of water, just providing the numbers).
- dllthomas 12y agoSpain also has nearly 2x the average rainfall of California. Rainfall in California is also mostly concentrated in places where we're not growing almonds - I don't know if that's true of Spain.
- DannyBee 12y ago"1 - the lawns in ruby hills and atherton are still green; " These lawns are 50% of urban use, which is 10% of total water use. While it is not a great sign of conservation efforts, The problem is that by pretending that it's a real problem, we keep avoiding the real problem - our agriculture is simply unsustainable in it's current form. IE it enables people and politicians to avoid the real problem, by selling a line to people that it's their non-conserving neighbors that are the problem, when it simply isn't. California needs to have a long and hard discussion about what should be happening in agriculture. Not a long and hard discussion about lawns in atherton. The oft-repeated "well, it helps people understand they need to conserve" is clearly false. It not only doesn't do that (hasn't for years!), it enables a smoke screen over the real issue. Now, instead of hearing on the radio that "politicians are seriously considering what to do about our agriculture issues", i hear, "politicians have enacted lawn watering restrictions to help ease the drought". That's what focusing, at all, on urban usage, does.
- x0x0 12y ago
- tlrobinson 12y agoLet's do some math. USGS says California consumes about 38 billion gallons of water per day [1]. Coincidentally, there are about 38 million residents of California. That's 1,000 gallons per capita per day. Even if every single resident dined at a restaurant every single day, and was served a glass of water, and they didn't drink it, that would be 1/16,000th of the water consumed for that resident for that day. [1] http://www.usgs.gov/newsroom/article.asp?ID=3977#.VQkNfxDF-L4 http://www.usgs.gov/newsroom/article.asp?ID=3977#.VQkNfxDF-L...
- fletchowns 12y agoCalifornia feeds a lot more than just its own residents with all that agriculture production. Pretty sure we produce more than the next 2 states combined.
- tlrobinson 12y agoYes, but that doesn't change the fact that not serving water at restaurants will reduce water consumption by less than 1/16000th.
- dasil003 12y agoIt's still worth doing from an awareness standpoint. Everyone in California needs to internalize the scarcity of water, and this is a reasonably effective way to do so. It is no harm to anyone to have to ask for water.
- mapt 12y agoWhat is the goal of internalizing it? What is the goal of personal responsibility here? There are fantastically profitable cash crops that the Central Valley is rapidly desertifying itself to produce, because that is what the regulatory framework incentivizes. They will do this regardless of whether half of LA feels shame about how long they spend in the shower. These things are ridiculous debacles that connect the well-meaning with the entrenched money to completely avoid the real issues. They're an attempt to get some people who don't use much water to point the finger at other people who don't use much water, and have a bitter culture war about it, and distract from the few people using most of the water. Water could and should be put into easy sustainability range by pricing it in accordance with how bad the local situation (reservoirs or water tables) has gotten. Instead it's doled out as a strange mix of feudal fiefdom and public service. And that includes pumping groundwater - which seems to be completely unregulated and unmonitored at present. California's problem is that it hasn't brought itself to manage water effectively, and it has erected obstacles to doing so during eras when water was neither heavily used nor well-understood. https://www.c-win.org/water-rights-primer.html https://www.c-win.org/water-rights-primer.html
- BurningFrog 12y agoPeople can be counted on to vastly overestimate the importance of things they can see, and most of all touch! This is why shopping bags, coffee mugs and water bottles get so much attention, while out of sight environmental problems many orders of magnitudes bigger are ignored.
- tzs 12y agoI'd expect it to actually be useful, because it is something people directly notice. When someone is thinking about or starting to do something that will waste water, I think they will be more likely to remember the drought and think about their actions if they have recently been inconvenienced in a restaurant by this ban than if they have only encountered the drought as something on the news.
- sfeng 12y ago80% of the water use in California is agricultural.
- fletchowns 12y agoYou say that like we can magically stop using water for agriculture production and divert it all to residential use and there will be no consequences. California produces a staggering amount of food, there would be a lot of consequences if agriculture production is disrupted. We need conservation efforts on both sides.
- DannyBee 12y agoNobody is suggesting we stop (yet). But uh, how about instead of trying for "the absolute most lucrative crop that happens to use 10x as much water as the next most lucrative crop", we say that this 10x isn't worth it. Here's california 2008 GDP broken down by sector: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/31/Gross_Domestic_Product_of_California_2008_%28millions_of_current_dollars%29.svg/690px-Gross_Domestic_Product_of_California_2008_%28millions_of_current_dollars%29.svg.png http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/31/Gro... (The data is similar for newer years). So 2% of our economy is using 80% of our water. This seems like a bad tradeoff, even if it meant a 30% increase in food prices or whatever. (Since california exports the vast majority of it's agriculture, this isn't likely)
- dllthomas 12y ago"So 2% of our economy is using 80% of our water. This seems like a bad tradeoff [..]" I don't think this comparison is actually terribly meaningful. Most of California industry just doesn't have much use for much water. The tradeoffs aren't so much with the next industry over (yet, or for a while) but with future years and with local ecologies. The 80% figure alone means it's probably where we need to be looking in terms of improving efficiencies, whether it was 1% or 20% or 90% of our economy. Certainly, we need to start actually charging appropriate amounts for water (including depletion of groundwater) so that people will find those efficiencies. But I'm not so sure that 80% number will change.
- rosser 12y agoYes, the actual savings of water from restaurants only serving on request is negligible. But it reminds people we're in a fucking drought. Maybe — just maybe — that awareness goes home with them, and they don't run the tap while brushing their teeth before bed that night. Or they take a 3 minute shower instead of a 10 minute one the next morning. Yes, these things are all token by themselves, and yes, residential use is utterly dwarfed by agricultural use, but every damn bit helps.
- tomjen3 12y agoOr more likely people get pissed at the restaurant for trying to cheat them.
- rosser 12y agoHow exactly am I being cheated by having to ask for water?
- wdr1 12y agoThose things aren't the problem. 80% of the water use in California is agricultural. If not serving water helped people think "hey! this land isn't sustainable on its own!" then maybe it would do something. But the other stuff is just theatre so politicians look like they're doing something.
- ars 12y agoThere are much much better ways to remind people. And how many people (as a percent of population) go to sit-down restaurants anyway? And even those that go will have a waiter ask: Would you like some water? And that's about the extent of it. It's not going to remind anyone of anything.
- DannyBee 12y ago"Yes, the actual savings of water from restaurants only serving on request is negligible. But it reminds people we're in a fucking drought. Maybe — just maybe — that awareness goes home with them, and they don't run the tap while brushing their teeth before bed that night. Or they take a 3 minute shower instead of a 10 minute one the next morning. " Which in turn does literally nothing to help. If you were to take all urban water use in california to 0, we'd run out of water in 10% longer a time period. So instead of a year, a year and a month. Of the 10% of total water used by urban folks, 53% goes to landscaping. So uh, killing all the sprinklers wouldn't even buy you an extra month if you were going to run out of water in a year. (there are other issues, like most homes in sacramento not having water meters until recently, and in fact, the state has only mandated that water meters exist everywhere by 2025, but ...) But sitting around pretending that conservation by urban people is going to make any difference in this drought, is just a silly game politicians are playing because most people don't understand where the water is going. Meanwhile, we keep paying taxes to build tunnels to divert more water to unsustainable agricultural use.