4 ms·
>One way to think of affirmative action is that it says "people from this group, on average, will score k points lower not because of a lack of ability or intel
by tsotha 12y ago
>One way to think of affirmative action is that it says "people from this group, on average, will score k points lower not because of a lack of ability or intelligence, but because of a lack of opportunities earlier in life due to social inequalities"...
Which is why the people actually helped by affirmative action tend to be middle class people from favored ethnic groups who had opportunities.
"Affirmative action" is a terribly divisive, blunt tool which creates more injustice than it remedies. The idea a poor white guy from a broken home in Appalachia is somehow starting out behind a middle class black girl with an intact family in Southern California is laughable.
- learc83 12y agoI've always thought if you were going to have any kind of affirmative action, it should be class/income based rather than race and gender based. Sure the most powerful people in the world are usually white men, but as you said that doesn't really mean much to the average poor rural white kid. Also income is also highly correlated with race, so disadvantaged minorities would benefit disproportionately anyway.