3 ms·
She needs to find another way to redress her greivance: she pretty clearly, by law and custom, does not hold copyright to the film. This isn't "throwing her un
by bediger4000 12y ago
She needs to find another way to redress her greivance: she pretty clearly, by law and custom, does not hold copyright to the film.
This isn't "throwing her under the bus", this is her asking for something for the wrong reasons. No need to futher pervert copyright just to cover a single odd case.
- anigbrowl 12y agoShe didn't claim copyright in the film. Read the decision; the opinion was written by Judge Kozinski, who is one of the brightest minds on the bench. https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=752615380456801846&hl=en&as_sdt=6&as_vis=1&oi=scholarr https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=752615380456801... Incidentally, Judge Smith makes cogent points in his dissent, but I'm a bit tired to go addressing them in detail now. In a nutshell, my take on it is this: Garcia has a copyright interest in her performance by default; she assigned that interest as part of her agreement with the film's producers; that agreement is pendant on a mutual understanding about the nature and general content of the film, and in the case of Innocence of Muslims the misrepresentation by the producers was so blatant as to be fraudulent, invalidating the contractual relationship the agreement was intended to establish, and voiding the assignment of Garcia's copyright interest, which must be presumed to have reverted to Garcia in the absence of evidence to the contrary.