2 ms·
I think it's more like IPsec hasn't happened because it's a huge hairball of complexity which requires kernel-level configuration on every client and full end-t
by acdha 12y ago
I think it's more like IPsec hasn't happened because it's a huge hairball of complexity which requires kernel-level configuration on every client and full end-to-end support for two new IP protocols and a UDP key management service.
In contrast, TLS requires using a new client library and works just about everywhere. All of the work people have been doing to switch to strong crypto everywhere and deploy things like perfect-forward security? Imagine how quickly that'd have happened if it required everyone to install a kernel update.
Until IPsec becomes easier to use (something as simple as checking that a socket is actually secure used to be shamefully under-documented) the best way to think of it is as a potential replacement for proprietary VPN protocols. Anything which cares about security will still need TLS over that so most people will simply use only TLS.